3 ms·
It looks like your example [1] was actually rather clear cut based on the actual use of the work and case law quoted in the court decision. I think in most cas
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
It looks like your example [1] was actually rather clear cut based on the actual use of the work and case law quoted in the court decision.
I think in most cases it is actually clear what "non-commercial use" looks like.
- ghaff 5y agoIt did spend four years going through the legal system even if, as a layperson, it seems clear cut and a dumb case. My primary interest is using photographs and I can pretty much guarantee that almost any use I might have beyond something like wallpaper on my personal computer, some number of people would argue is commercial because it has some connection, even if tenuous, to either my day job or other businesses.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe time the legal system takes to settle a case is another issue as is the reality that anyone can argue anything. What is commercial and non-commercial has to be judged on each specific case's merit, which obviously makes general discussions difficult beyond broad definitions, but in general it is not a big grey area.
- ghaff 5y agoThe grey area is massive. Take using photos. What if I run ads or have affiliate links on my blog? What if I'm a US not-for-profit that has $10s of millions in revenue? What if I'm giving a presentation at an industry event that I'm not being directly paid for but it's essentially part of my job? I could go on but I guarantee that if you surveyed the readers of this site many people would answer those questions differently. Effectively, if a lawyer were making the call of whether a particular use was OK, they'd tell you just not to use it because no use that you'd be asking a lawyer about is clearly OK.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThese are specific examples, and as mentioned there are an infinity of cases. I am not sure they are grey areas. For example, in general anything you do as part of your job at a commercial enterprise has a commercial purpose.
- ghaff 5y agoWell, see, I'm reasonably comfortable with using NC so long as I'm not selling or being directly paid for something. Otherwise, pretty much everything I have in public is associated with my job at a commercial enterprise or other business in some manner and I effectively can't use NC for anything non-trivial. So, without surveying the rest of HN, we already disagree on a wide swath of use and probably wouldn't change each other's minds.
- Semaphor 5y ago> What if I run ads or have affiliate links on my blog? FWIW, in Germany that would indeed make it a commercial endeavor. It gets even weirder with copyright, being part of a torrent swarm as uploading part has regularly been ruled as "commercial distribution".