5 ms·
>It is this weighing of risks and benefits, in all their many facets, that informs the chorus of health-care professionals imploring their families, neighbors,
by hammock 5y ago
>It is this weighing of risks and benefits, in all their many facets, that informs the chorus of health-care professionals imploring their families, neighbors, co-workers, and friends, along with everyone else, to please get vaccinated against covid-19. They urge vaccination because they see its ratio of risks to benefits as incredibly, unbelievably good.
For someone who has already had Covid and recovered, there is no benefit. Only risk.[1] But they are not allowed to make this calculation for themselves and instead are treated to constant social pressure campaigns like this piece.
[1]https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210608/No-point-vaccinating-those-whoe28099ve-had-COVID-19-Findings-of-Cleveland-Clinic-study.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210608/No-point-vaccinat...
- rdli 5y agoThis study is based on 2020 data, pre Delta.
- hammock 5y agoHere is the latest data. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/having-sars-cov-2-once-confers-much-greater-immunity-vaccine-no-infection-parties https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/having-sars-cov-2-on... Vaccinated person 13x more likely than the naturally immune to catch delta 7x more likely to be symptomatic More likely to be hospitalized Take back you downvote and educate yourself.
- spats1990 5y agoPerhaps, as is a common argument from the vaccine-hesitant, we should wait for more scientific data before concluding that previous infection provides more protection than the vaccine? :) After all, this whole thing has happened quite quickly.
- dev_tty01 5y agoThe commenter stated that the vaccine had no benefit to previously infected. That is not true. From the article you reference: "The researchers also found that people who had SARS-CoV-2 previously and received one dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech messenger RNA (mRNA) vaccine were more highly protected against reinfection than those who once had the virus and were still unvaccinated."
- hammock 5y agoAt what cost? What is the risk vs benefit for this particular scenario?
- criticaltinker 5y agoYes agreed, but the benefits appear to be insignificant relative to the benefits of giving that vaccine dose to an immunologically naive or otherwise vulnerable individual.
- akomtu 5y agoThe dangerous citizen who thinks for himself.
- inciampati 5y agoMaybe those who disagree with you think that you should make a more subtle argument. For those who are convalescent, the risk / benefit ratio of the vaccine is very different than for someone who is immunologically naive. And, to my knowledge, the vaccines have not been carefully validated in a convalescent population, on the same level as the clinical trials on which their efficacy estimates are founded. The idea of getting an illness and then immediately double vaccinating oneself against it should give any rational person pause. This is at very least marginally beneficial, and at worst downright risky. A single dose might make sense, but there should be no rush to apply one. The chance of an otherwise healthy COVID-19 convalescent person ending up hospitalized from reinfection appears to be almost immeasurably low. But the risk of a severe reaction to the vaccine is low but not immeasurable. And it could be worse for someone whose immune system is primed against the vaccine, but that's also not clear.
- criticaltinker 5y agoYes the lack of significant benefit from vaccinating individuals who have already acquired immunity has direct implications for public health policy. It’s not an efficient use of limited vaccine doses, especially when many vulnerable or immunologically naive people around the world have not received even one dose. These factors need to be considered because they could help reduce the total mortality from this pandemic [1]. [1] Model-informed COVID-19 vaccine prioritization strategies by age and serostatus https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/371/6532/916.full.pdf https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/371/6532/916.full...
- dev_tty01 5y agoNot true. Vaccinated and previously infected people are much less likely to be reinfected than unvaccinated previously infected. Here is a recent study: https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-protection.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr... Reinfection was twice as likely among unvaccinated previously infected. The more recent data includes the effects of the delta variant. So, the risk of Covid is much higher and the risk of adverse effects are approximately zero for getting the vaccine. Note that I am not commenting on vaccine prioritization and allocation, just the assertion of the post that vaccination has no benefit to previously infected people.
- hammock 5y ago>risk of Covid is much higher and the risk of adverse effects are approximately zero for getting the vaccine. Where is your data for this? What is the risk of a naturally immune person catching Covid, and being either a)symptomatic, b)hospitalized, or c)killed? How does this risk compare to the risk of a serious adverse event or long-term consequence such as autoimmune disease from the vaccine in a healthy young man?
- dev_tty01 5y agoYou asserted that there was no benefit to getting the vaccine for previously infected. I pointed you to a reference that shows that that is not true. The original article to which we are all responding pointed out the minuscule levels of risk associated with getting the vaccine. With respect to autoimmune disease, I think we are seeing that long covid is becoming a significant health concern among even healthy young people with only a mild response to Covid infection. Here is an example article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/as-vaccines-do-their-work-focus-moves-to-long-covid-11627038001 https://www.wsj.com/articles/as-vaccines-do-their-work-focus... Relevant quote: "Long Covid—a term referring to symptoms that linger for weeks or months beyond infection—affects between 10% and 30% of people who catch the virus, including those with mild or asymptomatic infections, according to experts. In some cases, symptoms persist for more than a year." At any rate, I imagine none of this will persuade you, so I simply wish you good luck and hope you remain healthy. My strongest hope is that things can improve enough that we can all go back to arguing about linux user interface schemes.
- pjc50 5y agoHow good and available is the testing to prove you have natural immunity?
- hammock 5y agoAntibody tests are instant and widely available. These tests are (I believe) what the natural immunity studies use to establish history of prior infection. Detractors will say that there is no established level of antibodies that means "immunity." Ironically, it is declining antibodies though (and no set threshold) that is being used to justify "booster" jabs around the world!
- detaro 5y agoFar from that clear cut, other results show booster shots on top of previous infection perform better than just natural immunity - and we will see how the longevity of both works out with future data, and can adjust accordingly. (and e.g. the current policy here in Germany: immunity counts for X (I think 6) months, afterwards a single booster shot counts as fully vaccinated.)
- OkiJ 5y ago> For someone who has already had Covid and recovered, there is no benefit. Only risk I guess you missed this big-ass bolded part at the bottom: *Important Notice medRxiv publishes preliminary scientific reports that are not peer-reviewed and, therefore, should not be regarded as conclusive, guide clinical practice/health-related behavior, or treated as established information. You fucking liar. You fucking merchant of death. You fucking deceiver. If your position were logical, rational, and intellectually honest, you would not have to mis-represent non-peer-reviewed, inconclusive single studies as inarguable truths. But your position is bullshit, so your arguments must be to. Go fuck yourself you fucking cultist.