14 ms·
UK national extradited to US for film/TV piracy
- randywaterhouse 5y ago> "for his involvement in the Sparks Group, an international piracy group that illegally distributed movies and television shows on the Internet." (from the announcement) in case you were wondering if this was some "simple" torrent usage or what... > "In furtherance of its scheme, the Sparks Group fraudulently obtained copyrighted DVDs and Blu-Ray discs from wholesale distributors in advance of their retail release date by, among other things, making various misrepresentations to the wholesale distributors concerning the reasons that they were obtaining the discs prior to the retail release date."
- azalemeth 5y agoThey bought DVDs with a paper trail, shipped them internationally, ripped them and then uploaded to scene sites with photos of the retail packaging. Not difficult to see how they got caught. One can't help but feel sorry for them. Commercial copyright infringement in the states probably carries a $1e308 financial penalty and/or life imprisonment. The fact that the article is written about a UK national just highlights the asymmetry in the treaty – meanwhile, US citizens can literally get away with manslaughter [1] without being extradited... [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-51228262 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-5122826...
- vkou 5y agoYour comparison between vehicular homicide and commercial copyright infringement would work better if the perpetrator of the former were not protected by diplomatic immunity.
- f8f6dhdherb 5y agoWhy is this greying out? It's an obvious and legitimate difference that isn't just "hur dur treaty biased for the Americans".
- royletron 5y agoOooh it's kickin off now.
- HatchedLake721 5y ago> Anne Sacoolas was not entitled to diplomatic immunity, as her husband was not listed as a diplomat.
- flir 5y agohttps://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-57954208 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-57954... I think it's very likely she was, in fact, a "diplomat" in the "they expel one of ours, we expel one of theirs" sense.
- traceroute66 5y ago> protected by diplomatic immunity Aah yes, about that "diplomatic immunity" ... (1) "In court papers, the former Foreign Office (FCO) minister Tony Baldry said the diplomatic immunity deal reached in 1995 was intended specifically to exclude dangerous driving cases, or indeed any actions not related to the work of the staff at the base"[1] (2) Even if (1) were not the case, there have been documented cases where the US has "put pressure" on genuine diplomats working on US soil who have committed offences in order to be able to prosecute in the US (something about a Georgian diplomat in 1997 IIRC). Why should the rest of the world be subjected to "do as I say, but not as I do" with the US ? (3) What about that stupid "surprise surprise" show Trump attempted to put on at the Whitehouse ? I mean that's just sticking two-fingers up in the air to the UK family by saying "well, you can meet the perpetrator who's waiting in the next room ... ready to shed some crocodile tears for the cameras". [1]https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jun/22/anne-sacoolas-did-not-have-diplomatic-immunity-in-dunn-case-says-ex-minister https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jun/22/anne-sacoola...
- Symbiote 5y agoDiplomatic immunity is intended to prevent the host country (the UK) from subjecting diplomats to unreasonable detention, imprisonment etc, or to protect them from work done as part of their job (the host country might consider it spying). Responsible countries either waive the diplomatic immunity, or prosecute the offender in their own courts. The USA has done neither. In 2002, a Colombian diplomat had his immunity waived, allowing the UK to prosecute him for manslaughter. [1] [1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2284320.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2284320.stm
- vinay427 5y agoNo, it doesn't show much of anything about the US-UK treaty because that treaty wasn't used. They were extradited from Cyprus, which is noted in the article (reproduced below). I would agree that the handling of the Sacoolas situation was very problematic. > OIA also provided critical support in working with Eurojust and Europol in planning the coordinated operation in August 2020 and provided critical assistance in securing the defendant’s extradition from Cyprus.
- unity1001 5y ago> life imprisonment Life imprisonment for copying digital bits. Less than that for premeditated murder. US justice system does not serve justice or the people. But the corporations.
