3 ms·
Between this and some other stories from early nuclear age, it makes me feel as if that system was designed by software engineers. If it's known that the contr
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
Between this and some other stories from early nuclear age, it makes me feel as if that system was designed by software engineers.
If it's known that the control rod is supposed to be between 0 and X inches out, and going past Y inches (Y > X) will likely cause a fatal failure, one would expect someone to machine a piece of metal that makes in impossible to move the rod further out than Y inches.
I read those accounts of people manipulating nuclear reactors by hand, and can't stop but think: this is dumb, even for 1950s era technology.
- leoc 5y ago> it makes me feel as if that system was designed by software engineers SL-1 feels as if it was designed and operated by Kerbals. TFA actually does mention the reactor and the accident > SL-1, a stationary low-power nuclear reactor in Idaho, blew up during refueling, killing three men. but that barely hints at just how eye-widening the whole saga was: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOt7xDKxmCM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOt7xDKxmCM To be fair, it is apparently considered likely that the overextraction of the rod was a deliberate murder-suicide. But yes, it seems that there's a reason that the US Navy still has a nuclear power program and the Army doesn't ( https://www.historynet.com/going-nuclear-idaho-falls.htm https://www.historynet.com/going-nuclear-idaho-falls.htm seems good; I am not an expert).
- HPsquared 5y agoThere was a lot of time pressure in those days of the Cold War. The other side was also working rapidly without much concern for safety. It was probably a consciously-made balance of risk, with relatively "minor" accidents here and there as a result of rushed development vs. the risks associated with getting overtaken by the Soviets. Technological superiority, particularly in that field, was a major factor in the balance of power at that time.
- Buttons840 5y agoThat manually operated control rod was sophisticated compared to some of the earlier experiments. They used to stack bricks around a chunk of uranium, so the bricks would reflect neutrons back at the uranium. Eventually, once you stack enough bricks around the uranium it goes super critical and just goes nuts. They used to manually search out this super critical threshold by manually stacking bricks and then slowly move that final brick towards and away from the uranium and watch it balance on the line between sub critical and super critical. One day, someone dropped the brick and there was a blue flash. Lots of neutrons were released that day. People died from radiation exposure soon after. There's also a story about a fuel rod getting jammed, so they tried to force it with a crane and ended up breaking it in half, spilling highly radioactive water all over the place, and then the fuel rod catches on fire because it's not being cooled anymore. It's comical how quickly these disasters escalate. Read https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-Mountains/dp/1605986801 https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-... , it's accurate and relatively fun given the subject. One of the chapters is titled "The US Government almost never lost nuclear weapons", which I find subtly amusing.
- joncrane 5y agoWhat about the "demon core?" It was a core of highly radioactive material, and instead of bricks, there were two hollowed out hemispheres made of some metal that reflected the radioactivity. Some guy put one hemisphere below the core, and had another one on top AND WAS USING A SCREWDRIVER to carefully titrate how "closed" the top hemisphere was to the bottom one. His hand slipped and he killed himself and some colleagues. Apparently the "demon core" got its name because it was involved in more than one supercritical accident.
- Buttons840 5y agoI think the demon core was the "chunk of uranium" they were stacking bricks around. It's been several years since I read the book so my memory is fuzzy. I think the later experiments used the metal hemispheres instead of bricks.
- Buttons840 5y ago"The core was placed within a stack of neutron-reflective tungsten carbide bricks and the addition of each brick moved the assembly closer to criticality. While attempting to stack another brick around the assembly, Daghlian accidentally dropped it onto the core and thereby caused the core to go well into supercriticality, a self-sustaining critical chain reaction. He quickly moved the brick off the assembly, but received a fatal dose of radiation. He died 25 days later from acute radiation poisoning." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demon_core https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demon_core The Wikipedia page describes the 2nd accident as well, involving a screwdriver and metal hemispheres.
- numpad0 5y agoOr safety education has improved far more than nuclear technologies did in the past 70 years.