19 ms·
I personally find it quite sad to see reactions on HN regarding the introduction of Docker Desktop subscription model. We all benefit from a well supported Dock
by dgellow 5y ago
I personally find it quite sad to see reactions on HN regarding the introduction of Docker Desktop subscription model. We all benefit from a well supported Docker company, it’s good to see they are trying to look for a sustainable model. If your team is using their tools daily since years, and you decide to change to a different one just to avoid a small license fee, that feels hypocritical. If the tool worked for you when it was free, it still works when you have to pay a small license fee and brings the same value.
Companies paying for developer tooling is good for the ecosystem.
- rckrd 5y agoAuthor here. I agree. Even as a past maintainer of minikube, I still am a frequent user of Docker Desktop and would gladly pay for it
- dgellow 5y agoBtw, thanks for the article, it’s an interesting read, I like your writing style
- ngauje 5y agoIn big Companies, the usage of VPN solution is pretty common. Especially since COVID with the rise of remote workers. One big feature Docker Desktop nailed is the VPN friendlyest of the solution! They developped VPNKit to solve VPN issues, and honestly it works very well. None on the alternatives provide such feature!
- detaro 5y agoWhat does it do?
- ngauje 5y agoIt links docker's network through a linux/windows pipe to a process on your windows/mac host. So containers network packets don't get out from a virtual network adapter (that can be filtered out) but from a vpnkit.exe process on windows. Using this, you are more compliant with strict corporate security rules and are less likely to be blocked by your VPN client, proxy firewall etc...
- gambler 5y ago> If your team is using their tools daily since years, and you decide to change to a different one just to avoid a small license fee, that feels hypocritical From engineer's perspective the difference between a free tool and a "small fee" (in most companies) is not money. It's the fact that you now have to jump through provisioning hoops and ask for permission to use the tool. The difference in flexibility is enormous.
- yunohn 5y agoThat’s exactly what Docker wants though - You’re using a tool for gainful development for your company. They should be able to afford a fee to compensate Docker for that.
- mbreese 5y agoAnd the risk to Docker is that the red tape required to buy the product isn’t worth the hassle, especially if there are alternatives to using the paid product. This is all based on open source, so I’d expect there to be many new alternatives within weeks. And workflows for existing tools/interfaces will probably be detailed in blog posts by the weekend.
- yunohn 5y agoThere’s a lot of companies (FAANG incl.) that prefer licensed software with support, over random GitHub repositories. Most people on this thread are not commenting on lack of business model, rather that they “don’t want to pay”.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoTotally. Paying a reasonable amount is actually cheaper than the manpower and attention required for an ‘open source check.’ And isn’t it nicer to pay engineers, rather than lawyers? :-)
- 5y ago
- jmnicolas 5y agoAs usual situations vary: I work in a small company, I'm the sole dev, there's absolutely 0 budget for dev tools, if it's not free I can't have it.
- lordleft 5y agoIn this case Docker's approach serves you well, as you are not expected to pay the subscription fee if your company has less than 250 people.
- jmnicolas 5y agoWe're very close to 250 people (but probably under, I need to check) but we're over the 10M / year line. And yes, the company could pay, it's just they don't want to. Just an example, I need to vent: I wrote a program that pilot all the lights in the company. To my great shame, it was failing spectacularly despite hours spent debugging the thing. I received a lot of criticism about my coding skills. Until I convinced him to buy pro dedicated hardware instead of cheap Arduino knockoffs to be the interface between my program and the light switches. It's working like a charm since 2010.
- lordleft 5y agoI misread, I thought you were saying you were the only employee, not the only dev. I also feel for you -- it's not fun having to fight tooth and nail to get funding for essential dev tools.
- yawaramin 5y agoIf you have almost 250 people and more than $10M/yr revenue–how are you a small company?!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lordleft 5y agoI agree with (some) of this. Companies are always going to be free to find alternatives if they're motivated to do so, but the cost of this subscription model is a drop in the bucket for a lot of larger firms, and there's nothing wrong with supporting a company that maintains and develops a critical piece of your infrastructure (in fact it's quite savvy). I sometimes worry that we've gotten too used to free things, whether those things are youtube videos, articles by journalistic institutions or pieces of software. I'm hardly an exception here -- I too wince when I see a paywall in front of an article, but people need to be able to sustain themselves when they create things that benefit others. It's hard the reconcile the paradox of wanting high quality things without paying for it.
