4 ms·
Helpful, interesting, yes. BUT not a real critique on this paper which specifically does not claim anything regarding similarity with the original. This happen
by amitport 5y ago
Helpful, interesting, yes. BUT not a real critique on this paper which specifically does not claim anything regarding similarity with the original.
This happens a lot with junior peer reviewers, they focus more on what the paper isn't or could be instead of what's actually there.
- savolai 5y agoSure, if you are evaluating at whether the claims are accurate on that level of precision, similarity may not be relevant. However for the rest of us, evaluating whether the work is relevant in the surrounding world really is important. And for that, resemblance to originals is critical in some use cases. I.e. we're evaluating a fit for specific use cases. Do you believe that is not a useful discussion?