35 ms·
If you define kinetic energy as mv^2 it basically means that you redefine the word "energy" to mean double energy (as we currently definine it). It could work j
by scotty79 5y ago
If you define kinetic energy as mv^2 it basically means that you redefine the word "energy" to mean double energy (as we currently definine it). It could work just as well, but we would have to have the factor 2 in all of the other equations that define any kind of energy or work so the "double energy" is conserved. The author alread gives such doubled equation for potential energy Epd=2mgh. You'd need to do the same for every other equation that involves any kind of energy in physics.
I wonder how author feels about 1/2 factor in equation that gives distance traveled by moving with constant acceleration. Should it be just at^2 ? This would redefine distance to be double distance and we would have to consider what it means for acceleration and velocity.
All these 1/2 come straight from integration of linear functions. To get rid of them we'd have to patch math results and since math holds this would mean factors of 2 pop up around everywhere else.
- SirIsaac 5y agoThanks for the comment. I see your point but I don't think it's a matter of definition. There is no doubt that the correct equation is Ek = mv². Since velocity v² = 2ad, it follows that mv² = 2mad = 2Fd. The work done is the acceleration of the body which is perfectly expressed in mv². The distance traveled is a result of the acceleration not the cause of it. Only the change in velocity matters. At least, that is my take on it.
- scotty79 5y agoBut the work done is Fd so 2Fd is double the work, and hence mv^2 is double energy. Why do you think work is given by 2Fd? Do you want it to be that? Do you want to define work as two times the force times the distance the force acted over? You can, if you like, but you'll be plagued by a factor of 2 in every place where you will talk about any work. It's way easier to keep this factor of 1/2 just in definition of kinetic energy instead. You can name mv^2 kinetic energy, and 2Fd work. But then you can name (mv^2)/2 kinetic half-energy and Fd half-work and physicist will still prefer to do calculations for half-work and half-energy because there will be less places where this factor of 2 will crop up in calculations.
- SirIsaac 5y agoCoriolis was wrong. The work done has nothing to do with distance. It only has to do with velocity. Accelerating the body from 0 to a final velocity is the work. This is what force does. If you know the distance and the acceleration, you can use them to calculate the final velocity with the well-known kinematics equation v² = 2ad. That is all. Likewise, if you know the elapsed time and the acceleration you can use the formula v = at to get the final velocity. It's simple, really.
- scotty79 5y ago> Coriolis was wrong. Probably about many things in his life as we all are. > The work done has nothing to do with distance. It only has to do with velocity. The thing that has to do only with the velocity we call kinetic energy. Work is something else. > Accelerating the body from 0 to a final velocity is the work. It's one example of work. You can also consider for example a force acting upon a body that travels with constant velocity of v over a distance d. And this force would still do the work equal to Fd. You might ask, how is it possible that this body that the force is acting upon doesn't have an acceleration? Because at the same time this body might have interactions with other bodies through different forces and do work on them. As example of this imagine a body that moves directly up on Earth with constant velocity v, because the force that does the work on it is directed up and equal exactly mg. That force does the work on this body, but none of it has anything to do with velocity and it goes directly into potential energy. Regardless of what kind of motion the body uses to travel distance d, if it's under the influence of the force F during that, the equation holds that work done by the force F equals Fd. This allows us to do calculations for various kinds of energies and multiple acting forces, just adding the work that each force does and changes in every kind of energy the body has. > If you know the distance and the acceleration, you can use them to calculate the final velocity with the well-known kinematics equation v² = 2ad. This equation is not some core law of the universe. It just comes from assuming we have a movement under influence of a single force of a body that at t=0 started at rest. It comes from v=at and d=(at^2)/2 and those come from integrals over time of a done once and twice. This equation you really like is just a result of how we define speed and acceleration simply applied to one kind of motion. It has nothing to do with forces or energies. It just deals with displacement and its first and second derivatives (velocity and acceleration). > Likewise, if you know the elapsed time and the acceleration you can use the formula v = at to get the final velocity. It's simple, really. Yes. It's simple to the point of not being especially interesting. What's interesting is that resulting formula deltaEk = Fd is more general. It works regardless of whether the motion that causes the change in kinetic energy has constant acceleration or not. And you can use it when multiple forces act upon this body and multiple kinds of energies are involved, for example deltaEp + deltaEk = Fd + Ge + Hi (where deltaEp is a change in potential energy, deltaEk is a change in kinetic energy, F, G, H are the forces and d, e, i are the displacement of the body while the forces F, G and H acted upon the body respectively). You are not wrong writing mv^2 = 2Fd and we might have called mv^2 energy but the we would have to call 2Fd work, and we really prefer to call Fd work because that factor 2 would crop up everywhere in physics where there are any energies and works considered (you already saw it in your version of the potential energy equation Ep=2mgh, and there are so many places in physics where it would need to show up, basically any place where there are energies and fields involved). So it's just more convenient to have it in the denominator of kinetic energy than literally everywhere else.