3 ms·
Consider that EJ is like most people who write anything online, including you and I on this site. We may know that everything we say is, in theory, open to the
by scott_s 15y ago
Consider that EJ is like most people who write anything online, including you and I on this site. We may know that everything we say is, in theory, open to the whole world, but in practice, no one cares. I think she wrote her blog post in that mindset. It's similar to a mindset that, say, you have when writing a comment on HN. Now consider what would happen when seemingly the entirety of the internet is analyzing what you said.
It's easy to say she should have known that her blog is a broadcast medium, but really, it's not most of the time. Most of the time, very few people probably read it. Most forum posts and blog entries get lost amid the noise. I think it's unrealistic to assume that everyone who writes things on the internet that normally gets lost among the noise should be emotionally prepared to be temporarily not lost among the noise.
- mc32 15y agoI'm sympathetic. It's a very reasonable and persuasive argument. Unfortunately, it's one of those things one cannot control -short of censorship. The same thing happens with people's email transcripts. The same happens with politicians and open mics. Most of the time ill-conceved/or personal emails or rants or candid opinions to an open mic are not picked up and broadcast --sometimes, depending on context, opportunity and misfortune, they are -to lots of regret, embarrassment and perhaps, lawful correction. Occasionally, opportunity. Basically, to me, they seem inextricable. I cannot/am not able to see a way to separate them in an unmoderated open forum. My main point wasn't that she should have realized it's a broadcast medium. Rather, realize the medium is subject, by its public nature, to a spectrum of reactions. Some of those can be reactionary and unwelcome. It's part of discourse.