4 ms·
There's one really simple, mechanical principle at work here. If you get an mRNA shot your body will generate a snippet of spike protein which your immune syste
by noduerme 5y ago
There's one really simple, mechanical principle at work here. If you get an mRNA shot your body will generate a snippet of spike protein which your immune system will learn to attack and destroy. If you get a live sars2-cov virus, your body will also generate that protein, but orders of magnitude more of it and without automatically ceasing generation once the original mRNA breaks down... because the virus generates more mRNA. Your immune system will also learn to attack it but by the time it does the virus may be dozens of generations of exponential growth in which means there is simply so much to attack by that point that you will never generate enough antibodies before it overwhelms you.
The only argument for not getting the vaccine would be if you thought you had a better than average chance of never encountering the live virus. If given a choice between a vax and the live virus, no sane person would choose the live virus.
So everything else here is BS. People don't want to get the vaccine because they're scared. I understand that. But the probability of them encountering the virus is so high that taking the vaccine is clearly orders of magnitude less risky than not doing so, since in both cases you almost certainly will end up with the spike protein in your system and the only decision you really have is whether that will be self-administered and self-limiting, or wild and replicating uncontrolledly.
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago> The only argument for not getting the vaccine would be if you thought you had a better than average chance of never encountering the live virus. Of course nobody reasonable is saying "Go out and try to get the virus! It's better than the vaccine!" But your comment overlooks a significant and growing population: the people who have already been infected. Last year, a WHO official estimated that as much as 10% of the world population might have already been infected. A year later, given the spread of Delta, it would not be surprising if that estimate was substantially higher. What do you advise the previously infected to do? It is scientifically dishonest to dismiss the strong and growing evidence we now have that natural immunity is robust and likely in some respects superior to that provided by the vaccines. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/having-sars-cov-2-once-confers-much-greater-immunity-vaccine-no-infection-parties https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/having-sars-cov-2-on... https://www.rockefeller.edu/news/30919-natural-infection-versus-vaccination-differences-in-covid-antibody-responses-emerge/ https://www.rockefeller.edu/news/30919-natural-infection-ver... > ...the only decision you really have is whether that will be self-administered and self-limiting, or wild and replicating uncontrolledly. Yes, the risks of a natural infection in an unvaccinated person causing severe illness are undoubtedly higher, but let's not slander the human immune system. Young, apparently healthy people do get sick and die, and some report debilitating symptoms that linger, but if you look at the overall numbers honestly, you have to acknowledge that the vast, vast majority of people who are not old and who don't have metabolic disease don't get seriously ill and die from COVID, they recover just fine. And a double-digit percentage of people never even display symptoms. This thing isn't Ebola and vaccination marketing that presents it as such is, not surprisingly, proving to be less than persuasive to lots of people.
- pandaman 5y agoIt's not really that simple. First of all, "the orders of magnitude" claim is not supported by anything I've seen, care to provide your source? Then there is an issue of what cells are affected. We know that the virus binds only to a certain receptor, which exists only on some cells. What about the vaccine's "lipid particles", do they bind to receptors at all? I also could not find any reliable information on these particle mechanism of action, which I imagine is natural as this is the trade secret of the vaccine manufacturers so we don't know if these affect the same cells the virus does. I for one rather sacrifice a few billion of epithelial cells to the virus than 1/1000th of this number in the brain neurons to the vaccine because neurons are probably not going to regenerate while the epithelium constantly regenerates.
- noduerme 5y agoFrom an engineering standpoint, it's just obvious that something generating a few million partial spike protein snippets originating in your deltoid muscle - even if some get into your blood or lymphatic system - is still a lot less dangerous than uncontrolled replication of billions of spike + whole viruses running wild around your body. Sure, either one could end up damaging your brain if it got through the blood/brain barrier. There's some evidence that vax-induced spike proteins have been found 30 days later in the bloodstream. Nonetheless, compared with the onslaught of that same protein you'd get from a live virus, it's the better of two bad options.
- pandaman 5y agoI do not understand this standpoint. I am an engineer myself and when I compare two numbers I calculate both numbers and not just wave my hands. I don't know how to calculate either number in this case. Where did you get the "few million"? How come the vaccine causes myocarditis and thrombosis, both outside the deltoid muscle, where you said it's contained? How could the virus end damaging my brain, are you really sure there are ACE2 receptors in the brain neurons?