3 ms·
I think there has to be a line somewhere between protecting employees right to talk about work (that has pretty strong protections, even public comments online
by duxup 5y ago
I think there has to be a line somewhere between protecting employees right to talk about work (that has pretty strong protections, even public comments online can be protected between employees have been protected) and ... having the employer host a slack channel.
What happens if that channel gets really nasty and some employees are bullying others (for any reason) or just anything bad comes of it?
The employer is by default privy to the whole channel too.
I just think recorded info like this hosted by the employer is inherently a bad idea and everyone would be better served if the employees ran some channel of their own hosted elsewhere.
- aaomidi 5y ago> What happens if that channel gets really nasty and some employees are bullying others (for any reason) or just anything bad comes of it? "We don't condone the existence of this channel, however due to labor laws, we can't and won't take action against it. If the discussion of this channel moves away from primarily being labor and organization related we will archive the channel, give all of you access to the archive, and shut it down. This is to prevent the harassment and not to block organization efforts. If you feel uncomfortable in this chat, please let us know and we can silently remove you from it. We also encourage employees that want to organize to use alternative methods that aren't hosted by Apple."
- chickenpotpie 5y agoAll too often people on hacker news will say “well what we’re they supposed to do?” and being honest and open is always the answer.
- nickff 5y agoThe other side on Hacker News will say 'be open and honest', but fail to indemnify the person at hand against potential losses. Talk is cheap, unless you're the one who has to pay for the consequences.
- aaomidi 5y agoAgain this is a legal requirement. If the cost of allowing this means Apple is going to tank then maybe it should tank.
- nickff 5y agoSo, if a company can't afford to enable "nast[iness]", they "should tank"? I am trying to take everyone's argument at face value, but yours doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
- tshaddox 5y agoWouldn't bullying be a reason for discipline regardless of what medium is occurred in? That doesn't seem relevant to Slack channels about any particular topic.
- elicash 5y agoYou suggest having a line, but as a top-level comment alludes to, there historically has been one and it's right where the author of this article drew it. Companies have the right in most circumstances to say "no hanging up non-work pamphlets on the bulletin board." But once you allow non-work pamphlets, you can't discriminate against against these types of issues. That, sadly in my view, changed under the Trump NLRB specifically when it came to email (which one could argue slack is similar to). Though it's likely to change again under Democrats. By the way, in terms of "bullying" it's worth noting that the law protecting the ability of people to talk about workplace conditions using company resources like a bulletin board or slack channel doesn't have to allow for abuse behavior by coworkers. If you're seeking a line, that can be it, and it's based in current law, too. This final comment isn't aimed at you, but I wish the "anti-cancel culture" activists took this seriously as a free speech issue. This kind of thing is much more common and a bigger deal than a select group of folks who have to rely on substack for their audiences to follow their thoughts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 5y agoIt's not even much more common: it's the same thing. "Canceling" is people losing their jobs over suspicion, rumors, accusations and unpopular opinions on no material grounds. With labor rights, that can't happen. You have to have a specific, pre-negotiated reason. Somehow the people who moan endlessly about someone getting fired for liking a tweet are the same people who will fight to the death to preserve the ability for employers to fire you for liking a tweet.
- thomasahle 5y ago> I just think recorded info like this hosted by the employer is inherently a bad idea and everyone would be better served if the employees ran some channel of their own hosted elsewhere. I wonder if the employees would be allowed to set up their slack channel elsewhere, or if Apple would prefer having control.
- duxup 5y agoIf I'm magically Apple CEO, I want it off my systems so some rando manager or VP doesn't go do anything bad with that information... But if I'm 'bad'... I want it.
- jfrunyon 5y ago> What happens if that channel gets really nasty and some employees are bullying others (for any reason) or just anything bad comes of it? What if the Earth ended yesterday? It doesn't matter, because it didn't happen. Also, that would be a disciplinary matter for those employees, not the chatroom. > I just think recorded info like this hosted by the employer is inherently a bad idea and everyone would be better served if the employees ran some channel of their own hosted elsewhere. Have you ever tried to get your friends to join you on some new social or messaging platform? And failed miserably? Yeah. Now try getting random coworkers to do it. The entire purpose of banning this room was to raise the barrier against organizing. And it did so effectively.