6 ms·
Overwriting Hard Drive Data: The Great Wiping Controversy (2008) [pdf]
- YLYvYkHeB2NRNT 5y agoAre you willing to take that chance when discarding EOL disks?
- fortran77 5y agoI sledgehammer them.
- swdev281634 5y agoDepends on the discarding method. I format them, and gift to some people around here who could make a good use of them (friends, neighbors). Usually, I replace disks because I need more storage, the old ones have quite a few years of life still left. These people know me, getting good hardware for free, and I'm reasonably confident they won't sell them to digital forensic experts on e-bay.
- chasil 5y agoAnything wrong with GNU shred on the block device?
- chungy 5y agoIn short, no. Often a plain old zero pass is good enough, but shred defaults to doing three random passes and that'll be sure to destroy any hopes of recovery.
- nullc 5y agoNothing wrong with it, and it absolutely will stop any kind of casual or software recovery. However, physically destroying the disk is the only way to be sure. And amusingly, it's often faster to physically destroy the disk than it is to run shred on it at today's capacity to write speed ratios. Bonus, not only does physical destruction cover non-working sectors it works on entirely non-functioning disks.
- jcrawfordor 5y ago1) Just a funny fact, the Craig Wright who's first author on this paper is that Craig Wright. 2) This is a good paper on the situation, but as I've mentioned before tends to miss the point. The data remanence concern today is usually non-volatile caches and remapped sections of the media which are not documented or accessible to the host. This problem is best known for SSDs but very much exists on modern platter drives as well. No number of host-based overwrites will reliably overwrite these even once, and the manufacturers do not document or disclose the behavior.
- anfractuosity 5y agoDo you mean a type of spinning disk that also has flash memory for caching? I thought spinning disks normally used volatile memory for the cache?
- jcrawfordor 5y agoNo, platter drives usually don't have nonvolatile cache although it's hard to say for sure. Enterprise drives are more likely to. The bigger issue with spinning drives is that they move data around the platters in ways not disclosed by the manufacturers, including both optimizations (writing near heads) and error corrections like ending use of problematic parts of the platter. These all leave bits of data in "non-addressable" parts of the platter.
- anfractuosity 5y agoAh, that's interesting. I wonder how hard it'd be to find these areas of the disk, I wonder if the location of them is stored in some kind of non volatile memory, so the disk can easily find them.
- dzdt 5y agoAnd the Dave Kleiman who is second author on this paper is that Dave Kleiman, the one who most likely invented bitcoin. Wright has claimed to be Satoshi Nakamoto but has proven himself to be a liar on this topic; by his actions he clearly believes that Kleiman controlled the Satoshi bitcoin fortune before his untimely death.
- nullc 5y agoYou probably don't want to believe anything in this: The author is a well known scammer/con-artist (Craig Wright) who has a long running advanced fee fraud scheme predicated on convincing suckers that he created bitcoin and has some secret stash of billions that he could get to only if his victims help him with some cash flow problems. He has a long history of using forgeries, faked documents, plagiarism, and impersonation in order to pass himself off as some kind of credible. This article is debunked in the "Further Epilogue" of https://www.cs.auckland.ac.nz/~pgut001/pubs/secure_del.html https://www.cs.auckland.ac.nz/~pgut001/pubs/secure_del.html Moreover, the images of their supposed MFM imaging was just copied off a manufacturer's page ( https://web.archive.org/web/20090418043851/https://www.engr.sjsu.edu/WofMatE/Mat'sChar2.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20090418043851/https://www.engr.... shows another copy on a similarly old page, citing the source) -- so it seems unlikely that they ever performed any measurements at all. A big chunk was plagiarized from an uncited source ("A Practical Guide to Scanning Probe Microscopy (1993)")... another hallmark of Wright's lame forgeries. There was a phenomenal twitter thread that went over all this and more, but Wright used spurious legal threats to drive the author off twitter. The biggest loss was where it pointed out that one of the citations in this paper is where they tried to cite Nikola Tesla in [20], but used the title of the 1989 album The Great Radio Controversy by the rock band Tesla ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Radio_Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Radio_Controversy ). :P These days Wright is busy prolonging a lawsuit against a dozen former and current Bitcoin developers-- including myself--, demanding that they help him compensate for his lack of private keys by publishing a backdoored version of Bitcoin in order to aid him in taking billions of dollars worth of other people's coins, or failing that pay him billions of dollars themselves. I wouldn't be shocked now if Wright wasn't promoting this article because in one of his lawsuits he claimed hackers hid a "wifi pineapple" in his home and used it to penetrate his systems and then delete his private keys. ... and then before contacting law enforcement he completely wiped his systems, helpfully destroying evidence that the supposed hack never happened and that the keys never existed. So now he's invested in the claim that deletions are never recoverable, to cover for his transparent spoliation. He's now funded by loans taken out against his non-existing bitcoin fortune, which likely explains why he's cowardly doing everything he can to delay progress in at least five different court cases. Presumably the consequences for him will be dire when his victims start realizing the funds he promised them next existed. Esp because one of the largest sponsors is a former drug smuggler who spent a decade on the run on the DHS most wanted list.
