3 ms·
NPR Trashes Free Speech. A Brief Response
- avmich 5y ago> It’s unsurprising that NPR — whose tone these days is so precious and exclusive that five minutes of listening to any segment makes you feel like you’re wearing a cucumber mask at a Plaza spa — papers over this part of the equation Well said :) pretty funny, I mean. The subject under consideration, however, isn't too clear - is there an opinion that speech limits in principle can't be justified by benefits the speech critics claim? It's possible - after all, a crude and simple rule is easier to follow or see it broken - but not completely obvious. Maybe I'm not seeing something?
- retox 5y agoAny limit on free speech is short-sighted in the extreme, and only makes 'sense' in a totalitarian regime which will never become democratic. At some point the speech you agree with today will be illegal tomorrow, and at that time the laws that restrict speech that you so cherished will make it impossible to ever go back to the previous position, making violent overthrow of the regime the only option.
- Barrin92 5y agoIt's kind of ironic to attack NPR for allegedly not producing a well thought out argument on the topic, but then proceeding barely talk about what was presented in the show, and instead attacking the presentation (harpsichord music?), the listener demographic, 'elite aristocrats' and so on. He mostly just sounds offended by what was said because by no means was there a 'trashing'. Personally I don't think there is much justification for these JS Mill type arguments. They're based on a sort of pre-Darwinian worldview where individuals voluntary with rational mind engage in free-speech to reach enlightenment. I think that's not a scientifically tenable position today. It makes more sense to think of communication as a network, people as vectors in it that exist to spread ideas. Dawkins of course was a proponent of this but even earlier Jung summed it up as "people don't have ideas, ideas have people'. Free speech doesn't produce 'true' ideas, it produces fit(!) ideas and that really takes the principle off a pedestal where it doesn't belong. I'd argue for a systems-thinking based approach. Don't think of free-speech policy from a standpoint of individual rights outwards, but start with the health of public discourse.
- zepto 5y ago> but then proceeding barely talk about what was presented in the show, and instead attacking the presentation (harpsichord music?), the listener demographic, 'elite aristocrats' and so on. This is a misrepresentation. His critique of the presentation is warranted, and he also clearly addresses the content, for example he presents a detailed and informative critique of the show’s poor understanding of Brandenburg vs Ohio. > start with the health of public discourse Who gets to decide what makes the discourse healthy?
- Barrin92 5y ago>for example he presents a detailed and informative critique of the show’s poor understanding of Brandenburg vs Ohio. I don't think he is clear on this at all. On the one hand he uses an absolutist reading of the case to justify his pretty scathing attack on NPR: "This was the essence of the ACLU’s argument, and it’s the same one made by people like Hugo Black and Benjamin Hooks and congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton, who said, “It is technically impossible to write an anti-speech code that cannot be twisted against speech nobody means to bar. It has been tried and tried and tried.” On the other hand, he seems to contradict that point at the end: "Yes, speech can be harmful, which is why journalists like me have always welcomed libel and incitement laws and myriad other restrictions, and why new rules will probably have to be concocted for some of the unique problems of the Internet age" He seems to be mostly attacking NPR because he has an axe to grind with the media rather than talking about the issue where it's not clear to what degree his own position differs from, or what is fundamentally wrong with it. >Who gets to decide what makes the discourse healthy? Authority. The same institutions that get to decide anything else. What I'm arguing is that, if you are okay with say, the police limiting freedom of association in the public space to ensure the safety of a community, you ought to be okay with limits on freedom of speech for that same reason. There's nothing mystical about it, nothing extra, nothing that warrants dogmatic defense. The reason why people hesitate with this is, as I said in the first post, that regulating speech amounts to acknowledging that this sort of rationalist individualism is a myth. It's an attack on ideology in a way that many other limitations of freedom are not.
- 5y ago
- dredmorbius 5y agoPoint of fact: On the Media is NOT NPR: BROOKE GLADSTONE: On the Media is produced by WNYC and distributed by NPR - what that means is that WNYC owns and produces the show. It licenses it to NPR, which distributes it to the public radio stations, collects fees from those stations, takes a cut and then gives the rest back to WNYC, to pay to produce the show. "This Is NOT NPR" https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/not-npr https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/not-npr