4 ms·
> Baseload should be handled by nuclear. Nuclear is already a bad idea under normal circumstances, given that no country has a long-term solution for dealing w
by mschuster91 5y ago
> Baseload should be handled by nuclear.
Nuclear is already a bad idea under normal circumstances, given that no country has a long-term solution for dealing with the waste, molten-salt reactors are vaporware (usually because it turns out molten salts are highly aggressive) and fusion has been "it's ready in a decade!!!" for like, what, half a century now. And that doesn't even take stuff like "who, other than the taxpayer, will foot the bill for tearing the reactors down" or "who, other than the taxpayer, picks up the tab in the case of an accident" and other financial questions. Nuclear is only "cheaper" because these side effects get conveniently ignored!
But it is an especially dumb idea in California with its earthquake fault lines. Have two large reactor accidents not proven by now that nuclear fission is extremely unsafe?
- op00to 5y agoHow many deaths from nuclear accidents? How many deaths from cancer, lung disease, heart disease from pollution from fossil fuel?
- evgen 5y agoSolar has killed more people in California than nuclear energy.
- mschuster91 5y agoWe need to get away from both fossil and nuclear fuels as soon as possible, neither is acceptable any more. The solutions are pretty clear: solar, wind, tidal/other water potential energy, battery backed storage and gas peaker plants (as these can be retrofitted to burn synthetic gas and are the cleanest technology of fossil energy that we have). And especially: a grid that has enough capacity to distribute power across continents.
- sasfasaf 5y ago" a grid that has enough capacity to distribute power across continents." That's easy to write, but very hard to envision the scale. The grid transports very small fraction of the consumed power over large distances, most of the power gets consumed along the way. But what you are proposing involves transmitting all the power that a far away community consumes several time zones away
- mschuster91 5y ago> That's easy to write, but very hard to envision the scale. We have this in Europe ffs. Almost all of Europe, parts of Asia (Turkey) and North Africa (Morocco, Algeria, Tunesia) run in a synchronized-phase grid, and we have interconnection links to the insular ones (UK, Nordic countries, and a small one tying us to Russia). The entire former Soviet Union runs on a synchronized-phase grid. America is the only developed country / large geographic area that does not run a single synchronized-phase grid. > most of the power gets consumed along the way Nope. Germany averages about 6% of transmission loss ("Netzverluste"): https://www.destatis.de/DE/Themen/Branchen-Unternehmen/Energie/Erzeugung/Tabellen/bilanz-elektrizitaetsversorgung.html https://www.destatis.de/DE/Themen/Branchen-Unternehmen/Energ...
- sasfasaf 5y agoSorry let me re-phrase "Nope. Germany averages about 6% of transmission loss" I wasn't referring to ohmic losses, or transmission losses. I was referring to consumed along the way. The power generated in Vladivostok doesn't reach Germany not because the line losses are real, but because there'a country of 150 million inbetween. "We have this in Europe ffs. Almost all of Europe, parts of Asia (Turkey) and North Africa (Morocco, Algeria, Tunesia) run in a synchronized-phase grid, and we have interconnection links to the insular ones (UK, Nordic countries, and a small one tying us to Russia). The entire former Soviet Union runs on a synchronized-phase grid" Indeed you do (and there's problems with that), and it's not the impressive frankly (N. America has the same, with HVDC interconnects). But the OP was (clearly?) suggesting transporting all the power needed in Europe in, say, the Gobi desert. That's a scale of grid capacity that you do not have.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Indeed you do (and there's problems with that) Which ones? Our grid is extremely resilient - the last major customer-visible nation-wide outage was in 2006 when a mistake during the shutdown of a power line for the crossing of a ship underneath led to a failure cascade. Meanwhile, the US has outage reports every few months, including such absurdities as rolling outages to prevent wildfires from shoddy unmaintained networks. Or the shit that went down in Texas, which refuses interconnections to avoid federal regulations. > But the OP was (clearly?) suggesting transporting all the power needed in Europe in, say, the Gobi desert. That's a scale of grid capacity that you do not have. We don't need a grid powerful enough to shift all the power around, as we have plenty of local renewable electricity from various sources. For the rest? Italy is planning to build a new submarine interconnect to Tunisia (https://www.derstandard.de/story/2000121873523/italiens-netzbetreiber-terna-plant-stromleitung-durch-das-mittelmeer https://www.derstandard.de/story/2000121873523/italiens-netz...), sized enough to transport energy towards Northern Europe.
- himinlomax 5y agoDeep core drilling is an easy solution, but solutions are not being developed because waste is not actually that much of a problem. Decommissioning is one, though.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> no country has a long-term solution for dealing with the waste Sure we do. Stick it somewhere dry and remote. Thanks to climate change, brought on in part by anti-nuclear activists, we’ll have plenty of both well into the future.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Stick it somewhere dry and remote. The only thing that will attract is terrorists. No matter how remote, "dirty bombs" are a real threat. And in densely populated Europe, we don't have the luxury of such places at all. > Thanks to climate change, brought on in part by anti-nuclear activists Sorry, what? Climate change has been brought on by fossil fuel companies: - 20 companies are responsible for a third of all historic emissions: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/09/revealed-20-firms-third-carbon-emissions https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/09/revealed... - BP is the inventor of the "individual carbon footprint", inarguably one of the most devious PR campaigns that moved "responsibility" from the government to individual people so that the fossil fuel industry could make money without problems: https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sham https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sh... - hotly contested, but fossil fuel companies may have had a hand in the decline of public transportation systems: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp... - not to mention the countless "donations", bribes and other lobbying efforts from the industry to politics over the last 50 years that made sure that cars were prioritized and emissions controls weakened (the latter only ended with the Dieselgate scandal).
