4 ms·
Reddit continues to insist that its sitewide administrative policies are based on behaviour rather than content, though it appears that this is a somewhat narro
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Reddit continues to insist that its sitewide administrative policies are based on behaviour rather than content, though it appears that this is a somewhat narrow distinction, and that behaviours which draw attention … tend to be associated with questionable content.
I’m not criticising the action. I support it. (The reasons are complex and difficult to articulate, though what I had to say ... on Reddit ... about limitations on speech some six years ago seems strongly appropriate. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2g8e8c/shouting_no_fire_in_a_warming_world_as_a_clear/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2g8e8c/shoutin...)
It's the rationalisation which seems thin.
The more so as what I’d based that argument on at the time --- falsely claiming no harm where a harm clearly existed is precisely at the centre of current discussions of the topic. This also seems to be a major, though under-discussed mode, of deceptive speech, and more pointedly a mode in which the downplaying of risk accrues benefits and gains to the parties promoting that message.
That said, Reddit’s lack of principled leadership and very-late-to-the-party redress continues to erode trust in the platform among those who live in a reality-based world and support strong epistemic systems. Which is one of the key challenges the firm faces: neither of the two principle sides in this matter are or will be happy with how it aquits itself.
I’ll note as well that the principles of “free speech” are not synonymous with the US first amendment (which concerns only government limitations), that speech on a privately-operate platform is both not the same as government censorship, but also not dissimilar in many regards, and that in any regard, free speech itself is not an absolute principle but one existing in balance with other considerations. I’ve been thinking in terms of a set of related, though often conflicting principles as Autonomous Communication (or variously: "informational autonomy" or "communications autonomy" --- naming things is hard --- discussed in “Which has primacy?”). The rights to privacy, free-assocation (both positive and negative), against self-incrimination, of obligated disclosure, and to accurate information, all collide, though there are some common principles which might help in adjudicating amongst them. I’m not aware of others offering any similar construction.
See: https://joindiaspora.com/posts/622677903778013902fd002590d8e506 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/622677903778013902fd002590d8e...
- nescioquid 5y ago> ...the principles of “free speech” are not synonymous with the US first amendment (which concerns only government limitations)... I think this is the nub of the problem. There are common carriers like the phone company, and there are publishers. A publisher will be responsible for what they publish, whereas a carrier really just gives access to their infrastructure. We have a situation now that seems like social media companies want it both ways (none of obligations and all of the prerogatives), so we get something like a phone service that censors your calls when convenient to the phone company. I really think this requires a political solution, though one often sees technological solutions suggested (peer-to-peer, federation). > ...free speech itself is not an absolute principle but one existing in balance with other considerations... Yes, political speech is the most protected variety. Curiously, money can be considered political speech. So while I think the only kind of real solution here is a political one, I don't expect that to ever happen.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's a nub of the problem. The problem has numerous nubs. But to the extent that socially harmful discriminatory practices of common carriers have profound influences, then yes, I agree with you. And yes, the problem is inherently political, as what it concerns is social power. Money-as-political-speech is profoundly problematic. The US has much very bad case law here.
- garaetjjte 5y ago>The reasons are complex and difficult to articulate, though what I had to say ... on Reddit ... about limitations on speech some six years ago seems strongly appropriate I don't think basing your argument on Schneck does it any good. It doesn't seem to be considered good decision nowadays. That case would fall well within First Amendment protections by standards established in later cases.
- dredmorbius 5y agoBut I didn't base my argument on Schenck. What I did was to take the metaphor of a dissenting opinion [Note: majority opinion, see comments below, my error] and then invert it (which would make any precedent invalid regardless) for the purpose of posing a question: what can we ask about the nature of harm caused by denying a threat, most especially when there is a self-serving interest in doing so? Schenck was a bad ruling, it's been overturned, and Holmes's argument appeared in a dissent. [Update: Nope, majority, see reply below.] It's memorable language (which is why it is invoked all the time, usually in a mistaken or misleading way). But it has never been guiding language. It's still a useful notion: one of considering private right to speech vs. the court's interest in public harm. Holmes's hypothetical was in falsely claiming a threat where none existed. That occurs occasionally, but is actually somewhat less an issue than denying a threat. The second is a behaviour we've seen again and again and again, mostly in a private-enterprise, "free market", private-property (and profit) context, where by downplaying some harm, profits or business can be transacted for a longer time with a larger market (or frauds perpetrated). This is what Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway document repeatedly in Merchants of Doubt. The benefit in Covid disinformation may be harder to pin down, though there are several pretty plausible cons that might be played, including poltical power, sale of hoax or ineffective cures (as has been suggested regarding Florida's governor and a key political funder), and general huckstering and grift.