5 ms·
I wish everyone in the world spoke one language. English is my preference - but only because I already speak it (I fully recognize it is a terrible choice). I
by bluGill 5y ago
I wish everyone in the world spoke one language. English is my preference - but only because I already speak it (I fully recognize it is a terrible choice). It is very bad for the world that there are people who cannot communicate. So many lost opportunities (both business and social) just because two people can't have a conversation.
Learning a new language is hard. The hardest thing most adults attempt in their lifetime and most fail. (Learning quantum physics would be harder, but few adults attempt that). I have no delusions that we will ever settle on a common language, but I still wish it could happen.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI'd love a single global language too. > (Learning quantum physics would be harder, but few adults attempt that) I'm not sure if quantum physics really is harder. Learning a new language requires tremendous amount of work over many years (and a lot of that work happens naturally, as people are making use of the new language skills) - I feel very few people ever expended a comparable amount of effort into learning quantum physics, so we don't have a good baseline to compare.
- whomstve 5y agoAnd I wish for the complete opposite. When I go to Finland, I want to hear Finnish, read Finnish, and eat Finnish. I don't want to go to a place where kids speak, write, and think exactly like the kids from the school down the road here in North America. I don't want to travel 8000km to hear and see the same things as I have for my whole life. There's nothing more depressing to me than a world where everything is the same and where there is no friction between anything.
- lostmsu 5y agoThat's a false dichotomy. Same language does not imply same everything else.
- bluGill 5y agoWhen I go to Finland I want to understand and be understood. When I go to Spain I want to understand and be understood. When I go to - any of the 100+ other countries in the world (most with more than one language) - the same, I want to understand and be understood. If this was just about Finland I would learn their language (or just not go there in my lifetime), but this is about the 3000 other languages spoken in the world as well, and nobody has time to learn them all. If I want to read I'll go to my local library and request a book. Unless you mean streets signs - but there again not enough time.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWell the future will be ‘interesting’ if it is all approximately the same culture. Then the only reason to travel would be to look at different earth formations and buildings, and experience different weather?.
- bluGill 5y agoLanguage isn't barely even a part of culture. Sure cultures have a language, but that is just to communicate, culture is how the people live their life.
- int_19h 5y agoPeople can speak more than one language, though. It would be great if we had one that was truly universal to encourage communication and sharing of information, while retaining all the existing languages for colloquial use and arts.
- sterlind 5y agoretaining the existing languages is hard. loan words will come in wholesale from English, there's no real incentive to keep speaking when you could be practicing your English skills, the native language will be associated with being uneducated, etc. Navajo is maybe the best example of a language that's been kept up for cultural reasons, and it tends not to assimilate loanwords, but thousands more languages are dying or extinct.
- int_19h 5y agoLiving people aren't some kind of exhibits in a museum. If they don't want to retain their existing language as living, they shouldn't be forced to - just as they shouldn't be forced to drop it. Same thing with language purity. Loanwords etc are a natural part of language evolution. It's up to the community speaking the language to incorporate more loanwords - or not - as they speak it.
- ploika 5y agoThat's too simplistic. It's very hard to keep minority languages alive, even if you really desperately want to, when you're immersed in a majority language. The Irish language is in danger even in the Gaeltacht areas where native Irish speakers live, because English is everywhere. Tech is almost exclusively English, most jobs are English-only, most media is in English (not to mention ads on YouTube), most news and politics happens in English (the primary sources at least), all the packaging on everything you buy is in English, it's much easier to find a solicitor who speaks English-legalese than Irish-dlítheanga, your kids pick up English from TV and life. Before you know it, you and many of your acquaintances are a bit rusty, and conversations happen in English more and more. The language declines, and it's not what you wanted.
- valdiorn 5y agoUnfortunately English is an objectively terrible language. It's very non-deterministic, and there's a lot of nuisance that you won't pick up for years or decades as a non-native speaker. There's also zero consensus on how to pronounce and even spell things, it's a very fragmented language. Even native english speakers from the US can't pronounce most English placenames. Heck, not even English people can pronounce their placenames. (and yes I know, those placenames have french/nordic/germanic/roman origins, but placenames do become part of the language over time). Other words change pronunciation without changing meaning (this one really annoys me). think of "to perspire" and "anti-perspirant". Why is the "perspire" pronounced so differently in those two words, despite referring to the same thing? Same with "vital" and "vitamins" (in UK english). The english pronounce it vit-a-minns, despite the origin of the word being "vital amines". Americans mostly do it the right way ("white-a-minns"). C or K or S? V or W or U? They're the same, but also different letters, except sometimes you pronounce them different? Forget it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti You can also basically pronounce vowels however you want. My favourite example (although a bit exaggerated) is that south african speakers only have one wovel sounds, which is "iiih". "I'm Sid Ifrikin" is how they pronounce "I'm South African" :) Difference in vowel pronounciation is the primary differentiator of different accents, but since we need to understand all these different accents and they all convey the same information, that means vowels carry essentially no information in them. "Do you like dags?" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQSnua3M2lo&t=56s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQSnua3M2lo&t=56s My point is; the written word does not convey how to pronounce the word.
- bluGill 5y agoI fully agree, English is a terrible language for the reasons you name (and a far longer list that you didn't). It is what we have though, nothing else currently dominates world commerce at this time.
- pirate787 5y agoI'd observe that the fracturing of spoken English across the global empire isn't really the language's fault, but more of a function of time and space. Also modern communications are reducing regional differences in spoken English.
- SamTwardowski 5y agoTruly a wicked vision for the world: A global monoculture where this week's fashionable nonsense is the rule in all corners of the Earth with no escape, no interesting alternative - the English language being the perfect vector for every social pathology and every intellectual disease. But it would be a simpler world for our bureaucrats and administrators to manage....