2 ms·
You're right, my error. I've updated my comment to note that, though I've left my error standing. I was thinking of the subsequent Abrams case (only a few mon
by dredmorbius 5y ago
You're right, my error. I've updated my comment to note that, though I've left my error standing.
I was thinking of the subsequent Abrams case (only a few months later in 1919) where Holmes departed from the Majority. That disagreement became the Great Dissent (and recent-ish book of the same title).
If I can somewhat cover for myself: Holmes in Schenck, and yes, writing for the majority, offered the "fire in a crowded theatre" hypothetical as not deserving protection.
Again: partiall overturned later in Brandenburg (1969).
My point remains that I'm not actually using Holme's hypo but one derived from it, and again, with a direct-gain motive added to that.