4 ms·
I think from a technical standpoint, Fuchsia as a modern redesign of an operating system is very interesting. However, from a technical point of view, the Wind
by jeroenhd 5y ago
I think from a technical standpoint, Fuchsia as a modern redesign of an operating system is very interesting.
However, from a technical point of view, the Windows kernel is just as exciting but the restrictions on the source code and its use make it very hard to build excitement in a community like this.
From a practical standpoint, the whole goal of the project is to throw out the open source system because manufacturers can't be arsed to play nice with open source. The philosophy behind it undoes a lot of the technical merit that would otherwise make it exciting.
Had Red Hat, Canonical or another such company been behind the project, I think the community would be all over it. With the way things are going, this is probably going to go down in the open source world like Darwin has: a few hackers building on top of it, but mostly everything is left up to the big corporation managing it. This is entirely different from Android, where enhancements are often built into custom ROMs made possible purely by the GPL nature of the kernel source code, enhancements that more than once made their way into the core Android project.
While I'm excited about a brand new kernel, I'm disheartened by knowing this project is a harbinger of death for large parts of the custom ROM scene. When Fuchsia appears on phones, we'll be thrown back into the days of customising Windows Mobile installs, by moving around special DLLs and copying over magical data files. Open source makes it easier to modify existing code, but manufacturers won't be running the open source version of that code.