4 ms·
John Carmack's repsonse: "Re Euclideon, no chance of a game on current gen systems, but maybe several years from now. Production issues will be challenging."
by prawn 15y ago
John Carmack's repsonse:
"Re Euclideon, no chance of a game on current gen systems, but maybe several years from now. Production issues will be challenging."
https://twitter.com/#!/ID_AA_Carmack/statuses/98127398683422720 https://twitter.com/#!/ID_AA_Carmack/statuses/98127398683422...
- chipsy 15y agoBy "production issues" I would think "pipeline" first of all. It doesn't matter if it's possible to convert a high-res mesh to an optimized voxel format, if the result takes hours of compilation. That is too long an iteration time for a single asset.
- wlievens 15y agoNot if it's a scalable thing, i.e. you can get a "decent" conversion in a short time, and only do the full-scale conversions for milestone builds.
- jarin 15y agoI trust Carmack's response over pretty much anyone's in matters of rendering engines. The guy is a god of coding them.
- leif 15y agogods have been known to be blindsided by revolutionaries
- MtrL 15y agoHe, and his company, have done research into the field of SVOs to compliment megatexture. I don't know enough to say if it's the same approach, but it's certainly the same field, so you'd expect him to know a fair bit about it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpEpAFGplnI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpEpAFGplnI
- prawn 15y agoI saw a comment on Reddit about this 6-7 hours ago suggesting that Carmack had a horse in this race and that we might be best to presume the very slightest of bias in his response(s). That said, I also view his perspective in this field as tending towards unquestionable. He's always seemed to have had a pretty sparkling reputation as well as the obvious talent.
- unconed 15y agoThe tech basically has to be a variant of sparse voxel octrees. Carmack has mentioned it in an interview years ago, It's reasonable to assume he's built his own prototype, as he does with pretty much anything else.
- 6ren 15y agoHis latest tweet on it is interesting: > @Foggen insufficient information to say if it is tracing or splatting. They state their method is based on a well-known technique used in engineering and medical visualization, and splatting seems to be used there. I'm still not 100% clear on what splatting is, but there's a bunch of papers applying that term to voxels, e.g. http://graphics.cs.cmu.edu/projects/objewa/ http://graphics.cs.cmu.edu/projects/objewa/
- greendestiny 15y agoSplatting is when you draw with a point cloud but fill in in-between the points to make a solid surface during the rendering. It's only necessary if you get close enough to your point cloud that the points don't map to adjacent pixels.
- Tomek_ 15y agoI remember reading years ago that id was considering using vortex graphics for Quake2 and Carmack had even started to work on it, but they abandoned the idea seeing that industry is heading into "more polygons!" thing (the context: it was a time when 3dfx released Voodoo2, nVidia was starting to gain popularity (Riva TNT2) and first Unreal was on a horizon).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]