- azalemeth 5y agoFor the record, I was joking – if the sentences were served sequentially the article implies that the person extradited would be on the hook for a 30 year sentence. My perhaps unfair "joke" was supposed to be hinted at the ~floating point overflow fine at the same time. (For the record, I think this is utterly disproportionate to the crime – they certainly did not cause Hollywood multi-million losses.) The reason behind my perhaps slightly uncouth reference to the Death of Harry Dunn [1] was because 30 years is nearly double that faced by the US citizen who killed him, refusing to return to the UK as "the potential 14-year sentence [is] not proportionate" as it "would not usually result in a prison sentence in the US" [her lawyer, also 1]. I find it very interesting (as a commentary on the role of media, technology, and incentives in society) that using DeCSS and creating a torrent is apparently punishable by a long gaol sentence, yet negligently killing someone is apparently not. Anyway, another poster has subsequently pointed out that I am wrong to draw this conclusion as a different treaty was used -- and, I should probably not overly politicise HN either -- my apologies for both. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Harry_Dunn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Harry_Dunn
- marcodiego 5y agoI'd like easier to buy or rent DVD's. The DRM in it has been broken for so long that it is basically DRM-free and the quality is good enough for most of mine entertainment purposes. I fear streaming services will make buying DVD's harder. Are Blue-Ray as easily watchable as DVD's these days?
- opencl 5y agoThe DRM on blurays has been broken for over a decade now. The newer 4K blurays are a pain though, there are only a few drives that work and you will probably need to reflash the drive firmware.
- anothernewdude 5y agoBut hey, a diplomat killing a kid? Nah the US can't give them to the UK to face justice.
- ssklash 5y agoIt is insane to me that someone can get up to 5 years or more for using one of the fundamental mechanisms of digital technology. If you put out a product on a medium whose design is fundamentally based on copying bits, I don't know how you can expect anything else to happen. Instead of accepting the reality of digital communications, the MPAA, RIAA, and the like lobby to have the law protect their outdated but favorable business model instead. I will never buy the idea that once they have sold a digital product, the seller somehow maintains a claim on its existence. Doubleday doesn't own the pages of the books they sell me. Lionsgate doesn't own the the bits that make up the DVDs they sell me either, even if that fact is rather detrimental to their bottom line.
- rebelos 5y agoIt's not hard to see how piracy threatens the entire business model. You can have rampant piracy or you can have financially sustainable content production. You cannot have both. There is some critical mass of piracy that would in fact destroy the economics of the content production model. The industry has to work to deter that by periodically making examples of people. The timing is likely not coincidental either. Expect to see more of this as content once again fragments across providers, reanimating the traditional package TV structure in fresh form.
- foota 5y agoIn fairness, crowd funding and or altruistic consumers could theoretically sustain content production.
- skeeter2020 5y agoin reality this isn't the choice; it's typically private enterprise vs. public (government) broadcasters. Even PBS with lots of supporting patrons can't make it without significant government funding.
- foota 5y agoDoes PBS make content people want to watch?
- wooptoo 5y agoThe extradition treaty is a disgrace for the UK, completely imbalanced in favour of the US. - https://blog.6kbw.com/posts/this-lopsided-treaty-is-the-us-uk-extradition-treaty-imbalanced https://blog.6kbw.com/posts/this-lopsided-treaty-is-the-us-u... - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_treaty_of_2003 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_trea...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Retric 5y agoThey where extradited from Cyprus not the UK. As Cyprus gained it’s independence from the United Kingdom in 1960, recent UK/US treaties are irrelevant to this case.
- 908B64B197 5y agoThey know they can just... negotiate a better one right?
- sonicggg 5y agoI find it quite disgusting countries that agree to extradite their own nationals, it smells like subservience.
- blibble 5y ago> Which Allegedly Caused Tens of Millions of Dollars in Losses so how many uploaded movies is that? 3?
- wil421 5y ago> U.S. Attorney Audrey Strauss said: “As alleged, George Bridi was a member of an international video piracy ring that circumvented copyright protections on nearly every movie released by major production studios, as well as television shows, and distributed them worldwide on the Internet. Thanks to the assistance of our law enforcement partners, the piracy ring has been busted and Bridi is now in U.S. custody.” Sounds like more than 3.
