2 ms·
Naively I'd guess that it's because sound is all munged up into two serial ports, whereas color is perceived simultaneously through a matrix of rods and cones o
by pessimizer 5y ago
Naively I'd guess that it's because sound is all munged up into two serial ports, whereas color is perceived simultaneously through a matrix of rods and cones of different sensitivities, each dealing with a tiny section of the visual field, and when that field changes, doing consistency checks with each other, filtering out effects due to changing light sources and qualities.
That seems pretty consistent with this, which as far as I can tell is saying that people who perform perfect pitch get good at filtering out common timbres.
I bet it'd be pretty easy to train people to identify 12 sine wave tones consistently, at the same volume and from the same position.
- jacquesm 5y agoSound perception is extremely parallel at the physical level, each and every one of the hairs in the cochlear duct (a fluid filled chamber that acts as a biological spectrum analyzer). Your characterization is not in line with how things actually work. > I bet it'd be pretty easy to train people to identify 12 sine wave tones consistently, at the same volume and from the same position. I'd bet against you. In fact that is a lot harder than identifying the 12 base pitches on for instance a piano.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Sound perception is extremely parallel at the physical level, each and every one of the hairs in the cochlear duct (a fluid filled chamber that acts as a biological spectrum analyzer). But isn't the result a curve that can be expressed as the simple superposition of waves? That simply can't be done for vision. (edit: without breaking time by encoding scanlines - which is just serializing it.) > I'd bet against you. In fact that is a lot harder than identifying the 12 base pitches on for instance a piano. I'd take it. I'd imagine it'd be as easy to train somebody to recognize 12 pitches from a particular piano in a particular room as it would to train someone on sine waves. But my point was it'd be easier to train them on either than on pitch in general, from many different instruments with different timbres.