- nerdjon 5y agoMy problem is less that it is happening but how we got here. If docker desktop was originally subscription based or they said that they wanted to make it subscription based later than the reaction would be very different. But Docker as a company has failed multiple times now to attempt to make money and this feels like a hostage situation by taking away a tool that many now rely on. They tried to go the support route like RedHat and others, but who needed just Docker support? Especially when there orchestration layer was basically DOA with k8s available. Last year (?) they started limiting pulls from docker hub unless you paid up. Which spawned companies like AWS to announce their own free alternative/mirror. At some point with in the last few months they made it so without paying I was forced to update docker desktop or constantly have to click snooze. I was perfectly happy with what it was currently doing and had no desire to update. But they added that artificial limitation after release. Now they are charging for something that was once free without really explaining any benefits? I think the reaction is perfectly valid given the companies track record. There are likely other examples they have tried but likely just didn't notice. Since Docker is in a situation where docker itself is just not what most of us really think about. It is the orchestration and docker is just a path to that. Edit: Also not super enthused about the idea that I now need to ask during a job interview what software I will be able to have locally for part of my workflow.
- yunohn 5y ago> Now they are charging for something that was once free without really explaining any benefits? It was free when they could afford it. Now it’s not, because they do indeed, need money. Why is that so wrong?
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> and you decide to change to a different one just to avoid a small license fee, That’s an oversimplification of the issue. I really don’t care about the small monetary cost. I do, however, care about adding yet another recurring license fee to my already long list of recurring charges and licenses to manage across the team. It’s not necessarily Docker’s fault, but I think many of us are experiencing a lot of SaaS fatigue with the ever-growing list of services and plans and recurring charges that need to be managed. Evaluating alternatives isn’t just about dodging a nominal fee. It’s about avoiding yet another recurring overhead and associated hassle, however small, that comes with every additional subscription.
- johannes1234321 5y agoOh, all those subscriptions. Office space, cleaning, drinks, coffee, electricity, heating, water, ... Dealing with expenses is part of running a business. Sure there's a lot, but that's part of it.
- smoldesu 5y agoI pay my electricity by the watt, and I pay for water because without it, we die. I don't really care about your $25/month Wiki/Container/Notes SaaS as much. If you raise the price anywhere along the subscription chain, this little frog is going to jump out long before you start boiling the water.
- dgellow 5y agoBefore you had a free lunch. Now they set a price on it. You check if the value you get from their product is worth the price they ask for (IMHO they priced it way too low). If that doesn’t match then you move away. Economics 101. The way people describe the situation in this thread makes it like they have been betrayed by their spouses… Nobody is exploiting anyone else, only one side decided to ask something in exchange for their beloved product. And only from large companies!
- rpdillon 5y agoYou're correct. My experience procuring SaaS (or even just self-hosted software licenses) is that there's a very different process for those than there is for sandwiches or janitorial staff. The engineers are always involved, but the negotiation process is arduous _every time_, and requires looping in the procurement team, who is essentially paid by how much of a discount they get off of sticker. So there I am, trying to run a suite of services for the company I work for, and every renewal is an existential crisis where the procurement team plays chicken with the vendor to see who will crack first in the negotiation, all the while the license expiration for my service is creeping ever closer. I've suffered large production outages because of this dynamic, and I'm tired of it: it's a totally avoidable risk, and I view part of my value to my employer as helping them avoid totally avoidable risks. So, I tend to go for open source or "bundled" solutions (like AWS) where I can avoid this process. I suspect this is what GP was getting at.
- agilob 5y ago> it quite sad to see reactions on HN regarding the introduction of Docker Desktop subscription model. Docker Desktop for Mac simply sucks. It starts slowly, has slow UX, burns CPU all the time even when not active and no container instance is running. They recently added that "you have to upgrade now" popup and it feels updates are more frequent. I might be biased here due to poor UX with the popups, updates were smoother before. If I'm to pay for it, I really would like to have better experience using it. I can run VSCode, IntelliJ and Firefox with dozen of tabs open and my mac isn't as hot as when running docker desktop.
- regularjack 5y agoThis is absolutely not my experience with Docker for Mac. I've been using it daily for years and can't remember a single issue I had with it. Performance is also adequate, even when running many containers, though usually not more than 10 or so. I use a base model MacBook Pro 16".
- ggregoire 5y agoSame. Docker definitely had some performance issues on Mac a few years ago but it's fine now.