- pessimizer 5y agoAnd unusually, the press release/statement is not an exaggeration. SPARKS ripped so many pre-release movies that at some point they obviously scared themselves, and suddenly announced that they were going to stop for the studios' sake.
- Joakal 5y ago$500k for first offence and $1m for each next offence. At "tens", we're talking about $20-90m? So, that means 21-91 DVDs. In other news, if you wilfully share a copyrighted picture of an American citizen, that's a $500,000 fine and USA will extradite and jail you. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_...
- f1refly 5y agohttps://www.srrdb.com/browse/1080/-SPARKS/order:date-desc/1 https://www.srrdb.com/browse/1080/-SPARKS/order:date-desc/1 They seem to have been quite a busy bunch
- Sytten 5y agoThe claim that is caused tens of millions in lost revenue is always funny to me. It is the same argument used to push DRM everywhere. The fact is, a lot (if not most) people that downloaded the movies or shows would not have paid for it in the first place. So it is not lost revenue.
- toiletaccount 5y agoi like the numbers they come up in some of those lawsuits. i have uhh...heard of people that have robbed the entertaintment industry of roughly the world gdp. if you go by their numbers.
- mhh__ 5y agoIt's no better than https://youtu.be/KSWqx8goqSY https://youtu.be/KSWqx8goqSY (That Awesome Time I Was Sued For Two Billion Dollars) level argument, just with better lawyer-speak. The US is sheltering a diplomat(spy?) who negligently ran over and killed a British civilian as we speak, but these guys are the real danger.
- pessimizer 5y agoThere's no doubt that SPARKS pre-releases cost the studios millions. When you release a terrible movie ahead of the opening weekend, the rumor spreads quickly that the movie is terrible. Normally, that effect would be part of (and swamped by) the 2nd weekend drop, but now it's part of your opening weekend. For good movies it probably doesn't make much of a difference. But most movies are not good. There's a huge gambling element to seeing a movie, and a leak gives away the outcome.
- alternatetwo 5y agoSPARKS was a retail group, they released DVD rips and BluRay rips - so their releases didn't impact theatrical opening weekends. You can check some stuff they pred here: https://www.srrdb.com/browse/SPARKS/order:date-asc/1 https://www.srrdb.com/browse/SPARKS/order:date-asc/1 As you can see (sorted by oldest because surprisingly many things have sparks in their name), it's mainly retail rips. In fact, few scene releases before COVID would actually impact theatrical openings, since the movies only get released weeks/months later on phyiscal media/streaming. The only thing you get before are crappy camrips/telesyncs. They do however usually manage to acquire the media a few weeks before the street date, which is why streaming releases are now a few weeks before the physical media releases.
- chroem- 5y agoI'm honestly relieved that the adults are back in charge at the Justice Department. We finally have rule of law again. :)
- subpixel 5y agoRIP thebox.bz
- hamburgerwah 5y agoThe US wants to have moral authority with scummy authoritarian governments throughout the world and then acts like a scummy authoritarian government. Do you want thriving dictatorships? This is how you get thriving dictatorships.
- president 5y agoAgreed but can a utopia without a scummy authoritarian government exist? There are worse scummy authoritarian governments out there and I'm glad that our scummy authoritarian government is still better than those.
- colechristensen 5y agoPeople on both sides of the political spectrum seem to very much want authoritarianism to enforce their viewpoints. You can’t have utopia without dealing with these people first.
- colechristensen 5y agoEh, what happened goes beyond simple piracy. They were defrauding wholesale distributors so they could rip and share prerelease dvds. To me this crosses the threshold into reasonable prosecution and extradition isnt a crazy abuse.
- frashelaw 5y agoThe US was always the most advanced police state. All the "freedom" indoctrination just thinly covers up the fact that the rich pull the strings, own the politicians, start the forever wars, and neglect the needs of the common person.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI can't help but feel like we are moving from sovereign governments having authority over territorial jurisdictions to sovereign governments having authority over specific interactions between specific parties across the globe. The US government doesn't just have authority over US territory, it has authority over any disputes between anyone and US persons or entities. The same seems to be happening across the EU and southeast Asia. It paints a grim picture.
