4 ms·
FWIW, you can use Emacs just for org mode, and continue to use your usual tools for writing code.
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
FWIW, you can use Emacs just for org mode, and continue to use your usual tools for writing code.
- selfhoster11 5y agoEmacs is very idiosyncratic for beginners. Things like confusing terminology and lack of conformance with CUA (aka Windows 98-style shortcuts for navigation, copy and paste) make for an extremely steep learning curve when all I want to use it for is a very fancy organizer tool. I'm not willing to spend this much effort at this stage.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoSo don't :). It's not a competition. "Confusing terminology and lack of conformance with CUA" (aka. being older than both CUA and modern terminology) is perhaps a stumbling block for some, but arguably not that big once a wannabe-user decides to extend their attention span beyond 30 seconds.
- selfhoster11 5y agoIf the Emacs keybindings and terminology could be mastered in not much more than 30 seconds, they wouldn't pose a problem in the first place. There is value in standardisation, and it's unlikely that the current starter Emacs layout provides any unique value other than letting 40+ year old industry veterans keep their muscle memory, while alienating basically everyone born after the age of the monochrome glass TTY. While I understand that using or not using Emacs is not a competition, it almost appears that Emacs tries to be different for the sake of being different. Just like Mac OS uses the Ctrl+PgDn/Up/Arrow shortcuts in a way that contradicts what virtually every other platform does (including Windows and Linux). Edit: do not misunderstand my point, I am not saying that Emacs is trying to be different for the sake of being different. I am saying that remaining the way it is, on purpose, when the majority of the world expressed a preference for a different convention that comes with no clear downsides, makes it look as if that were the case. Or makes Emacs look recalcitrant, if you prefer.
- least 5y ago> it almost appears that Emacs tries to be different for the sake of being different. Emacs conventions existed long before CUA became the standard and to adapt to CUA would require Emacs to change some very basic and critical conventions. There were plenty of word processors like Word Star that also featured its own conventions, just Word Star has mostly become an esoteric word processor while Emacs and Vim remain prevalent to this day (I mean... they're still esoteric but not that esoteric). MacOS also has its own conventions that don't comply with the "standard" which of course, again, came after MacOS established its own standards and of which are superior to Windows, anyway, since it doesn't break compatibility with the unix terminal. Maybe the real issue is Windows and Linux that decided to adopt the inferior conventions of the dominant OS?
- selfhoster11 5y agoJust because a control convention existed before other implementations, it doesn't automatically make it good. Plenty of older shooter games have a control scheme that besides being unfamiliar, is simply not ergonomic enough. E. g. Wolfenstein's control scheme that uses the mouse to rotate the camera, but also to move the player forwards and backwards.
- least 5y ago> Just because a control convention existed before other implementations, it doesn't automatically make it good. Conversely, just because CUA became the de facto standard in Windows and Linux doesn't make it good, either. They became standardized as a consequence of Windows becoming the most popular operating system and the only reason you're advocating for it is because it's what you are comfortable with, not because it has any meaningful advantages over other keyboard shortcut paradigms.
- selfhoster11 5y agoYes. My point is, Emacs convention and CUA are basically equivalent. In which case there is little excuse to go with the less popular one if you want to attract young blood without creating an obstacle course they must pass first. If you don't have young blood coming in occasionally, your editor will remain stagnant after a while.
- cyberbanjo 5y agoVanilla emacs comes with cua-mode so you can more easily feel at home
- exikyut 5y agoFacepalms in https://xkcd.com/378/ https://xkcd.com/378/
- brabel 5y agoIf you're on Mac, Cmd+C Cmd+V and Cmd+Z do the same as in other apps, and so will Option+Left/Right for example, I guess the problem is on Windows where those shortcuts use Ctrl and emacs uses Ctrl for all its other shortcuts? In which case you can try cua-mode but then you might have trouble with other useful shortcuts commonly used being bound to unusual keys.
- ubermonkey 5y agoIn fact, I do precisely this. It's worth it.
- beermonster 5y agoThis is certainly true. I use Emacs just for Org-Mode and magit. That’s how good both of those are.