4 ms·

Don't A&A do bandwidth quotas? Their bandwidth limitations also look really pathetic (asymmetric FTTP, is this a bad joke?).

minimaul 5y ago
They do, but they’re sufficiently high you really shouldn’t hit them unless your traffic pattern is very extreme (the main home option is 5TB/month). Asymmetric FTTP is because they’re using Openreach’s FTTP platform (like most other ISPs in the UK), and Openreach FTTP is asymmetric. The fact they don’t offer faster speeds is currently a limitation of their broadband platform (they use in house developed routers), but they’re working on it.
- dijksterhuis 5y ago
  There's also the quota bonus to be aware of > half of the unused quota from the previous month being added to the next. https://support.aa.net.uk/Home::1 https://support.aa.net.uk/Home::1 I currently have 8.7TB left on my quota this month.
- tialaramex 5y ago
  Some people download tremendous amounts of stuff they don't need. This lifestyle is incompatible with A&A quotas (at your big name ISP it's actually costing them more than you pay for the service, but they have so many customers they don't care unless it gets entirely out of hand). Hear a passing mention that "Bob's Cheese Factory" is good on the podcast you listen to in the shower. Find out there were six seasons, OK, download six seasons of the Bob's Cheese Factory show, equating to 60 hours of video. That evening, watch the first twenty minutes of the pilot, seems kinda flat, delete all sixty hours. Similar behaviours exist in many aspects of life, there are people who own hundreds of items of clothing they'll never wear, for video games we know an on-line only title will see a staggering number of purchasers who never even go on-line with it once, meaning they paid for it, but they have never played even a few minutes of it, many of us order far more than one reasonable meal per person for take out food.
  - Lev1a 5y ago
    > quotas [...] at your big name ISP it's actually costing them more than you pay for the service Apart from one-off costs for building the line and associated repeaters and curb boxes, the only real running costs should be occasional maintenance on those boxes, some electricity costs and most likely some out-sourced phone support ("Have you tried turning it off and on again?"). I'm pretty sure the oh-so-convenient-to-ISPs tale of ever-rising costs if customers go past some arbitrary monthly limit (which is a tiny fraction of the possible monthly usage with the advertised bandwidth) is a MYTH and has been known as such for years. A little napkin-math: 10⁹ x (1/8 B x 1/2 x 3600s x 8h x 8d) = 10.8 x 10¹² B = 10.8 TB/m = 500Mb/s [1] @ 8h per day for 8 days per month which is much more than the oh-so-magnanimous 5 TB/month budget I read as an example in a comment further up. [1]: half of the advertised bandwidth
    - minimaul 5y ago
      In the UK, most ISPs don't build from the edge out to their own core. Most ISPs use a shared wholesale network provided by Openreach & BT Wholesale (or Openreach & TT Business, or Openreach & Zen Wholesale, etc). Customer connections over that backhaul are typically billed at a fixed monthly rate for the line itself, and a separate charge which is consolidated between all customers for bandwidth. That bandwidth cost is one of the largest costs for UK fixed line ISPs that aren't building their own infra. Peering/Transit to the internet is very cheap in comparison. edit: and the ISP we're talking about primarily does not offshore support. It's all in house & provided by technically knowledgable people who don't just have a script - and they're in the UK.
      - Nullabillity 5y ago
        > Customer connections over that backhaul are typically billed at a fixed monthly rate for the line itself, and a separate charge which is consolidated between all customers for bandwidth. That bandwidth cost is one of the largest costs for UK fixed line ISPs that aren't building their own infra. Peering/Transit to the internet is very cheap in comparison. Okay? So I guess the bottom line here is "A&A and Openreach both have pathetic pricing models". That's still not much of an improvement.
jonathantf2 5y ago
This is the main reason I'd choose Zen or IDNet instead of A&A if/when I move to an area where I can only get BT/OR. Bandwidth quotas have no place in $currentyear since it costs them basically zero.

minimaul 5y ago

They do, but they’re sufficiently high you really shouldn’t hit them unless your traffic pattern is very extreme (the main home option is 5TB/month). Asymmetric FTTP is because they’re using Openreach’s FTTP platform (like most other ISPs in the UK), and Openreach FTTP is asymmetric. The fact they don’t offer faster speeds is currently a limitation of their broadband platform (they use in house developed routers), but they’re working on it.

dijksterhuis 5y ago
There's also the quota bonus to be aware of > half of the unused quota from the previous month being added to the next. https://support.aa.net.uk/Home::1 https://support.aa.net.uk/Home::1 I currently have 8.7TB left on my quota this month.
tialaramex 5y ago
Some people download tremendous amounts of stuff they don't need. This lifestyle is incompatible with A&A quotas (at your big name ISP it's actually costing them more than you pay for the service, but they have so many customers they don't care unless it gets entirely out of hand). Hear a passing mention that "Bob's Cheese Factory" is good on the podcast you listen to in the shower. Find out there were six seasons, OK, download six seasons of the Bob's Cheese Factory show, equating to 60 hours of video. That evening, watch the first twenty minutes of the pilot, seems kinda flat, delete all sixty hours. Similar behaviours exist in many aspects of life, there are people who own hundreds of items of clothing they'll never wear, for video games we know an on-line only title will see a staggering number of purchasers who never even go on-line with it once, meaning they paid for it, but they have never played even a few minutes of it, many of us order far more than one reasonable meal per person for take out food.
- Lev1a 5y ago
  > quotas [...] at your big name ISP it's actually costing them more than you pay for the service Apart from one-off costs for building the line and associated repeaters and curb boxes, the only real running costs should be occasional maintenance on those boxes, some electricity costs and most likely some out-sourced phone support ("Have you tried turning it off and on again?"). I'm pretty sure the oh-so-convenient-to-ISPs tale of ever-rising costs if customers go past some arbitrary monthly limit (which is a tiny fraction of the possible monthly usage with the advertised bandwidth) is a MYTH and has been known as such for years. A little napkin-math: 10⁹ x (1/8 B x 1/2 x 3600s x 8h x 8d) = 10.8 x 10¹² B = 10.8 TB/m = 500Mb/s [1] @ 8h per day for 8 days per month which is much more than the oh-so-magnanimous 5 TB/month budget I read as an example in a comment further up. [1]: half of the advertised bandwidth
  - minimaul 5y ago
    In the UK, most ISPs don't build from the edge out to their own core. Most ISPs use a shared wholesale network provided by Openreach & BT Wholesale (or Openreach & TT Business, or Openreach & Zen Wholesale, etc). Customer connections over that backhaul are typically billed at a fixed monthly rate for the line itself, and a separate charge which is consolidated between all customers for bandwidth. That bandwidth cost is one of the largest costs for UK fixed line ISPs that aren't building their own infra. Peering/Transit to the internet is very cheap in comparison. edit: and the ISP we're talking about primarily does not offshore support. It's all in house & provided by technically knowledgable people who don't just have a script - and they're in the UK.
    - Nullabillity 5y ago
      > Customer connections over that backhaul are typically billed at a fixed monthly rate for the line itself, and a separate charge which is consolidated between all customers for bandwidth. That bandwidth cost is one of the largest costs for UK fixed line ISPs that aren't building their own infra. Peering/Transit to the internet is very cheap in comparison. Okay? So I guess the bottom line here is "A&A and Openreach both have pathetic pricing models". That's still not much of an improvement.

jonathantf2 5y ago

This is the main reason I'd choose Zen or IDNet instead of A&A if/when I move to an area where I can only get BT/OR. Bandwidth quotas have no place in $currentyear since it costs them basically zero.