3 ms·
> "Do not be offended if someone suggests you are not being reasonable." I don't think they consulted with a psychologist before coming up with this "principle
by crazygringo 5y ago
> "Do not be offended if someone suggests you are not being reasonable."
I don't think they consulted with a psychologist before coming up with this "principle".
Telling someone they're not being reasonable is one of the worst things you can do in any conversation. And if you feel offended by it, that's entire normal and, well, reasonable.
Telling someone not to be offended is similarly completely counterproductive.
When you're in a difficult situation, you should generally avoid focusing on what you perceive to be personal characteristics of the other person, or on telling them how they "should" be responding -- and instead focus on objective realities that you can use shared problem-solving techniques on.
- e40 5y agoTo put a finer point on this, a very small percentage of people, when confronted with "you are being unreasonable" will react in a positive and/or productive way. I personally have never witnessed, in the conversations I've had or observed, it ever having a positive impact.
- xvedejas 5y agoComing at it from the other direction though, the very small percentage of people who, in my experience, do have a good reaction to "you are being unreasonable", have ended up realizing that they were in a scenario where they needed to think about conflict resolution. This attitude, although rare, has been extremely useful. Maybe this suggests the robustness principle: "be conservative in how you behave but liberal in what you accept from others".
- ozim 5y agoYes I read that principle description and that was my first thought. One should not tell others that they are unreasonable and be reasonable enough to understand that someone might still tell them that they are, then act accordingly.
- zzt123 5y agoI’ve had the opposite in my social circle. People generally try to be reasonable and so that suggestion is extremely rarely made. When received, it tends to be positively received as a time to self reflect and evaluate. That said, the wording used is more like “are you sure you’re approaching this reasonably?” rather than as an assured statement of “you are being unreasonable”, and I feel that difference may be significant in terms of distribution of response.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- posterboy 5y ago> I don't think they consulted with a psychologist before coming up with this "principle". This is ironically and needlessly confrontative. I think you are not being reasonable. Now don't get offended, I'm just the voice of reason telling you what is, and I already have my principles in place that won't be challenged. Me, unreasonable? That's quite the offensive thing to say, how dare you!
- 908B64B197 5y agoThis reads like a GPT-3 entry where the training data was Twitter.
- Baeocystin 5y agoAt this point, I am ~90% convinced that Shiri's Scissor is real. https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/
- fragmede 5y agoThe point isn't that telling someone else they're "not being reasonable" is a useful, or even productive tactic. The point is if someone else comes up to you, and (tactlessly) tells you that you're being unreasonable, that the smart move is to stop, take a step back, and fully consider their feedback, and not, as most people would do, immediately reject the advice. It would be entirely understandable, as a reflex involving hurt feelings, to disregard their feedback and blame it on some selfish petty motivations of that person. It might even be true. But if you don't want to surround yourself with yes men, take the time to strongly consider that you may actually be the unreasonable one in this circumstance.
- naasking 5y agoUnless you still throw temper tantrums when someone says you can't have or use something of theirs that you really want, our natural responses can be retrained. If this principle is part of training for staff at CMU, then receiving this comment could become a trigger to take a step back and reflect, rather than a trigger to become angry or defensive.