8 ms·
The Worst Businessman of the 18th Century BC (2018)
- Foomf 5y agoThey found the tablets with the complaints in what was presumably his house? I wonder what happened that caused the businessman to be the last resident to ever live in that house. I assume if someone moved in after him they would have gotten rid of the complaint tablets.
- prox 5y agoThat’s a totally unreadable website on mobile. Introduction text seemed interesting.
- YetAnotherNick 5y agoIt is working fine for me on mobile.
- prox 5y agoI had ads all over, it re arranged the DOM a quarter in so it became a mess. Safari here btw.
- dr-detroit 5y agoyikes.
- quickthrowman 5y agoSounds like it’s time to get a content blocker for iOS Safari, I use one and see no ads here
- username_my1 5y agosuch a good read.. the writing in stone reminded me of telegram messages where you have to be contrived so much that it makes the language appear so rudimentary.
- OliverJones 5y agoAs often happened in early 20th century archaeology, Wooley's crew was a bit sloppy handling the tablets they found: they boxed them up and took them home to try to figure them out, corrupting their order. Kind of like, I suppose, reading a hard drive sector-by-sector without understanding the file system layout. (Source: the ancient near eastern librarian at Penn State, Chuck Jones, who happens to be my brother.) It's great that Dr. Killgrove and her team were able to find an actual story to tell from that trove. And an interesting story, too.
- pjmlp 5y ago> Kind of like, I suppose, reading a hard drive sector-by-sector without understanding the file system layout. More like dropping a stack of compiled cards for early computers.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMaking me realise the physical similarities of cuneiform and punch cards: standard media formats ("lentils" vs. cards), both marked via an impression tool (reed vs. punch). In columns, as it happens. The reeds were more expressive for individual marks, but the major concepts are highly similar. https://youtube.com/watch?v=XL0f3Kq1He4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=XL0f3Kq1He4 (Am now contemplating a Lentil Tabulating Company creating automated readers for an early Babylonian census, and resulting in an early Intertribal Babylonian Machines information monopoly.)
- pjmlp 5y agoQuite interesting, I wasn't aware of it, thanks for sharing. I bet copying and writing such tablets was a business back then.
- dredmorbius 5y agoGreat work if you could hack it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scribe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scribe The equivalent of today's front-end engineers.
- ncmncm 5y agoMesopotamians had lived in these cities for 1700+ years before these tablets were written, using the same script all the while. The world must have felt older to them than ours does, because they had no expectation that anything in the future would ever be notably different.
- prox 5y agoIn terms of complaints nothing has changed (my other comment is complaining about ads/layout issues) :)
- betterunix2 5y agoThey did not truly use the same script the entire time. Like all writing systems the script did change as people simplified characters for their own convenience and as spoken (and thus written) language changed. New characters were added over time and old characters fell out of use. Cuneiform originally developed from commonly used pictograms that were used for various purposes (accounting, identification, etc.) but were not "true" writing. Same thing happened in China and Mesoamerica. The degree to which people were aware of the change in the characters is debatable, but there was certainly some awareness among the scribes and elites in later centuries (e.g. the Talmud records a debate about the Hebrew writing system). I suspect that at least the elites of Mesopotamia knew that the system had changed because they had access to much older tablets than what they themselves were producing. At a minimum they knew that the language had changed, since they were literate in both ancient Sumerian and whatever the common language of their city was (Akkadian, Elamite, etc.), and they likely recognized regional variations in the characters on tablets they received from other cities.
- ncmncm 5y ago"Same script", for some version of "same". And, yes, the actual language being written changed as armies swept through, except for religious matters which had to be conducted in (what would have been imagined to match) the original language and pronunciation. Can't expect the gods to learn a new language, or expect incantations to work when pronounced "wrong"! Apparently the Hindu priesthood, from Vedic times, had a terrifyingly rigorous system for maintaining exact wording and pronunciation for their rites, for that reason; and preserved mathematical lore used for astronomical calculations the same way, before they got to writing it all down many centuries later. Many Chinese people imagine they can read documents from two millennia ago, but rely on the inherent ambiguity of their script to construct an apparent "poetic" meaning entirely disjoint from what was written.
- fouc 5y ago> But the most irate of all of Ea-Nasir's customers is a man called Nanni who was so livid that he covered a tablet front and back in cuneiform complaints. It's comforting to see even angry people from eras ago working just as hard at complaining as they do nowadays.
- noneeeed 5y agoIf you visit the Roman Baths here in Bath they have a load of lead tablets that were thrown into the water as prayers/requests to the gods/curses, I love how like an angry facebook complaint some of them are. I'm alway hugely sceptical of claims that technology creates human behviour. Human nature seems to be remarkably consistent in many ways, technology just seems to provide outlets for it. People complain about performative desplays on Facebook/Insta/Twitter, but it's no different from people in the 70s inviting their friends round to show them a slide-show of their holiday photos. Instagram didn't create narcessism, it just made it much more visible.
- exolymph 5y agoSufficiently increasing scale leads to qualitative jump-steps. Complex systems gonna complexify!