- mbreese 5y agoIt still seems to suck battery life on my 13” Intel MBP. But aside from starting to nag me to keep upgrading, that’s about my only complaint.
- yunohn 5y agoDoes Docker consume battery, or the actual app itself? I don’t have much extra power consumption from the UI app, as to be expected.
- jzoch 5y agoyou must be running tiny containers - I spin up a dozen containers and run a few tests every day. The entire test suite takes 45 minutes on my mac and 25 on linux. Docker for mac performance is atrocious
- morpheuskafka 5y agoAs someone with only minimal experience with containers, is Docker the company still relevant? When I set up a new server with RHEL it has some open source replacements (podman) instead, and says they work with the same containers. The Docker Desktop client obviously is useful for quickly setting up and interacting on macOS and Windows graphically, but is Docker still relevant for the server? It seems like Docker Swarm never took off and everyone just uses Kubernetes anyway.
- mumblemumble 5y agoReframing the discussion in terms of just server seems to be deliberately missing the point, since the issue under consideration is the new pricing model for Docker Desktop. Which is 100% about developer experience on OS X and Windows.
- systemvoltage 5y agoStep 1) Release open source free software Step 2) Get millions of people aboard Step 3) Clamp down, raise prices, make people pay for their mistake of relying on 'free' services/products. If you change Step 1) to Subsidize services, then you get Uber/Lyft. This also applies to drug trading (first time is free!). It gives unfair advantage to companies that have deep VC-lined pockets and a huge pool of money to spend. It raises the critical barrier for the small-guy to compete in this landscape. It also makes it easy for these companies to wipe out competition by undercutting them. This is just cheating.
- dgellow 5y agoIt’s good business, i don’t see wha is wrong with it. You offer code source, documentation, tools for free for a very, very long time. Eventually you ask for a small license fee from big companies. Everybody benefited immensely from this.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoDocker Enterprise was already sold. What they said then about the community and future was this: > Moving forward, we will expand Docker Desktop and Docker Hub’s roles in the developer workflow for modern apps. Problem is, that i don't see anything really improving. It seems that they are cashing in, no?
- dgellow 5y agoThey are continuously investing into Docker for Desktop, which is what is being discussed here. See the other people in the thread complaining they have to update too often as a side effect.
- yawaramin 5y agoBy 'cashing in', do you perhaps mean 'trying to earn a living'?
- NicoJuicy 5y agoI would think that is the idea of having an enterprise version for. Which they sold.
- yawaramin 5y agoAnd so they're never allowed to change their business model? Companies sell divisions and change their product lines all the time. What makes Docker's change so different? Let me guess, it's because it inconveniences a few loud HN commenters.
- blitzd 5y agoI personally am just looking for a stable tool to build and test images. I can appreciate that Docker is looking for a way to become sustainable, but the way they are going about doing it has become disruptive to how I use the tool, thus alternatives like podman are becoming much more attractive. The license fee is really not an issue for me - but continuously having to adjust my workflows when Docker Inc decides to change how things work on the back-end is an issue, and it's much more expensive for me than the license.
- raesene9 5y agoIf you just want to build and test images, a Linux VM with the open source Docker engine installed will work fine :)
- yawaramin 5y agoIf an alternative like podman works for you, then Docker for Desktop is not really targeting you at all, right? It's only for Mac and Windows computers, not for Linux.
- yunohn 5y agoYou’re using Docker, and confusing the convenient UI app for the CLI. You can easily setup Docker without it, and never have to worry about any GUI asking for a fee. Yet, here we are. Lots of complaints, but no real understanding.
- blihp 5y agoIt's the bait-and-switch aspect I suspect most are reacting negatively to. Given how many of these 'pivots' we've seen, let's be honest is observing that generally the plan for a sustainable model all along most likely was "don't start charging for it until we're sure we've become a user habit and killed the competition." They knew long ago, if not on day one, that "give it away for free and make it up in volume" wasn't a serious long term plan. On the one hand, I don't blame companies for pulling this because the market continues to go along with it. On the other, I have no sympathy for the backlash they get for doing it. Choice and competition are good. Companies taking a scorched earth approach with extended "free... for now (because we've got the runway to do it)" business models are bad for the ecosystem.
- raesene9 5y agoTBF if you know the history of Docker, it seems unlikely that this was their plan in the beginning. Docker started back before the container orchestrator wars and the rise of Kubernetes. They couldn't have predicted that or the popularity of their services and tools. They then had the enterprise Docker edition and swarm along with UCP which at one point looked like a reasonable path to monetization. It was only after selling the enterprise software arm to Mirantis, which isn't that long ago really, that it would have been likely that their end game was charging for the Docker desktop product.
