3 ms·
> Does that mean GPL and all similar free licenses that rely on copyright law cannot be enforced in similar jurisdictions You missed one important point 3) Th
by bluGill 5y ago
> Does that mean GPL and all similar free licenses that rely on copyright law cannot be enforced in similar jurisdictions
You missed one important point
3) The French court said take this is for the contracts courts, take it to them - something that hasn't happened yet.
The contract courts have not ruled (this hasn't even been brought to them from what I can tell) on this case at all, but probably would find in favor of the GPL. The GPL probably can be enforced in France, but it is a contract violation not a copyright violation which apparently the FSF doesn't like. (I'm not clear on why - possibly because the court award would be much less)
- lukeschlather 5y agoThe FSF is not mentioned in this article, nor are they the author of the article. I was surprised when the author wrote "Remember that it’s all about money!" because that is never what the FSF says - in fact the FSF whenever they sue they always say "We don't care about money, we want you to comply with the terms of the GPL."
- bluGill 5y agoGood point. Though the courts might disagree and decide it is about money anyway. I have no idea how France will handle this - nor any of the other countries in the world.