- h2odragon 5y agoThermite is cheap, fun, and effective. Fire cleanses all sins.
- throw0101a 5y agoPer NIST Special Publication 800-88 Rev. 1 (p. 7): > For storage devices containing magnetic media, a single overwrite pass with a fixed pattern such as binary zeros typically hinders recovery of data even if state of the art laboratory techniques are applied to attempt to retrieve the data. * https://csrc.nist.gov/publications/detail/sp/800-88/rev-1/final https://csrc.nist.gov/publications/detail/sp/800-88/rev-1/fi... If you're really paranoid use degaussing or physical destruction. If you can, use the SATA/SCSI "secure erase" command. Which definitely needs to be done for non-magnetic media (e.g., SSDs). I'm sure there are some places where regulations dictate certain actions.
- bsder 5y agoDidn't there used to be a prize offered for anyone who could reconstruct a disk that had been zeroed? I don't think anyone ever won it. Yes, it seems that it is theoretically possible to recover a drive that has been zeroed, but it seems that, practically, no one will bother. Of course, SSDs are a complete other kettle of fish.
- GuB-42 5y agoFrom my understanding, you can recover data after a wipe if that data is on a sector that has been marked as defective by the firmware. A software wipe will skip it, but "SATA secure erase" should not. Another thing worth noting is that hard drive manufacturers intentionally make recovery of overwritten data difficult. Not because of security, but because data that can be recovered is wasting space. For example, if you have a 100GB hard drive and you can recover 10GB after a wipe, it means that there is actually 110GB stored here, and the manufacturer will want to tweak things up to make used of that space.
- instkin 5y agoThis "security expert" wiped a claimed billion dollar hard drive, after he claims a "hacker" deleted his files (that he never backed up).
- torx 5y agoCRAIG SH*T WRIGHT - faketoshi.cypherpunks.xyz
- jourfa 5y agoSo many paid shills (probably just a couple of #greg accounts) are trying to attack the creator of Bitcoin.
- SRTP 5y agoMust be rough, putting your faith in a scammer pretending to be Satoshi, then seeing your investment disappear like snow before the sun. BSV was a top 10 coin a few months ago. Right now? Ranked 50. Must be rough.
