5 ms·
Woman with 3 Properties Left Homeless Because Tenants Couldn't Be Evicted
- anemoiac 5y agoThe article doesn't explain how this woman supposedly became homeless. Was she evicted from a property she was renting to live in? Did her bank foreclose on her residence? Given the moratorium on foreclosures and evictions, I'm not sure how a lack of money due to her tenants' unpaid rent could cause her to become homeless.
- zugi 5y agoI mean it doesn't really matter all that much, but I think I read elsewhere that she broke up with her long-term boyfriend and had to move out. Normally that wouldn't be a problem for someone who owns 3 houses. But her tenants aren't paying so she's broke and isn't allowed to kick them out and live in her own house.
- vmception 5y agoShe is allowed to list the property for sale though. But in any case, I would probably go to the media first too. But also list the property for sale. Not my problem which part of the story they go with. At least I could point to why I sold the properties, to any other sentimental stakeholders.
- ganoushoreilly 5y agoGood luck selling a home with an existing tenant that's not paying.
- dragontamer 5y ago> moratorium on foreclosures and evictions That only applies to some areas of the country, and I believe the supreme court just struck it down. So as of now, applies no where iirc.
- gizmo686 5y agoThe Supreme Court struck down the federal moritorium [0]; and there wording made it clear the issue was the CDC exceeding it's authority under current law (as opposed to a fundamental constitutional issue). As such, this ruling has no bearing on state issued eviction moratoriums. Having said that, the New York moratorium (which was passed as a law by the state legislature) expired today (August 31, 2021), so that is a moot point in this case. For completeness, I will point out that the US Supreme court also evaluated this state law [1], and mostly allowed it to continue. The only change they made was allowing landlords to contest the claim of hardship from the tenants. For further completeness, that was the only part of the New York law the Court was asked to rule on, so conceivably they would still have overturned the entire thing if the proper case was brought before them. [0] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a23_ap6c.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a23_ap6c.pdf [1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a8_3fb4.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a8_3fb4.pdf
- ryan_lane 5y agoYou've made a business from renting people property. You've staked your ability to pay your bills on that business, and you've found yourself in a situation where your business is no longer viable. This sounds like a poor investment strategy to me. Should all of your tenants be homeless so that your business succeed? The premise here is also absurd. The market for rental properties is extremely hot right now. Sell one of the properties and don't become homeless. You have options. Your tenants probably do not.
- cko 5y agoThe standard advice is to have enough cash reserves to cover all your mortgages for 6-12 months. It's been more than 12 months but most conforming loans have been able to get forbearance, and yeah, not sure why selling one wasn't an option in this scenario. Probably wouldn't have gotten top dollar if there's a nonpaying tenant in there but better than involuntary homelessness. Of course this article is light on details.
- zugi 5y ago> you've found yourself in a situation where your business is no longer viable I mean to be fair here the government instituted a policy that basically took her property and allocated it for someone else's use for free, depriving her of its use either for revenue or as a place to live. It's a bit disingenuous to spin this as some sort of speculative investment gone wrong.
- Guest42 5y agoI’d claim there’s a good chance that mass evictions would lend themselves to lower property values and rental incomes which would also lead to an unsuccessful business strategy and a similar outcome. Whether or not this is preferable would then be a separate conversation of hypotheticals.
- m0zg 5y agoMass evictions would lead to everything opening back up overnight. It's utterly pointless to have _any_ anti-COVID measures at all when a vaccine is available to anyone who wants it. Moreover, it's strongly counterproductive. Let me explain this to folks as simply and unambiguously as I can. Have you ever had a cold? Yes? You will have COVID in the near future. No ifs or buts about it. You will have it, several times each year, for the rest of your life, it's endemic and unavoidable. Do you not want to die of COVID? Get the vax. The calculus is _really_ simple here. This should be the messaging from the CDC and everyone else. People (vaxxed and unvaxxed alike) seem to think they'll be able to "avoid" it somehow. That option was off the table as early as in January of 2020. Why are we subjecting millions of small landlords to this hadship, especially in the cases where tenants _can_ pay?
- codingdave 5y agoSell a property, get an equity loan, etc. Clearly I don't know the full story, but it doesn't sound plausible that someone who owns three properties doesn't have enough knowledge of real estate to find a way to monetize them other than rental income.
- throwjd764glug 5y ago> Sell a property, get an equity loan, etc. I believe this is how hedge funds are planning to become renting quasi-monopolists: https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/02/business/family-homes-wall-street/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/02/business/family-homes-wall-st... Renters desperate to sell because they're facing bankruptcy from having their property effectively confiscated is just what they need to keep the prices low. Especially since they're all getting desperate around the same time, flooding the market with supply
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> get an equity loan You are assuming she has good credit.
- snicker7 5y agoBill de Blasio should be made to provide accomodations for her in his own home.
- rasz 5y agoShe can live in one of the homeless shelters run by Cuomo's sister, NY is already paying $3K/month per bed for those.
- TrackerFF 5y agoI'm not from NY, or the US for that mater - but has there been a freeze on the banks from pursuing action? When there are moratoriums, it would only be fair to also bar the banks from taking action against the landlords - even more so when there's an emergency fund.
- jonahbenton 5y ago"Newsweek" should not be a permissible link target on HN.
- cratermoon 5y agoWhy not? HN allows substack and the Cato Institute.
- effingwewt 5y agoBecause it's on par with The Telegraph.
- cratermoon 5y agoI can't disagree with that, but it doesn't make it bannable.
- effingwewt 5y agoI agree completely, I was just saying why it was bad. It's damn near on the level of the National Enquirer, but yea Im in the 'if you don't like it dont read it' camp. Bans are not healthy.
- fortran77 5y agoNo! Because they report on stories that go against his fixed mindset -- so he feels that nobody should be able to discuss them.
- danShumway 5y agoThe title of the submission matches the title of the article, but the title of the article itself is doing a lot of editorializing here. A more accurate description of the situation directly from the article: > Only $1.7 billion of the $46.5 billion Emergency Rental Assistance Program has been distributed by state and local governments Both the landlord and her tenants interviewed in this article do not have the money to rectify this situation, the landlord is stuck without income because of Covid, the tenant is stuck without income because of Covid trying to care for an entire family. Without government assistance, one of those two parties is going to be homeless, period. You will either have landlords suffering a loss of income (sometimes catastrophically) or you will have mass evictions of low-income renters who have no way to afford housing during the pandemic. So the entire point of rent moratoriums was that the government was going to step in and provide resources to people affected, to try and prevent these kinds of no-win situations. That money hasn't appeared, despite being approved by Congress. So now we're having a debate about whether it's more moral to force a landlord with 3 properties to live in her van, or whether it's more moral to force a renter caring for her daughter and autistic son to be homeless. Both of those outcomes are bad. The real story here is, after the government approved $46.5 billion to help prevent situations like this, why only around a tenth of that assistance has actually been distributed to the people who desperately need it.
- JohnClark1337 5y agoPoliticians never approve spending unless they have a way of pocketing some of it.
- airhead969 5y agoPoor rich, rent-seeking property owners being abused by actual poor people who have no choice, no assets, and income reduced or eliminated by a global pandemic. This is a cherry-picked example to demonize the poor and demand evictions in the name of profit. The homeless and very poor rationally should demand housing.