3 ms·
> although the choice of Indian gauge cannot practically be reversed. It would probably be very expensive, and might not have ROI, but couldn't you lay narrowe
by toast0 5y ago
> although the choice of Indian gauge cannot practically be reversed.
It would probably be very expensive, and might not have ROI, but couldn't you lay narrower gauge rail in between the current rails, then modify or replace rolling stock to use the smaller gauge... and once done, remove the old broad gauge rail?
Looking at some random BART rail images, laying the new rail would be difficult; some places have equipment between the rails, other places have concrete between the rails. It would probably need to be a very long project; early stages could just be verifying which sections would be feasible to add narrower gauge to and making sure new construction would allow for it and when rework is already happening, consider working room for narrower gauge into the maintenance. You could really only progress sensibly once at least one line was nearly ready.
I guess the question would have to be, would all the expense and time it would take to switch to a narrower gauge, be justified the improvement in user comfort (I assume) and benefits of using more standard equipment.
- bobthepanda 5y agoI can't seem to find this online, but I would assume that BART cars are wider in general than most standard subway cars, not just in track gauge. If this is true, you would also need to close platform gaps to continue to meet ADA requirements (a large enough gap is considered inaccessible). It would be a lot of expense, for not a whole lot of benefit in the short term, and BART probably doesn't have enough money with reduced COVID commuting trends to even think about paying for something like this when they could instead build more rail and get more butts in more seats.
- Symbiote 5y agoThe presentation linked in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28355136 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28355136 says the BART car width is 3.2m, which seems to be the typical North American passenger car width [1]. The BART cars certainly look wide, but that's because they're not very tall. This is wider than most metro trains (especially 19th century systems), but BART isn't a metro system anyway. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loading_gauge#Standard_loading_gauges_for_standard_track_gauge_lines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loading_gauge#Standard_loading...