- bawolff 5y agoI'm not sure that's really new. International relations has always been a thin veneer over might makes right, and the usa is very mighty.
- jrochkind1 5y agoThe "Spark group" was not a for-profit enterprise, they just gave away what they pirated, and made no money off of it? That seems remarkable.
- Joakal 5y agoAn Australian who had never been to USA was extradited and jailed despite not for profit too. On release, they got re jailed for being in USA illegally. They only got deported back to Australia on the condition they never visit USA in future. Currently, Australia's laws allow extradition if there's a jail term and we all know that sharing a picture is a jailable offence. Pirate Party Australia tried to push for non commercial+violent exemption but they never took off.
- Stevvo 5y ago"Spark group" are part of a resilient not-for-profit subculture of pirates called "the scene" that has existed as long as the internet itself. Some of the other groups have good enough opsec that they have been around since the 80s. Sure is remarkable.
- mhh__ 5y agoYou'll have to answer to the Coca-Cola company!
- TechBro8615 5y agoI wonder if this is related to the “grudges” [0] President Biden promised to hold against Britain a few days ago. [0] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2021/08/29/joe-biden-holds-grudges-will-punish-britain-afghanistan-criticism/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2021/08/29/joe-biden-...
- linuxhansl 5y ago> Dismantle the Sparks Group, Which Allegedly Caused Tens of Millions of Dollars in Losses Resulting from Pirated Films and TV Shows Smells like false math or at least the false assumption that every consumer of the copyrighted content would have paid otherwise.
- shsbdncudx 5y agoNobody should be approved for extradition to the US until they cough up the wife of that diplomat who killed someone in her car a escaped and evaded back to the US
- lanevorockz 5y agoWhat do you think the whole Hate Speech movement is ? They want to criminalise speech and the enforcement framework is SOPA. After two decades they noticed that it’s much easier to achieve what you want if you create a buggey man.
- dangjc 5y agoHe stole intellectual property and deserves to be prosecuted. With abundant streaming options these days and threat of being cut off from your ISP, few people pirate films anymore in the US. This is not normal, tolerable practice anymore. People’s livelihoods depend on these industries. A lot of the people here on hacker news make a living from producing intellectual property.
- f1refly 5y agoHe stole nothing, he merely copied. The abundant streaming options are abusive and leave the "customer" without rights and without options. This is normal, tolerable practice. A lot of people here on hackernews would make just the same, as unpermitted copying has been shown to have an unnoticable, if not positive effect on movie payoff.
- mousepilot 5y agoI think as long as people can't recognise theft of publishing rights, it will be difficult to have any sort of sensible conversation about it.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoIt's an interesting juxtaposition to have this article on the front page of HN at the same time as this one: The Sackler Family Wins Immunity from Future Opioid Lawsuits[0] [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28385661 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28385661
- 8eye 5y agowe have to start asking ourselves collectively if this is the life we voted for
- satellite2 5y agoIt's interesting as on HN frontpage today there is also a book about a VC explaining that we are switching in a new post material scarcity era and that the economy is transforming into one where only attention is scarce. It's really on point as it's clear from many papers and years on research on piracy that mostly people that downloaded pirated content would not have bought it but might still buy derivatives (and do in average). So generally piracy is a net positive for copyright holder. Nevertheless, this group members were chased and prosecuted around the world as their crime is that they unfairly competed for people's attention which is transforming into our world currency.
- yamrzou 5y ago> On August 26, 2020, in coordination with law enforcement authorities in 17 countries and supported by Eurojust and Europol, dozens of servers controlled by the Sparks Group were taken offline around the world, including in North America, Europe, and Asia. The Sparks Group utilized these servers to store and disseminate copyrighted content illegally to members around the globe It's impressive that 17 countries can can coordinate and take such action.