3 ms·
An average of an average does not yield any number that has any useful definition.
by vlovich123 5y ago
An average of an average does not yield any number that has any useful definition.
- mattkrause 5y agoCould you elaborate? The average (over 24 hours) temperature yesterday was 25˚C. You could certainly ask how that compares to other August 29ths in different years. This even has a name ("grand mean"), so I'm surprised that someone thinks it's never useful.
- vlovich123 5y agoI may have overstated slightly. The mean of means is equivalent to the overall mean iff > the subsamples have the same number of data points It's unlikely to be useful in any other situation. Certainly not for averaging the temperature of a galaxy.
- mattkrause 5y agoYes, that's obviously how the math works out. Both the overall mean and mean-of-means have sensible interpretations though. Suppose you observe a random sample of stars and find their temperatures to be 6000, 6250, 6750, and 7000C. The best possible guess[0] for the temperature of a new star drawn from that population is 6500C. The average temperature of all the starstuff may be different if one star is larger than another, but that's an answer to a slightly different question. In fact, I would argue that the mean-of-means is often a more appropriate summary statistic than the overall mean of the observations when there are repeated measurements. [0] Under L2 loss, with no prior, etc etc