6 ms·
This would be a good thing if it were true. Politics is not a product where your choice of whether to consume the red, blue, or green thing is an irrelevant exp
by pessimizer 5y ago
This would be a good thing if it were true. Politics is not a product where your choice of whether to consume the red, blue, or green thing is an irrelevant expression of your personality or style. It's always life or death, and that fact is disguised when it doesn't mean your life or death.
This survey is also corrupted by self-reporting. People like to pretend that they're more tolerant than they are (especially when they don't have a comfortable or civil argument for their intolerance.) In fact, I bet if you followed up with a bit of a Keynesian beauty contest, you'd find that they report that the tribe that they belong to is far more tolerant than the enemy tribe.
And for a fact pulled out of my ass, I bet if you checked the proportion of people who married outside of their race or religion 50 years ago, it would be <1% (at least for people who claimed a race or religion.) If you checked now, the numbers would be 4-6% IIRC. That's an improvement. You might find a higher percentage of mixed Democrat/Republican relationships 50 years ago (maybe), but if that number has dropped, that's also an improvement. Material differences in opinions about how the world should be run and people should behave should at least be more significant than race or (the mystical aspects, not the moral codes of) religion. It means that society is becoming more supportive of people trying to escape their tribal affiliations. 80 years ago, in the US, there were laws actively preventing this.
- draw_down 5y agoIn America, politics is indeed a middle class-dominated area where people choose their product. When matters do come down to life and death, such as in wars, the two teams do not proceed materially differently. There is a reason we had 20 years of war in Afghanistan for example, and it ain’t because only one of the teams kept it going. I agree on your point about people’s view of their own tolerance.
- reccanti 5y agoPeople on this site like to mindlessly parrot the “we’ve become too partisan and divided these days” narrative, but what are they actually proposing? Oh wait… https://twitter.com/rottenindenmark/status/1432643902322925572?s=21 https://twitter.com/rottenindenmark/status/14326439023229255...
- shkkmo 5y agoThat is an offensive, inaccurate and entirely unproductive comment. We are proposing a wide range of changes that would break or weaken the hold of the two party system in America. Our political system of pure winner takes all regional representation in partisanly gerrymandered districts strongly encourages negative partisanship and decreases the actual voice that voters have in how their country is run.
- reccanti 5y agoYou can do that and also not date people who are against LGBT rights?
- specialist 5y agoSure, if you think that'll help. Or what you must do for your own sanity. I get it. I have friends who are in very tough spots who have had to make hard choices. I can't and won't judge any one else's life choices. We're all a little bit confused, exhausted, anxious, and maybe even a bit insane. And just trying to do the best we can. Even my crazy uncle who forwards me emails about liberals like me destroying real America. Honestly, the 2016 presidential broke me. Then around 2018 I decided my relationships were more important than being right. For instance, it was our turn to do eldercare (and other family emergencies), so I had to cooperate with my family. Because that's what's best for our mom. I definitely iced out the more toxic individuals (eg "Obama's a Muslim!") who just wanted to fight. Ask me again in 10 years, after our mom's passed, if I made the right choice.
- specialist 5y agoHobbs is a gem. I just listened to the episodes on Political Correctness (#123) and Cancel Culture (#125). So good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You're_Wrong_About https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You're_Wrong_About FWIW, my SO voted for Trump. We just don't talk about politics, and somehow manage to make it work.
- reccanti 5y ago
- leetcrew 5y agoI disagree. I mean sure, it's a good thing (if true) that race is less significant than politics in choosing a partner, but why should we have to pick one? unless you're part of a very select group of activists, politicians, or wealthy donors, your impact on world issues is pretty much negligible. the political opinions of the average person are much less significant than they might think. but what we can do is have a strong impact on the people who are actually in our lives, and that has very little to do with politics. if I change my political positions to please a potential partner, that doesn't really change the big picture. if I refuse to date someone because of their political views, I again have not moved the needle at scale, but I have closed the door on a potentially happy partnership. my parents have had a long and happy marriage despite deep disagreements over political issues. the disagreement is so strong that they had to agree years ago to simply not have those discussions. I guess that's not exactly the model of tolerance, but I am glad they found a way around that. if they hadn't, either my family would have been ripped in half, or I wouldn't have been born at all. and the rest of the world would be the same as it is today.
- reccanti 5y agoBRB changing my gender back so I can date a transphobe. Glad I changed my political position!
- leetcrew 5y agookay, that's a good counterexample. I wouldn't expect you to be able to have a good relationship with someone who doesn't agree you should exist and/or your gender identity is real. but take gun control for example, which seems to be pretty high on the list. does it really matter whether a potential partner is for/against gun control? one person's opinion is not going to change the law of the land. I'd think it would only matter whether you could come to an agreement on whether there would be guns in the home you share.
- klyrs 5y ago> I'd think it would only matter whether you could come to an agreement on whether there would be guns in the home you share. That does sound like a dealbreaker to me. A gun collector isn't going to marry somebody who won't tolerate guns in the house, right?
- jandrewrogers 5y agoYou are too pessimistic. Inter-racial marriage alone in the US went from ~3% in the 1960s to ~17% as of 2015 (Pew Research). In some regions of the US, such as the West, it is approaching 25% of all new marriages. That is pretty well-mixed considering many people live in locales with few opportunities to date outside their race.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> You might find a higher percentage of mixed Democrat/Republican relationships 50 years ago (maybe), but if that number has dropped, that's also an improvement.... It means that society is becoming more supportive of people trying to escape their tribal affiliations. Fewer cross-political-party marriages mean that we're becoming more supportive of people trying to escape their tribal affiliations? Not if you count Red/Blue as one of the tribal affiliations, it doesn't...