5 ms·
I always feel these sorts of posts are misguided. They portray VSCode gaining market share as something other than an marketing investment by Microsoft. Simil
by taeric 5y ago
I always feel these sorts of posts are misguided. They portray VSCode gaining market share as something other than an marketing investment by Microsoft. Similar vibes go for why Java rose to popularity.
At some level, to build a market, you have to invest in marketing.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYou need marketing. Someone has to know your language exists, and is useful, and why it's useful. But to build a lasting language, you need a language that solves real problems better than other alternatives. Java promised three things, and delivered two and a half. It promised - and delivered - an end to manual memory management. It promised and delivered a huge, thorough, useful library. And it promised and kind of half-delivered "write once, run anywhere". That worked well enough to be at least somewhat useful, and failed enough to be really annoying. Marketing can get you in the door. To stay there, though, you need something that is actually useful.
- taeric 5y agoI feel you are dodging my assertion. Java promised those, with a stupid large marketing budget that shoved it down the throats of anyone near computers at the time. VSCode probably has more money going into developer reach out than I can imagine. And I can imagine big numbers. Am I claiming that intrinsic quality is fabricated? Not intentionally. I am claiming that it only goes so far.
- pjmlp 5y agoThere was no "stupid large marketing budget" in 1996, when the only thing available was the JDK, and we had to use emacs/vi/Ultraedit to write our Java programms and rely on makefiles to build the whole thing. Yet our distributed computing department decided to move right away into Java from C to teach distributed systems, thanks RMI and a coherent toolchain across the platforms we had on the labs. Similarly by 1998 the compiler development classes had moved from C into Java, thanks tooling like SableCC. By 2000, IBM that used to be a big Smalltalk vendor, and used Smalltalk as foundation for their Visual Age IDEs, moved into Java, and from Visual Age ashes Eclipse was born. Borland added a Java IDE to their collection, while Symantec not only did the same, they also created their own Java implementation. Ah, and then there was this fellow called Anders Hejlsberg that left Borland to Microsoft, and joined Visual J++ team. That is real work, and people paying real money for products. We didn't need someone shoving it down our throats to appreciate what it brought into the 1996 - 2000 computing landscape.
- taeric 5y agoYou are comparing the budget to push Java, the language, with every other editor. My assertion is there wasn't a journalist, college student, or product manager even closely related to computers that wasn't courted with regards to Java being the best language of all time. You do hint at another angle I left out. Getting Microsoft to pour money into this landscape, in the form of Visual J++, was probably more key than makes sense. It is very much like real estate, in that regard. You want to spend where other people are spending, if you want the best return.
- robomartin 5y agoA tangent, yet I think it is in the same domain: When I see a new movie advertised incessantly, I conclude it must be bad-to-terrible. A good movie, product, language needs little to no marketing.
- taeric 5y agoDepends how much you trust the marketing channel. I recall back in the day, if Penny Arcade promoted something, I probably liked it. (Note, this may still be the case.) Similar, if a few of the trusted artists and such I have on Twitter recommend something, in willing to buy it near instantly. Otherwise, the marketing budget is merely correlated with the product budget. And, to a large extent, big budget productions are predictable. In that you can usually easily predict if you will like it.
- kamaal 5y agoOn a tangential note, Java doesn't even have a decent documentation site these days. The documentation page feels like its from 2002. In fact its more like non existent. I'd like to think that's a non starter for some one new starting a project in Java.
- simiones 5y agoAre you talking about the API docs[0]? Or about some official tutorial page for Java the language [1]? The Java tutorials are seriously out of date (they even mention explicitly that they were written for Java 8, and that they may refer features that are no longer available). However the Javadoc is well maintained and quite useful, discoverable and thorough in my experience. Certainly one of the best native library docs that I've seen. [0] https://docs.oracle.com/en/java/javase/12/docs/api/index.html https://docs.oracle.com/en/java/javase/12/docs/api/index.htm... [1] https://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/ https://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/
- kamaal 5y agoI got -2 points for stating the very noticeably obvious. That pretty much sums up just how rusty and old Java has become over the years. So what is the way to learn Java in 2021? Buy 2 - 3 Paperback books? These days even Perl has documentation on a site that belongs to 2021. These are some things that you need to do to make your language accessible to people wanting to start new projects. As of now the only real way to read something about Java on the internet is adhoc answers on StackOverflow.
