3 ms·
I'd like to repeat someone's HN comment: what limits the (Western) civilization is the power of the collective intellect, the amount of effective thinking per d
by nine_k 5y ago
I'd like to repeat someone's HN comment: what limits the (Western) civilization is the power of the collective intellect, the amount of effective thinking per day.
Attention is a proxy to it, rather imprecise but easy to measure.
A lot of our problems stem from the fact that we don't know how to tackle them. We have the money and the resources money can buy, but we don't have a clear idea. We keep thinking and trying stuff, but apparently not very efficiently, because practical results are few; often we don't even seriously do that. This applies to everything, from curing common cold to solving global warming. Profitable investment of any kind is among these problems.
- hakfoo 5y agoI tend to categorize this as a combination of three problems: 1. We don't have a single defining policy platform for our society. If the CCP puts out a detailed timeline to a zero-carbon China, they have all the economic and political levers they need to pull in one place. No person or group in the US has any comparable authority. 2. Because of this, western countries tend to be limited to piecemeal solutions that can fit into smaller scale budgets and timelines. We can sell one power plant at a time, rather than a clearly strategized 50 year rundown to zero emissions. That means a lot of either-or decisions (Solar or traditional nuclear or Thorium, not funding all three) and a lot of people who are fundamentally on the same side get caught in infighting and bikeshedding trying to compete for limited opportunities. 3. You're often dealing with a problem where the solution is "yeet the entrenched counterinterest." The counter-interest group in 3) really just has to prevent you from doing anything to win, so it tends to encourage 2) as a cheap way to keep the opposition fractured.
- WJW 5y agoI'd argue that for most of the "Big" problems (world peace, nuclear proliferation, pollution, climate change and providing food/education/healthcare to all) the problem can be summarized as "lack of collective will to make the changes required". It is pretty clear what we would need to do to drastically reduce carbon emissions for example, but almost nobody is willing to make the economic sacrifices required.
- prox 5y agoI would also argue that ideological entrenchment because of stifling debate (or vice versa) is a big problem. Lots of problems have solutions but are ideologically entrenched.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI think "collective will" is a red herring. Humans are what they have always been - gradient descent optimizers on a good day. Understanding of morality, a culture, the law - those are tricks we've developed over time to, sometimes, break us out of situations in which our natural behavior threatens our communities (and so is self-destructive on aggregate). No, I think the common aspect of all Big Problems is that available solutions don't create equilibria. They're not stable. And we know they're not stable - most people do, if only on an instinctive level (our "social sense" is good at navigating these things). That encompasses all the "lack of collective will" cases: people are aware that they're being asked to make an immediate and concrete sacrifice, in exchange for uncertain and abstract long-term gains - gains that won't accrue unless almost everyone makes that same sacrifice. Our gradient-descending minds rightfully figure there's no point. See [0] for a much longer discussion of this topic. The point I'm making is that we should stop thinking about this as a moral failure, in the sense of "if only we had the collective will", as if almost everyone was lazy or heartless or stupid. On the contrary - the Big Problems persist because we know of no solution for them that can be implemented in context of our civilization - societies, cultures and laws[1]. The way I see it, we have following ways forward: - Figure out different solutions, ones that form stable equilibria within our current social framework. This is the part where technology plays critical role - new technologies are a way to create new options. - Transform our social framework into a one in which existing unstable solutions are stable. This is slow and hard work, involving changing laws and ultimately cultural norms. It ultimately means fighting our biology - not all social frameworks can be implemented on top of humans, and even for those that can be, there may not be a possible path from "here" to "there". -- [0] - https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ [1] - A good thought exercise to get a feel for it: imagine that we somehow found the "collective will" to solve one of the Big Problems. What mechanisms are there that protect people from being exploited at scale using the same collective-will-generating circumstances?