3 ms·
> A study shows that when leaders are randomly chosen, group performance actually improves Interesting, if true. Where can one find this study?
by bambax 15y ago
> A study shows that when leaders are randomly chosen, group performance actually improves
Interesting, if true. Where can one find this study?
- ckuehne 15y agoThe OP cites three sources at the bottom of the page. http://mindhacks.com/2009/02/12/leadership-can-be-based-on-quantity-not-quality http://mindhacks.com/2009/02/12/leadership-can-be-based-on-q... http://www.spring.org.uk/2009/07/how-newcomers-can-influence-established-groups.php http://www.spring.org.uk/2009/07/how-newcomers-can-influence... http://psycnet.apa.org/index.cfm?fa=buy.optionToBuy&id=1998-10613-003 http://psycnet.apa.org/index.cfm?fa=buy.optionToBuy&id=1... EDIT: cleaned links
- TastyMorsel 15y agoThe study mentioned in the mindhacks story can be found on the author's website: http://mors.haas.berkeley.edu/CAnderson%20Pilot%20Site/Pubs/Why%20do%20dominant%20personalities%20attain%20influence%20in%20groups.pdf http://mors.haas.berkeley.edu/CAnderson%20Pilot%20Site/Pubs/...
- ckuehne 15y agoThe hypothesis of this paper rings true (based on my experience).
- wccrawford 15y agoSome thoughts on that, not proven by anything that I know of: People who desperately want to be a leader are rarely suited for it. They tend to hunger for power, rather than feel the need to help the group. It's possible they are competent, but more likely that they will use the group to suit their own ends, rather than working for the group. People get jealous easily. If someone asks to be leader and gets it, others may feel jealous. If the leader is chosen randomly, it's harder to be jealous, since it was obviously fairly done.
- amirmc 15y ago> ...it's harder to be jealous, since it was obviously fairly done. I assuming by 'fairly done' you mean 'completely random'. If you meant it in the sense of 'just', then I'm not sure I agree.
- wccrawford 15y agoI didn't say it was done the best way. I said it was done fairly. As in, nobody had any advantage.
- Steve_Baker 15y agoI think regardless of the reasons why, people who want to be leaders, on the whole, clearly shouldn't be. Since these people comprise a small subset of the total of all people, simply choosing randomly will tend to not choose them. I doubt it has to do anything with fairness. Maybe "leaders" aren't as necessary as people think, and actually are a drain on productivity.