- MagnumOpus 5y ago> And in densely populated Europe, we don't have the luxury of such places at all All the nuclear waste of Europe could go in a building that's about one hectare. Yet there is enough place for both ten thousands of hectares of open pit coal mines, and hundreds of hectares of totally unprotected and open-air ash ponds containing toxic sludge that is guaranteed to more dangerous to your health - and sometimes also more radioactive - than just about any nuclear reactor waste. Face it, the "Green" movement in Germany which has lobbied to replace nuclear power with wind/solar in the last decade (instead of replacing coal with renewables and nukes) are responsible for gigatons of carbon emissions and will be rightly vilified by future generations.
- sasfasaf 5y agoWell there are breeder reactors that significantly transform waste to less harmful products, and the Russians have basically commercialized them. But they're still a bad idea. Nuclear waste implies a strong, competent, and stable state that is able to secure it for millennia. Fifteen years ago when I arrived to the US the Americans I spoke of couldn't conceive their hegemony collapsing or the US state becoming incompetent. This, I think, is the strongest argument against (current) nuclear power - in time it appears that all regimes collapse, geographic areas fall into anarchy and chaos. Human society simply doesn't have the proven long term stability to secure nuclear power.
- helloworld11 5y agoYou're aware also that storage of all the nuclear waste produced since the beginning of nuclear power to today would require a remarkably small amount of space, which even in conditions of political turmoil (when are conditions not in some state of turmoil, often far worse than today?) is far from as hard to find as you're painting it with your fearful idea of all governments collapsing "eventually". Specifically, for the U.S at least, in 2018, there were just over 80,000 metric tonnes of high-level waste that have been generated since the 1950's to now, all capable of fitting inside a single football field to a depth of just under 10 meters, and no more than 400,000 tonnes globally. That's pretty much all of it so far (sources: https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/P1799_web.pdf https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/P1799_web.pdf, https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-nuclear-fuel https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-... ). Between 1971 and 2018, nuclear reactors in the USA generated 3000 GW-years of electricity to make their 80,000 tonnes. Also, given the average density of most spent nuclear fuel, 80,000 or even 400,000 tonnes is not a tremendous physical volume to find some safe place for in the largely stable countries where most of it has been produced for many decades. There are far more immediately dangerous substances and objects in much less stable storage conditions all over the world (small arms, conventional explosives, landmines, toxic chemicals we have no way of not producing etc) that should warrant far more concern for the deaths they could or even do already cause per ton of weight.... Also, to debunk a few general misconceptions about storing nuclear waste. Yes the source has a certain bias, but it delivers well-reasoned points and offers sources of its own: https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-wastes/radioactive-wastes-myths-and-realities.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-c...
- FredPret 5y agoIt’s fission, not fusion. The only fusion reactor in use is the one in the sky. Nuclear has externalities. But carbon-based has much more. You mention solar panels. What are the externalities of those? Lots of harsh chemicals go into batteries, and we need a buttload of batteries to make solar work at scale. We don’t have a foolproof plan for long term storage of nuclear waste. But we have no plan at all for longterm storage of CO2 or battery/solar panel chemicals. Regarding the accidents, I can only assume you mean Three Mile Island and Chernobyl or perhaps the Japanese tsunami. If you look into it a bit more you’ll notice that those were technologically ancient reactors. Japan had several reactors - some with the older design, some more modern. They all got hit by a massive tsunami, much more than the design spec called for. The old ones leaked. The modern ones shut down safely, exactly as planned. Anti-nuclear = anti-science
- mschuster91 5y ago> It’s fission, not fusion. Fixed the typo, thanks. > You mention solar panels. What are the externalities of those? Lots of harsh chemicals go into batteries, and we need a buttload of batteries to make solar work at scale. Battery production in itself isn't as toxic as you make it out to be. > But we have no plan at all for longterm storage of CO2 or battery/solar panel chemicals. Long term CO2 storage has an easy concept: trees. Solar panels can easily be recycled these days - they are mostly glass - and battery recycling efforts are already underway, they should be at mass scale once the problem becomes relevant (since even used electric car batteries can have a long second life as decentral storage units). > Regarding the accidents, I can only assume you mean Three Mile Island and Chernobyl or perhaps the Japanese tsunami. If you look into it a bit more you’ll notice that those were technologically ancient reactors. Most reactors in operation today are ancient reactors, new constructions (Flamanville!) are plagued by cost and time overruns that put the infamous BER airport to shame, and possibly-new constructions (MSRs) are a pipe dream and/or have plutonium proliferation concerns. > They all got hit by a massive tsunami, much more than the design spec called for. California is deemed way overdue for a big earthquake (per https://www.cbsnews.com/news/california-earthquake-drought-overdue-for-major-quake-today-2019-04-03/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/california-earthquake-drought-o... and others). It is a really, really bad idea to build a nuclear plant anywhere close.