- pseudalopex 5y agoHow do people who use containerd and minikube benefit from a well supported Docker company?
- raesene9 5y agoDocker begat ContainerD, so without Docker the organization, it would not exist as a project in it's current form. As to current support, well if you're just using minikube, you don't need Docker Desktop, so this isn't a problem :)
- pseudalopex 5y agoBut would they care if Docker Inc went bankrupt now? The claim was we all benefit. Universal and present tense.
- raesene9 5y agoIf Docker hub went away, I have a fairly strong feeling the sound of CI/CD pipelines collapsing around the world would be heard for quite a while :) Also without paid developers maintaining Docker Engine, there would be a nasty situation next time there was a security issue in it and the millions of installs were unmaintained.
- dgellow 5y agoThat’s not really relevant, the discussion is about Docker for Desktop. But your still benefit from their brand and marketing and development efforts, as the rest of the ecosystem.
- lukeschlather 5y agoIf Docker Desktop seemed like it was a great product I would be happy to pay money for it. But I've been using it for years and it still doesn't feel like Docker gets what I want from it, and I'm not sure I see the thing evolving to be what I want. I want something a lot more like minikube or preferably buildah/podman. So this is a natural moment to ask if I can get the thing that I really want and incidentally avoid spending $1000/year in licensing which is not nothing.
- yawaramin 5y agoThe license fee doesn't come out of your pocket though? It's purchased by your company. And that too only for businesses large enough to qualify for that tier.
- outworlder 5y ago> I personally find it quite sad to see reactions on HN regarding the introduction of Docker Desktop subscription model Let me tell you what the problem is. This is the Darth Vader business model: "I have altered the deal, pray that I don't alter it further". The reactions didn't start today. First, features that could decrease their lockin tend to linger in limbo forever. For example, the ability to have mirrors. This works, but _only for dockerhub_. Isn't that odd? There are even pull requests proposed ( * ) https://github.com/moby/moby/issues/18818 https://github.com/moby/moby/issues/18818 Then there were the Dockerhub changes. Those are understandable, it must be a heavy money sink to maintain that service. Want to keep using that registry? Pay them. This is a fine arrangement (but note that dockerhub has special status, as you can use it without specifying the registry, and it can be used a a mirror). Still ok though. More recently they changed Docker Desktop to not allow skipping updates if you are not paying them. That was the strangest "feature" ever. Don't want to support? Say that's the last supported "free" version and stop providing updates after a certain date. But this "you can only choose NOT to update if you are pro" was weird. And then there's this. They have been trying and failing to extract a working business model out of their technology. So instead of trying to offer something that would entice people to pay, they have started to cripple their product for the ones who don't pay, just to get back to the same feature level they had before. Can they do that? Of course. What else will they decide to do in the future though? ( * ) Maybe this would be a Docker Pro/Team/Enterprise/whatever feature? Ok cool. This would make my life easier to try to pitch buying it. Mirrors would improve stability. Maybe some fancy local caching for K8s clusters so they would avoid pulls if another machine has pulled an image already? Give us something that will save time or money or improve stability and I can pitch to management. Right now? I see no reason to pitch pro/team/business as most of their stuff we don't care about. And maybe don't conflate Docker, the software, with DockerHub?
- yawaramin 5y ago> More recently they changed Docker Desktop to not allow skipping updates if you are not paying them. More recently than that, they changed it back to allow skipping the updates for free after all. > So instead of trying to offer something that would entice people to pay, Like a convenient desktop-based virtualization layer that allows running Docker containers on Mac and Windows? > they have started to cripple their product for the ones who don't pay You mean like how Linux software doesn't run on Windows and Mac natively? Weird.
- MDWolinski 5y agoI haven’t read all the replies so someone else may have talked about this, however for enterprises it’s not the cost, so I certainly agree with you. Enterprises pay large amounts for services (ie Slack, etc) so the number of employees using docker in a corporation isn’t overall large enough that these changes would cause a blip on a finance statement. That being said, while I’m not a first person knowledge on the reasons, the company I work for would not accept the licensing terms. What exactly the issue is, I don’t know, but I know a lot of effort has gone into prepping to mitigate this change and move the company away from Docker as a solution. In the end, I’m guessing the biggest misstep here is the terms included in the new agreements, not the price.