2 ms·
> A key question imho is this: will algorithmic music composition ever produce anything else than more or less sophisticated musac, effectively recycling a part
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> A key question imho is this: will algorithmic music composition ever produce anything else than more or less sophisticated musac, effectively recycling a particular musical corpus of a particular music tradition?
A related question is: how many human composers manage do this? It seems that we are fairly OK with a large body of composers "effectively recycling a particular musical corpus".
- streamofdigits 5y agoThere is indeed a lot of "filler" type production and even the most talented creators are far from always producing unique pieces that touch audiences (let alone endure). But this misses the point: some creators do occasionally hit the magic sweet spot and invent something that makes the rest worthwhile. Heck, some creators invent new genres. A DL type algorithm will not produce a new "classic" except by a "thousand monkeys hitting keyboards" type accident... at least not until we dig far deeper into what makes some music stand-out. And an algorithm as conventionally defined is unlikely to ever produce a new musical style. The true opportunity (as always with algorithms) is the augmentation of creative talent.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI'm not convinced (though I'm also not insisting that you're wrong). Studies of the human creative process that I've read don't provide a lot of support for the idea that there is a magic step here. You probably know the quote: "good artists borrow, great artists steal".