6 ms·
Do political stickers work? (2020)
- nonameiguess 5y agoThis is missing at least one thing. Bumper stickers and stickers placed on public property differ in one important respect: a bumper sticker is on an identifiable person's private property. That means you know who put it there. The woman who lives across the street from me has her car absolutely plastered, totally covered with political stickers. She is advertising very loudly to the entire neighborhood anywhere she ever parks her car what she cares about. So that is a 4th purpose not covered in this article that cannot be served by stickers on stop signs.
- pope_meat 5y agoPeople with political bumper stickers are braver than me. In an ever more polarized political climate it's almost dangerous to declare a side openly. But then again, without risk, there's no chance for reward, and silencing yourself for safety reasons just reinforces the status quo as working. What a fun little nightmare.
- exmadscientist 5y agoWhat reward? I fail to see any substantial benefit from displaying my political leanings publicly. "Work Clean" is often sensible advice for one's public face. Though who am I to talk, I had a Giant Meteor 2020 yard sign up last cycle....
- pope_meat 5y agoFingers crossed for Giant Meteor in 2024. It's a rather sad state of affairs when "destroy it all" is a genuine opinion. I've been advocating for a new political party that I call "nuke everything party" and the platform is very simple, launch all the nukes, and party until it all ends.
- dagw 5y agoWhat reward? I assume the hoped for reward is that 'your' candidate wins. I guess the thinking goes that if I am on the fence about who to vote for, but see that a lot of people around me that I feel I have many things in common with openly support candidate A, then I'm more likely to swing towards candidate A myself.
- inglor_cz 5y agoIn that case, having just one sticker is probably less safe than having your car entirely plastered with them. The latter gives a vibe of a person crazy enough that you do not want to mess with them.
- Banana699 5y ago>The latter gives a vibe of a person crazy enough that you do not want to mess with them. Or provoke the attention of a whole squad from the enemy ranks, as it marks you as a high-value object lesson. Whereas a more moderate stance might be common enough for them not to bother going after every such person. :(And if they did go after you, you'd probably have the sympathy of the public and the authorities more if you were just a moderate follower declaring your allegiance with one flag than if you were a True Believer^TM completely dedicating your property to signaling your status)
- 8note 5y agoAre they actually identifiable? I generally have no clue who's car is parked right beside me, nor who put the stickers on their car
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoMany people can see their neighbor's car parked in the driveway, so yes, sometimes.
- rich_sasha 5y agoThere's more, perhaps more relevant in countries with more than 2 mainstream parties. There's a "hey this is a viable idea, look at how many people are supporting it" kind of thing. For example in local elections in the UK, plenty of people put up a little poster thing for their candidate. I definitely had my attention drawn to candidates I considered no-hopers and gave them a second look. I wouldn't have if I thought they have no support otherwise. I think this is a bit different to simply repeated advertising. There is also a component of "join us, we're a cool community [of people voting for X], it's OK". Think about, more so in the past, people were often reluctant to admit they are voting for a populist candidate. Stickers can bring such "uncool" candidates into the mainstream.
- the-dude 5y agoWell, this resonates with myself ( sorry, I know ). I am Dutch and in NL, but acquired an 'original' Trump 2016 MAGA shirt ( a friend brought it from the US ). I am not pro-Trump, but also not anti-Trump, while normal civilized discourse in my town of 'progressives' is Orange man bad. I enjoy the apparent tension the whole subject seems to generate. I proudly wear the shirt, which is seen as brave by my friends : it could get me in trouble, but I am a big, assertive guy. The shirt makes people speak up who would have never spoken up given the climate. Some are pro-Trump and some are not anti-Trump, some are US citizens. It definetly brings out the dynamic you are referring to. Well, there, I said it.
- trainsplanes 5y agoI’m American and most certainly not pro-Trump. That said, I’ve thought Make America Great Again hats were hilarious since day one. I’ve wanted to get one and wear it, but I know that doing that is taken as a strong sign of endorsement for him and various other things, and it sets some people off into a rage. Can’t wait until a decade from now when it hopefully settles down and they’re just goofy pieces of vintage wear.
- csa 5y agoMy very liberal friend thought the same thing… so he just got one written in Russian. The reactions are pretty hilarious.
- dll 5y agoIn Wales you can't go anywhere without seeing Yes Cymru stickers, to the point that unionist politicians complain about them; I'd say they're working here.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI once saw an entire political debate about Welsh independence play out in graffiti on a pub wall. I certainly hope if it happens they’ll allow rump UK citizens to live and work there as Ireland did upon independence, I miss living in Wales and will probably return one day.
- gjm11 5y agoI can think of two reasons for political stickers and posters, neither of which is among the ones listed in the article linked here. 1. Putting them up cements the loyalty of the person putting them up. You're less likely to consider switching away from the Purple Party to the Orange Party when you've already spent a lot of time and effort putting up Purple posters and when you've publicly declared your affiliation by plastering your property with Purple stickers. 2. Having a lot of them up demonstrates that your party has enough support to be worth bothering with. Few people like the idea of voting for a likely loser, especially in places where elections are first-past-the-post. So having lots of Purple partisans put up Purple posters lets everyone see that Purple are in with a chance and therefore not feel as if a vote for the Purple candidate would be thrown away. #1 is a reason why parties should produce these things, though not a reason why individuals should put them up. #2 seems to me a more plausible reason for putting them up than the ones in the article. If my theory about #2 is right, we might expect to see more political posters in places whose electoral systems make votes for minority parties less valuable. I don't know whether that's actually so. [For the avoidance of doubt, "Purple" and "Orange" here are arbitrary labels and aren't intended to suggest any actual parties or movements that might use those colours.]
- gverrilla 5y agothere's also the cost for the stickers
- PoignardAzur 5y ago> If my theory about #2 is right, we might expect to see more political posters in places whose electoral systems make votes for minority parties less valuable. I don't know whether that's actually so. In France the candidate who has the most posters is Asselineau. They are everywhere; but most people know he has no chance of winning the next election.
- meursault__ 5y agoI think the OP misunderstands the purpose of many of these stickers, especially the ones used by the independent left or the alt-right. Their purpose is not to convince you to vote for a particular party. The main purpose is often to mark a certain territory, based on the stickers, it is often easy to determine how strong the antifascist left or the alt-right or neo-fascist right is in a particular district of a major city.
- chrisxcross 5y agoFull agree. Political stickers are much more like graffiti tags. It's pretty fun to 'follow' some groups around by just recognizing their stickers.
- specialist 5y agoYes and: Stickers (logos, yard signs, t-shirts, etc) are: - expressions of identity, virtue signaling - source of revenue for the cause The stuff about marketing, loyalty, branding, and such is all still true. It's just that the underlying core motivators are even more basic, primal, simple. Source: Ran for office, worked on many campaigns, did fund raising. I'm still flabbergasted. Many contribute $200 and will be very grumpy if they don't get a yard sign. They're paying you to promote you.
- theBobBob 5y agoOne other use of political symbols such as bumper stickers or flags etc is to "mark your territory" to make sure that people know whether they are welcome or not. As an Irishman driving through some parts of Northern Ireland the best/worst case of that was some small towns and villages that more or less literally, had every available space covered in the British flag. I mean every building and many windows had a flag on or it it, every lamppost was covered in both flags and bunting of even more flags. It looked like there was some sort of British flag bomb that had coated the town. Do you think me with my Irish reg car, and Irish accent stopped in that town while I was driving through?