- mixedCase 5y agoNot everything successful is due to marketing. VSCode is extremely accessible, performant enough, has a huge ecosystem tuned for a plug'n'play experience and is free, among other graces. It's just a great text editor for programmer's to get productive fast, both beginners and experts.
- taeric 5y agoI'm torn. I'm not meaning to claim that marketing is the sole requirement for success. That said, when the topic is raising the profile, I see profile as market share. Which... Needs a marketing budget.
- xvilka 5y agoIf only it wasn't Electron...
- p1necone 5y agoIt may be an Electron app, but a lot of custom engineering has gone into the core text editing stuff - https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2018/03/23/text-buffer-reimplementation https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2018/03/23/text-buffer-r...
- evilduck 5y agoWhy do you care? Serious question. Have you ever compared the system resource demands of emacs and vim or neovim when you add enough plugins or extensions to reach feature parity with VS Code? They get to be just about as demanding on your disk space, ram and idle cpu.
- p1necone 5y agoI don't give a shit about Microsoft but VS Code is really good. It's performant, easily customizable and has a healthy extension ecosystem for most popular languages. Microsoft doesn't exactly have a fantastic rap with developers, especially OSS developers - do you really think it would have become this widely used if it wasn't good?
- taeric 5y agoI feel I can claim the same on emacs. Such that this rings kinda hollow for me. :(
- p1necone 5y agoI'll concede the healthy extension ecosystem is possibly a result of the marketing budget ("Developer Outreach" being the preferred euphemism). I suspect the learning curve is probably a big part of Emacs lack of mainstream success (same with Vim/Neovim).
- taeric 5y agoPretty much this. When called "developer outreach", it doesn't trigger nearly the backlash as calling it "marketing." But... these are the same things. The learning curve on all software is stupid hard to pin down. Consider, arduino has been a massive success in the embedded hobby market. Why? Nothing really easy or clever about it. Just cheap and clearly marketed for what it can and intends to do.
- sokoloff 5y agoI think the Arduino example might be stronger on the “they finally made it easy” than you give it credit. I had done some electronics and micro-controllers work in college, so I wasn’t starting from zero, but the simplicity of the open an example, click upload, and watch it succeed was pretty magical. I’d tried with only modest progress to do some PIC development (as a hobbyist) a few times in the years in between. Arduino was an undetectable amount of effort to get the examples to work. That, in turn, enables a bunch of GitHub and YouTube style of collaboration among regular, non-wizards who can hack something to a basically working condition, share it, and have someone be semi-confident that they can do it too. Professionals sneer at the Arduino IDE (and its inherent removal of gatekeeping), but it’s massively popular because it’s easy. (It’s not because it’s a great IDE for sure; it’s the least pleasant program that I use somewhat regularly.)
- mbrodersen 5y agoWhat marketing? I use VSCode because it is really really good. Better than anything else I have tried (including Emacs). Emacs feels like it hasn’t evolved for 50+ years. The kind of thing that my grand dad might have appreciated but not something that a modern person would use.
- mbrodersen 5y agoWow apparently some Emacs lovers don’t like it when somebody points out that Emacs is the Ford T of editors :)
- diskzero 5y agoJust don't start criticizing vi next. Then you will be in real trouble!
- mbrodersen 5y agoDon’t worry. I am brave but not stupid ;)
- overgard 5y agoThe only marketing I've ever seen for VSCode has been word of mouth
- mhh__ 5y agoI have never seen an official emacs Youtube Short, whereas Microsoft are making some for VSCode