3 ms·
> That's because people have become used to receiving enormous subsidies from the clueless unwashed masses, and that kind of self-interest almost always takes p
by dpark 15y ago
> That's because people have become used to receiving enormous subsidies from the clueless unwashed masses, and that kind of self-interest almost always takes priority over recognizing that paying $50/month for downloading 500GB of porn while your neighbor pays $50/month for downloading e-mail just isn't fair.
Can I assume that you are in favor of tightly-capped broadband, then?
I don't think that scenario is unfair at all, either. If you and I rent town-homes side-by-side, is it unfair that I live in mine year-round and have guests over regularly, while you are rarely home? Of course not, because you're not being charged for usage. You're being charged for capacity. Whether you use that capacity or not is your business. What about a gym membership? Is it unfair if you pay the same as me but only use the gym once/week while I'm there every day?
> I simply don't believe you when you say it doesn't work. Other industries are able to charge for use without a massive collapse in revenues as you state. I don't see why a massive drop in revenue needs to happen. I don't expect usage patterns to stay the same at all, I merely expect the new usage patterns, when applied to sanely structured new prices, to result in similar revenue.
Most industries don't charge for bandwidth. You don't pay for water service based on how many gallons per minute you've got on the line. You don't pay for electric based on how many amps are flowing to your house. Innovation and progress in the networking arena is driven by bandwidth, though. No one compares America's price per GB to South Korea's price per GB. They compare bandwidth. The fact that worldwide the industry works this way indicates that it's not just some arbitrary American telco thing. Increases in bandwidth provide an increase in capability and quality of service (arguably an increase in quality of life). It makes sense to incentivize this and have companies compete on the basis of speed.
As for why a massive drop in revenue has to happen, ask yourself if you (a hypothetical high-bandwidth user) would continue your service if your bill went up 10x. My guess is that you would not happily pay the increase. Instead you would drop the service entirely or at least drastically reduce your usage. In that case, the extra bandwidth is no longer being utilized, so you're not paying for it and ATT isn't getting the revenue. So revenue drops unless they crank up the price/GB until everyone's paying the same $30 they were paying before. Maybe that's "fair", but it's not especially useful, because now everyone's paying the same price but basically capped at the previous average amount.
- mikeash 15y agoWhy would you assume I'm in favor of tightly-capped broadband? I would have thought it was extremely clear that I'm in favor of paying per use, which would then eliminate the need for any caps. I can't comprehend why ISPs like Comcast are instituting hard caps rather than simply charging for usage above the limit. If I use more than 250GB/month, Comcast will fire me as a customer. Why don't they just send me a bill for the excess instead? I get to keep my service, they get more money, everybody wins. I don't see how your hypothetical demonstrates anything. You simply assume that my costs would go up by a factor of ten, when I see no reason why it would be anything near that kind of increase.
- dpark 15y agoWhat you're talking about isn't pay-for-usage. It's not pay-per usage when Comcast charges a flat fee up to 250GB and then charges extra beyond that. That's a soft cap or a tiered plan. I agree that Comcast seems stupid for cutting people off at 250GB, but I would not call it pay-for-usage to extend beyond that. I assume you would see a 10x jump in cost because AT&T says that the top users are consuming 12x as much as the average. If users are paying their "fair share", then people using 12x as much bandwidth would pay about 12x as much. Otherwise it's not "fair" and it's not "pay-per-usage". (There might be some "volume" discount, but the overall cost would still be drastically higher.) I'm not strictly opposed to a tiered plan, but that's not pay-per-usage. It's no more "fair" than the current system. It just means that heavy users have the option to pay extra rather than getting capped. Everyone else would still pay about the same amount, and the guy using 1MB/month is still subsidizing the guy using 250GB/month. Assuming those top 5% aren't going to pay drastically more, everyone else would have to pay about the same on average to keep revenues constant. Perhaps you have a different idea in mind for how the plan should work, and I'm not understanding your idea. If so, please clarify how you think AT&T should charge, and how the new plan would maintain revenue.
- mikeash 15y agoThe idea itself is simple: charge a fixed amount for the connection itself, to cover things like physical line maintenance, billing, customer service, etc. Charge a variable amount for use of the connection. That variable amount does not have to be a fixed dollars-per-byte rate. I'd imagine that the casual e-mail users would pay on the order of $20-30/month (Comcast already offers such a plan in my area, making it cheap by limiting the speed rather than the transfer quantity), average users would pay about what they pay now ($50-60), and heavy users might pay $100-200.