3 ms·
> The process is federally operated and the same processes are followed everywhere. The US has state-run elections, as provided in the Constitution (Article II
by sokoloff 5y ago
> The process is federally operated and the same processes are followed everywhere.
The US has state-run elections, as provided in the Constitution (Article II, section 1).
Each state could individually opt-in to use a federally run system (or portion thereof), but the feds can’t mandate it, absent a Constitutional amendment.
The USA is really a republic of states in many regards and the states have [or at least started with and in theory still have] a lot more power than in many other countries where the central government is stronger.
- syshum 5y ago16th and 17th amendment neutered alot of power the States had.. With the 16th the federal government was able to extort/bribe the states with money... With the 17th the states lost their voice in Congress... The 2 combined has really hurt the idea of State Sovereignty. Personally I would like to see that power restored back to the States
- sokoloff 5y agoI agree with your overall preference. I’m not as sure that the 17th stripped power from the states, so much as defined how that power was elected. (It’s clear that it could make some difference but not clear that it shifts overall power federally.)
- syshum 5y agoBecause before the 17th the Senate was the State Governments representative in the congress. Senators represented the desire of the State Legislatures not the People of the states. This is why all spending bills have to start in the House, because the House is the peoples voice in congress, and if they want to spend the peoples money it has to start with the peoples voice, not the States. The US was to be a republic with only a single part of the new federal government democratically elected, there was / is a reason for that. Separation of Powers and distributed power being the key concepts. By changing congress to have both the house and the senate become democratically elected the State Governments lost their voice in the federal government.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> The US was to be a republic with only a single part of the new federal government democratically elected Just because the president is elected indirectly through electors, and Senators were elected through States, doesn't mean they were any less "democratically elected" than Representatives. You could equally say that the House of Representatives is undemocratic because democracy would require all laws to be approved by referendum. Also, in case anyone still thinks that representative democracy is antithetical to the goal of a republic, and goes against the wishes of the Founding Fathers, they should consider Hamilton's words: "But a representative democracy, where the right of election is well secured and regulated & the exercise of the legislative, executive and judiciary authorities, is vested in select persons, chosen really and not nominally by the people, will in my opinion be most likely to be happy, regular and durable." https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-01-02-0162 https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Hamilton/01-01-02-01...
- syshum 5y ago>> You could equally say that the House of Representatives is undemocratic because democracy would require all laws to be approved by referendum. I do say that, I know its probably a shock but I am not a fan of democracy. I believe democracy is 2 wolves and a lamb voting on what is for dinner. I do not support the generally popular idea that democracy is the best form of governance. >>anyone still thinks that representative democracy is antithetical to the goal of a republic It can go against the goals of the republic, democracy itself needs to be balanced against other powers. The US was setup to be a careful balance of interests, over the years we have upset that balance and today the democratic elements of our republic are antithetical to the goals of the republic as founded, which was to promote and preserve the Lockean philosophy of individual rights. The democratic elements in our current system have replaced this idea of Individual rights, with the idea of collective rights... Has replaced the philosophy of negative rights, with positive rights. Has replaced individualism, with collectivism Individualist like myself see this has a problem. >>goes against the wishes of the Founding Fathers, they should consider Hamilton's words: Personally I am not a big fan of Hamilton, and he hardly spoke for all the "Founding Fathers". Many people seem to have this idea that the "Founding Fathers" all sat in a room agreeing with each other. Far far from the case. They largely disagreed with each other, and many hated each other. Personally I am more of a Jefferson, and Franklin supporter than a Hamilton supporter. Hamilton had the desire to create a much stronger and more centralized federal government than many of the other Founders were comfortable with, He had to make many concessions that reduced the power of the federal government. Most famously he was opposed to the Bill of Rights even being included as he saw it as unnecessary... No to me Jefferson was better founder... and if I was alive then I likely would have been a part of the Anti-Federalists...