3 ms·
It assumes only that rent control controls rents. Are you saying that if landlords are required to enact rent control they have the power to unilaterally raise
by pydry 5y ago
It assumes only that rent control controls rents.
Are you saying that if landlords are required to enact rent control they have the power to unilaterally raise future market rents in response?
- gruez 5y ago> It assumes only that rent control controls rents. ...for the current tenant. When he leaves it goes up to make up for it, and then some to make up for the free call option.
- pydry 5y agoI'm struggling to see why you think landlords would be able to charge above market rate once rent control ends. (or alternatively, why they would choose to leave money on the table and rent below market rent if they weren't subjected to rent control) It doesn't make a lot of sense to me that they would (minor exceptions excluded) charge anything other than market rent.
- gruez 5y ago> I'm struggling to see why you think landlords would be able to charge above market rate once rent control ends. It won't be above market rate, but the market rate will go up to account for the call option. It's like if the city mandated all landlords to install AC (assume for this example this is for a region where most units don't have AC). Since this cost is applicable to most landlords, the landlords collectively will raise their rent because their costs have gone up.
- pydry 5y agoAs far as I can see it's exactly like being mandated to install AC - in that it would not change supply of housing and it would not change demand for housing. That is, unless there was a non-negligible number of landlords who would be so infuriated with spending, say, $2k on installing AC that they would take their house off the market (but not sell it) and therefore willingly forego, say, $2k of rent every single month. I don't see that as plausible, though. If you have an unsold rental unit doing nothing but collecting dust you're wasting money. In rent controlled cities like SF/NYC almost by definition rent is high, so these theoretical landlords would be leaving a lot of money on the table so if you think this effect is real you are obligated to assume that these landlords are behaving in an irrational manner.
- leetcrew 5y agothe pre-AC prices are already in equilibrium. mandating AC increases the cost of supplying housing, so it disturbs that equilibrium. who actually absorbs that increased cost depends on the elasticity of demand. for highly elastic goods, the producer/seller loses more of their surplus (ie, they cover most of the cost increase). but with a highly inelastic good like housing in a desirable location, it is much more likely that the consumer covers the larger part of the cost increase. this is basically equivalent to the effect of elasticity on tax incidence. you can view the cost of AC or forgone rent from rent control as a sort of tax. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand#Effect_on_tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand#Eff... another good example of an inelastic good is gas. people who commute can't easily change the amount of fuel they consume. if the gas tax goes up, or a barrel of oil becomes more expensive, your local gas station doesn't just make it up from their margin. they increase their prices, regardless of how accustomed people were to the previous price. tl;dr: the fact that a landlord can charge more after being forced to install AC does not imply that they could have just increased rent in the first place if they weren't so stupid.
- pydry 5y agoWhat tax incidence is is extremely clear to me. A careful reading of my previous comment should make it clear that I alluding to precisely that, in fact. Also it was explaining why it would 90%+ fall on the landlord in high rent locales like NYC/SF. Why you think it shouldn't fall on the landlord in high rent markets just because the supply of property is relatively inelastic isn't so clear to me.
- leetcrew 5y agodo you not agree that housing demand in nyc/sf is highly inelastic then? the rest kinda follows from that. or are you arguing that the supply itself is even more inelastic than the demand? I think part of the problem with this example is that $2k is just not very much money compared to rental income in those areas. I agree, it is hard to imagine landlords dropping out of a market where they can rent a studio for $2500+/month over a one-time $2000 expense. I argue it would still happen at the margins, but it might result in a market rent increase that is below the noise floor. still, it is a mistake to assume that all HCOL landlords are making money hand over fist. places with high rents tend to also have high price-to-rent ratios. landlords with recently purchased, mortgaged properties might not be making much profit, even with sky-high rents. if a lot of landlords are in this situation, the supply could be surprisingly elastic.