3 ms·
What you're talking about isn't pay-for-usage. It's not pay-per usage when Comcast charges a flat fee up to 250GB and then charges extra beyond that. That's a
by dpark 15y ago
What you're talking about isn't pay-for-usage. It's not pay-per usage when Comcast charges a flat fee up to 250GB and then charges extra beyond that. That's a soft cap or a tiered plan. I agree that Comcast seems stupid for cutting people off at 250GB, but I would not call it pay-for-usage to extend beyond that.
I assume you would see a 10x jump in cost because AT&T says that the top users are consuming 12x as much as the average. If users are paying their "fair share", then people using 12x as much bandwidth would pay about 12x as much. Otherwise it's not "fair" and it's not "pay-per-usage". (There might be some "volume" discount, but the overall cost would still be drastically higher.)
I'm not strictly opposed to a tiered plan, but that's not pay-per-usage. It's no more "fair" than the current system. It just means that heavy users have the option to pay extra rather than getting capped. Everyone else would still pay about the same amount, and the guy using 1MB/month is still subsidizing the guy using 250GB/month. Assuming those top 5% aren't going to pay drastically more, everyone else would have to pay about the same on average to keep revenues constant.
Perhaps you have a different idea in mind for how the plan should work, and I'm not understanding your idea. If so, please clarify how you think AT&T should charge, and how the new plan would maintain revenue.
- mikeash 15y agoThe idea itself is simple: charge a fixed amount for the connection itself, to cover things like physical line maintenance, billing, customer service, etc. Charge a variable amount for use of the connection. That variable amount does not have to be a fixed dollars-per-byte rate. I'd imagine that the casual e-mail users would pay on the order of $20-30/month (Comcast already offers such a plan in my area, making it cheap by limiting the speed rather than the transfer quantity), average users would pay about what they pay now ($50-60), and heavy users might pay $100-200.
- dpark 15y agoSorry, but can you clarify how much you expect the fixed connection to cost? It sounds fine to charge a fixed connection fee, but I kind of doubt that the revenue works out the same unless the fixed fee is nearly the cost of the current service. You say that the transfer cost doesn't have to be a fixed dollar/byte, but if it's not, what are you envisioning? If you charge $10 for the first GB and $10 for the next ten GB, you're just on a tiered plan. You say that light users would pay $20-30, average users would pay $50-60, and heavy users would pay $100-200. I can't see a lot of people willing to pay $200 for home broadband service (I also can't see the FCC allowing it). I have a hard time seeing most of them paying $100 for just Internet access, honestly, and even at that rate it'd be hard to argue that light users at $20-$30 aren't still subsidizing the heavy users. 4x the cost for 12x the bandwidth? Unless we're assuming that the fixed connection fee is $20? Truthfully, I don't think a lot of people will want the fluctuating bill from month-to-month, either, even low-usage customers. It's nice to know that you owe Comcast $X every month so that you can budget. Comcast's speed-limited plans are entirely different. Telcos are competing based on bandwidth, not transfer amount. Comcast is offering several plans in that space, none of which are actually competing based on usage.