8 ms·
I dunno who his target audience is, but I assume that the majority around here are computer programmers with anywhere from $70k/year single income to maybe $500
by dragontamer 5y ago
I dunno who his target audience is, but I assume that the majority around here are computer programmers with anywhere from $70k/year single income to maybe $500k/year dual income ?
Financial advice in general sucks. But when we get into the specifics... such as any say $150k/year programmer or higher, the generic financial advice of 6 months saving + max out 401k plan works.
-------
The plan for people at average, 50k/year combined income is closer to the go to college and get some skills that will launch your career.
What I do find amusing is our collective inability to talk about things that matter. Ex: the paycheck is the elephant in the room. And even though it is brought up in this post, the paycheck differences between families can lead to grossly different experiences.
- giantg2 5y agoYeah, but the audience of those financial gurus are the general public. So sure, their advice might work for the top 5%, but the rest of people will never "get rich" using that advice. Even that top 5% could be better off if building passive income, businesses, etc.
- dragontamer 5y agoBut the irony is that the generic advice actually applies to the hacker news audience pretty well. People reaching 100k/year or so single income should be able to save comfortably. And a lot of programmers are on an appropriate career path to get there in a few years
- giantg2 5y agoI wish that were true for me. But I think you're missing the point. The advice for most people (the target audience of the gurus) is wrong. It's just a coincidence that this article is posted on HN and it would be disingenuous to examine it from only this position/context.
- zhdc1 5y ago> So sure, their advice might work for the top 5%, but the rest of people will never "get rich" using that advice The median household income in the United States is $79.9K. Assuming that a family of four can live on $50K (including taxes) in - most - locations, which is twice the poverty limit, they can theoretically save $30K a year in a mix of 401K, IRA, and general investment accounts. This amount, if invested over thirty years with a 7.5% annual return (which is lower than what the S&P has historically returned by a fair amount), would give them a nest-egg of $3M. If they only manage to save half of that amount, they would still have $1.5M by retirement. Now, this is a very feasible scenario for families in their twenties to late thirties, which is why many of the names mentioned in the article harp on the importance of investing early. It doesn't work nearly as well once you reach that point. However, the opposite - not saving or investing, and having a large amount of consumer debt - leads to significantly worse outcomes.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The median household income in the United States is $79.9K. No, its not, that's the median family income, which only counts groups of two or more people related by birth, marriage, or adoption living in the same home, whereas median family income includes single-member households and those whose members have no family relation, and thus is significantly lower, about $65K.
- zhdc1 5y agoIf we want to be pedantic, I was using the median - family - income estimate from HUD, which includes Puerto Rico and extrapolates off of the 2018 ACS. The Census Bureau, which lags by a year or so, puts the figure at $86K.
- giantg2 5y ago"The median household income in the United States is $79.9K. Assuming that a family of four can live on $50K (including taxes) in - most - locations, ... " I think the main problem here lies in assumption of the distribution over the various locations. $50k+ in Appalachia is good money and you might be able to save $30k out of $80k. One would not be saving and investing in many of the large cities and their suburbs (where more people live). One thing to note is that the $1.5M-3M is not inflation adjusted and would be worth much less than it is today. It will result in better outcomes, but it won't make people rich, like many claim. $1.5M is just enough to keep a couple out of poverty who will be retiring at 65 years old, 35 years from now. This is especially true if people live longer and the cost of healthcare continues to increase much faster than inflation. "(which is lower than what the S&P has historically returned by a fair amount)" The next decade is supposed to be much lower. (Past performance is not an indicator of future returns).
- fossuser 5y agoThe r/personalfinance and r/financialindependence subreddits are quite good and even cover more exotic details like the “mega back door roth” otherwise known as “after tax 401k contribution in plan conversions to roth” (which can let you add an additional 36k to a Roth IRA over the 6k limit each year in addition to the normal 19.5k for a traditional 401k). They’re mostly bogleheads so are a little risk averse, but for most that’s probably the right move anyway.
- sokoloff 5y agoIn the overall distribution of risk-aversion, bogleheads are more comfortable with risk than far too many savers. I’ve seen too many of my parents’ generation squander decades of investment returns because of the idea that stocks are risky.
- Spivak 5y agoI mean once you reach a certain age you really can’t afford to just hold on to your investments for a few decades because of a financial downturn. That retirement money is also most people’s emergency medical fund which can and does hit people in their 40s.
- sokoloff 5y agoI’m not saying to put 100% of every liquid dollar you have into the market, but in your 40s, I think it should be the majority of your investment funds. Boglehead advice agrees, with an explicit principle of “Never bear too much or too little risk”, suggesting 30-40% bonds in your 40s and the rest in stocks. I think more people underperform from being too risk-averse than under-perform from having too much equity exposure and having an unfortunate overlap of a large expense and a downturn in the market.
- spekcular 5y agoThe book "Lifecycle Investing," by Yale professors Nalebuff and Ayres, argues that a young person ought to invest 100% or even more (via leverage) in stocks. (More specifically, a young person with high future earning potential, which probably includes many people here with a career in tech.) I'm fairly risk averse and don't totally believe their leverage calculations. But it did convince me that any non-negligible bond allocation is probably suboptimal.
- pushrax 5y agoOwning a small slice of a business where you're employed can also help make you rich if it grows a lot. In the tech world there are probably more financially independent employees than founders, because of the growth of some massive companies over the last few decades and high salaries. Probably a different story in the UHNW category though, very few employees can get to that level.
- Nasrudith 5y agoThe obvious pitfall is that it is putting both your income sources in the same basket. Unless you have sufficient liquidatable savings that is a bit of a "flying jump kick" - if it lands it works great, if it doesn't you are left committed to a train wreck and pain will follow.
- pushrax 5y agoDefinitely true - usually you don't have a choice though due to vesting schedules and/or illiquid markets pre IPO.
- dheera 5y ago> max out 401k plan works What are the advantages of 401k instead of say dumping it into half-VOO half-crypto and making millions one way or another?
- MattGaiser 5y agoA 401K is a box, not a specific investment. You can put things like VOO in the box. Anything in the box is tax advantaged however.
- whateveracct 5y agoTax advantages basically mean you make the dollars invested inherently worth more
- pushrax 5y agoThe variance in potential outcomes of holding VOO is much, much lower than the variance of holding crypto. Buying VOO buys a share of the profits of the work of many millions of people. It also speculates that other people will continue to want to buy those profits. Buying a token only speculates that more people will want to buy that particular token. It's much harder to project that people will continue to want it.
- zhdc1 5y ago