4 ms·

I don't recall ever having heard about Blokada before, but looking it up now it doesn't seem recommended: https://gitlab.com/fdroid/fdroiddata/-/merge_requests/

• ignoramous 5y ago
  (I created that merge request) Blokada's UI is without peer and so it makes for a very good "just works" for the majority (in fact, from what I know, it is the most downloaded DNS-based content blocker on Android by far). However, it is disappointing that some of their decision-making is found wanting: https://www.reddit.com/r/privacytoolsIO/comments/papgeq/any_app_connection_scanners_for_android/haejrbi https://www.reddit.com/r/privacytoolsIO/comments/papgeq/any_...
  • ttctciyf 5y ago
    Forgive the questions, but you seem to be a good person to ask.. How does Blokada actually work? Its FAQ claims it: > prevents apps and browsers installed on your device from sending your private data (known as tracking fingerprints) to the Internet. Is it doing some kind of packet inspection? As a secondary layer of blocking I use DNS66 which intercepts DNS requests and fails them for blacklisted domains, by installing itself as a virtual VPN - essentially a cooked /etc/hosts for Android. Would Blokada work alongside that?
    • ignoramous 5y ago
      > prevents apps and browsers installed on your device from sending your private data (known as tracking fingerprints) to the Internet. For now, Blokada's utility is limited to DNS-based content blocking. It cannot and does not prevent most forms of fingerprinting. > Is it doing some kind of packet inspection? Yes, only DNS packet inspection, but even for the only thing it does, it is clumsy: It leaks DNS requests; that is, Blokada does not trap all DNS traffic on port 53, and it does not handle DNS queries sent over TCP. DNS66 has these same issues, too. > As a secondary layer of blocking I use DNS66 which intercepts DNS requests and fails them for blacklisted domains, by installing itself as a virtual VPN - essentially a cooked /etc/hosts for Android. Blokada uses the same trick (I mean, core parts of Blokada 4 code-base does bear similarities with DNS66 which preceded it... Blokada 5 however was re-written in Rust). > Would Blokada work alongside that? No, it cannot. But: Apps that support "DNS proxying" (like Nebulo [0]) can. It is quite an involved setup. I'd simply use Nebulo over DNS66, as it is not only more capable but also encrypts DNS traffic unlike Blokada 4 or DNS66. > ...but you seem to be a good person to ask.. A disclosure, rather something to keep in mind: I have been accused of spreading fud by the Blokada lead developer and using it to "market" a "competitor" app I co-develop. In my defense, it wasn't / isn't fud what I spread, unless fud === uncomfortable truth. [0] https://github.com/ch4t4r/Nebulo https://github.com/ch4t4r/Nebulo (fixed link, thanks u/NoGravitas)
      • status_offline 5y ago
        Would you mind to suggest any alternative to Blokada? Thanks!
        • ignoramous 5y ago
          https://github.com/offa/android-foss#-ad-blocker https://github.com/offa/android-foss#-ad-blocker and https://github.com/offa/android-foss#-firewall https://github.com/offa/android-foss#-firewall
      • NoGravitas 5y ago
        Github link for Nebulo appears wrong: is this the correct one? https://github.com/Ch4t4r/Nebulo https://github.com/Ch4t4r/Nebulo
      • ttctciyf 5y ago
        Thanks for the info!