3 ms·
Astrology is a psychological technology that cleverly relies on celestial mechanics as a source of effectively-random numbers. I.e., your sign matters only in t
by ncmncm 5y ago
Astrology is a psychological technology that cleverly relies on celestial mechanics as a source of effectively-random numbers. I.e., your sign matters only in that it differs from 92% of other people's signs; more if you bring in moon sign, rising sign, what-have-you. The randomizing keeps people from all getting the same advice at the same time.
How is classroom practice similar?
- solarmist 5y agoMy interpertation is just that they meant they have no rational basis or foundation upon which they are built. Castles in the sky so to say.
- solarmist 5y agoAfter reading it, I'd say a better title would be "Most classroom practices are folklore".
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI thought it was a perfectly clear analogy: Astronomy grows out of astrology. Astrology can be seen as the "primitive" form of astronomy. Astrology can be seen as the predecessor of astronomy. I felt it was saying "We still have a long ways to go before this is some kind of science."
- ncmncm 5y agoWas there ever expectation that classroom practice derived from any kind of science? It evolved as a practice that pretty reliably generates tuition and employment of educators. Any success in actually educating has always been secondary as an evolutionary measure of fitness. I guess you could say that astrology developed by a similar process, optimized to produce people willing to pay for it, with little demand for other objective result. Objectivity is rejected pre-emptively.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]