- austinbrady 5y agoCraig is going to go down as one of the most under appreciated geniuses of our time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- midmagico 5y agoThere is stronger evidence that paper is nonsense than there is that it's a valid piece of academia. As per painted_frog's superb sleuthing, even the electron microscope image in there was just a rotated and cropped image from another electron microscope website in 1999. Here's the source image here: https://web.archive.org/web/19991103120709/http://www.engr.sjsu.edu/WofMatE/Mat'sChar2.htm https://web.archive.org/web/19991103120709/http://www.engr.s... Notice the artifacts of the rotation in the plagiarized copy. https://twitter.com/retired__frog/status/1157762921293914113 https://twitter.com/retired__frog/status/1157762921293914113 "14/26 As Gutmann himself points out in an appended epilogue after OHDD was published, there are major problems with OHDD, one being that bc the authors don’t know the difference between Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Magnetic Force Microscopy (MFM), they confuse the two "15/26 Note the copy/paste (no citation) from A Practical Guide to Scanning Probe Microscopy (1993). Given the authors’ unfamiliarity with these tools and methods, it doesn’t lend huge credibility to the paper’s conclusions that there is no documentation of the experiment itself. "16/26 Indeed, the paper falsely claims a MFM-captured image as deriving from this project. In fact it’s a crop of an image originating from Veeco Instruments Inc, in an MFM image gallery on its site since 1999 at latest. The accompanying citation is an unrelated paper about MFM. "18/26 The concluding section makes the unsupported (false) claim that this study demonstrates that a single-pass overwrite renders data irretrievable even with the use of MFM “or other known methods”. The study didn’t purport to test any other methods, only MFM. "25/26 No corroborating artifact from the study was ever made available; there is only the critically flawed paper. Questions about method (ex. locating disk sectors) received dubious or dismissive answers.
- MyLegacyKit 5y agoIsn't that one of many plagiarized papers by someone who made cosplaying the dead and the alive (Dave Kleiman, David Rees, Deborah Kobza, Satoshi Nakamoto, Tim May, to name a few), lying and creating forgeries a fulltime job? Who's latest con is a massive neverending Nigerian prince advance fee scam on Calvin Ayre, now ending in a totally corrupt and bankrupt Bitcoin affinity fraud that is failing by all serious metrics? The man who is called a liar and a fraud by 7 judges on 3 continents, who is now involved in numerous lawsuits in which his counsel ONTIER has no shame to reuse Faketoshi lies and forgeries that have been called out by ATO and court Florida already? What a shame there are still people who give this con man the benefit of the doubt. He doesn't deserve it: https://link.medium.com/rj9V8yb0pib https://link.medium.com/rj9V8yb0pib
- oudekaas 5y agoArthur von Pelt, another obsessed anti Craig personality…. Arthur wakes up and goes to bed thinking about Craig….. It’s almost like Arthur is giving Craig the benefit of the doubt Not that long ago, Arthur was put in place by Renowned Cryptographer Iain Grigg when Arthur asked the question if Craig ever actually stated anything about Bitcoin that wasn’t already known. Iain then had to educate Arthur about how Craig indeed explained things about Bitcoin that even Iain didn’t know at the time. Things like the double hash for instance, funnily enough after Craig explained the double hash it was subsequently altered in the BTC wiki. Yes ladies and gentleman this is the kind of folks we are dealing with here….
- nullc 5y ago> Arthur von Pelt, another obsessed anti Craig personality Being angry about an obvious fraud who lobs obviously baseless $6 billion dollar lawsuits against retirees who were once volunteer Bitcoin developers isn't obsession, it's humanity. > Things like the double hash for instance, funnily enough after Craig explained the double hash it was subsequently altered in the BTC wiki. Actual history: Some random person wrote on the BitcoinWiki on some obscure page that sha256(sha256(x)) might be used in bitcoin to improve security against collisions a few years later this claim was noticed and removed with a link to a 2011 post on Bitcointalk that pointed out that any collision on H(x) is also a collision on H(H(x)). The text on the wiki was just incorrect, the author was likely confusing collision and preimage security or at least really unclear in their writing-- that's just one of the risks of public wikis. Wright started running around repeating this point someone else made on BCT in 2011, pretending to have come up with it himself, and suggesting that knowing about this thing (which obvious and common understanding long before Bitcoin existed) was somehow evidence of him being Bitcoin's creator. Craig didn't "explain" anything that wasn't already explained in detail within the Bitcoin community before Craig ever heard of Bitcoin, and known outside of the Bitcoin community long before Bitcoin existed. Going back to 2011 people have given many explanations as to why the use of sha256(sha256()) in Bitcoin had potential advantages, in some corner cases. Wright hasn't added a single thing to that discussion, and some of his attempts to do so have just been flat out incorrect. For example, for a while he was claiming that it was done that way so that parties could give miners transactions to mine without disclosing the transaction to them (a really bad idea), but that works just as well if sha256() is used.
- SRTP 5y agoCraig Wright is a liar and a fraud.