4 ms·
Well, infinity is inherently unscientific, as there is no way to scientifically differentiate between an infinite quantity and a really huge quantity (same for
by tsimionescu 5y ago
Well, infinity is inherently unscientific, as there is no way to scientifically differentiate between an infinite quantity and a really huge quantity (same for infinitesimals), in finite time.
What this means is that a universe that contains infinities is, even in theory, entirely indistinguishable (in finite time) from an universe that contains really large/small but finite quantities.
- turminal 5y ago> there is no way to scientifically differentiate between an infinite quantity and a really huge quantity (same for infinitesimals), in finite time That depends on the model of computation you pick, doesn't it?
- tsimionescu 5y agoOnly if you want to think about models of computation that allow performing infinite operations in finite amounts of time, which I don't think are that interesting.
- auggierose 5y agoI'd say if our universe makes such computations possible, then that would be very interesting.
- tsimionescu 5y agoAbsolutely! Similarly, if our universe allowed instantaneous travel and free energy, that would also be very interesting. Not holding my breath for either.
- auggierose 5y agoThe fact that you can breath at all is quite a miracle. Not sure why you are so pessimistic about the rest.
- ithkuil 5y agoWhat about negative numbers? Or complex numbers? They are only tools, which can be quite useful to build models of the world with predictive powers but shouldn't be confused for the underlying reality. Even whole numbers are an abstraction that makes sense only when you can clearly define what is the thing you're counting.
- tsimionescu 5y agoWhole numbers can be defined and proven to be necessary to describe the world pretty easily. From there, rational numbers are trivial to define. Negative numbers are somewhat more abstract, but they have very intuitive definitions in many domains, such as accounting. It may be possible to avoid them in a theory of physics, though. The complex numbers (well, at least those with a rational imaginary part and a rational real part) have been recently proven to be necessary to describe the universe[0] (assuming quantum theory is correct). The irrational numbers are then are the only numbers that are harder to pin down, and I'm not sure that there is a way to prove that any physical quantity has an irrational value, vs a rational value that is arbitrarily close to that irrational value. [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/2101.10873 https://arxiv.org/abs/2101.10873
- ithkuil 5y agoInfinity may be also "necessary to describe the world". But like every tool, you need to know its limits.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI'm not sure that it could be, actually. You can't use a finite amount of evidence to verify that something is infinite, so any infinity can always be replaced with a huge (or minuscule) number and the theory would make the same measurable predictions.
- ithkuil 5y agoI'm not talking about proving that there exist infinite things. I'm talking about using the abstract concepts of infinity as a useful mathematical tool to produce predictions. Notable example: calculus
- canjobear 5y agoI don’t see how this makes infinity “unscientific.” Infinity is part of the language of mathematics. It’s no more scientific or unscientific than the definition of matrix multiplication. Also wouldn’t your argument also apply to zero? You can never know if a quantity is zero as opposed to some enormously small epsilon that you haven’t detected yet. Is zero “unscientific?”
- tsimionescu 5y agoWell, I can say that there are precisely 0 african elephants in the room with me right now, so no, 0 and other integers don't have this problem. Similarly, the rationals are clearly realizable with perfect precision. The reals however are a different problem, and it's not scientifically possible to prove that the ratio between the length and radius of any object is exactly pi (that it is a perfect circle). However, it's also impossible to prove scientifically that it is 3 or 3.14 or any other number. Now my use of "unscientific" is more of a hyperbole or click-bait. I thought I explained my actual claim pretty well - that you can't measurably/scientifically distinguish between a universe that contains actual infinities and one that only contains some arbitrarily large numbers.
- snet0 5y agoThat's just because you use the word "exact", though. Exactitude doesn't exist in the universe as we understand it. There's a difference between something not being instantiated in this universe and being unscientific, though. If we produce a model of the universe that doesn't make a single incorrect prediction given all data available, and it predicts infinities to exist in some strange but quite real cases, is it unscientific?
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Exactitude doesn't exist in the universe as we understand it. Of course exactitude exists. For example, two electrons have exactly the same charge. A photon has exactly 0 charge. > There's a difference between something not being instantiated in this universe and being unscientific, though. Well, science is a particular way of studying what exists. Studying something that doesn't exist is unscientific (of course, you can use science to try to determine IF something exists). But there are also things that are outside the reach of the methods of science, so they are unscientific in this sense. Questions such as "did some god create the universe" are unscientific because it is simply impossible to apply the methods of science to arrive at an answer to this question. Similarly, asking "is the universe infinite in size" is unscientific, because it is impossible to apply the methods of science and arrive at a definite answer to this question. > If we produce a model of the universe that doesn't make a single incorrect prediction given all data available, and it predicts infinities to exist in some strange but quite real cases, is it unscientific? If it predicts actual infinities exist in certain conditions, than it is not going to be a testable theory in those conditions. It may still be a perfectly workable model, just as GR is perfectly workable despite predicting singularities at the center of black holes. That doesn't mean that the singularities exist, it means that GR breaks down at certain points. But even if you had a physical theory that relied on something like a Banach-Tarski construction, you could never distinguish between an actual infinity of points, leading to two perfectly solid, perfectly identical spheres; and an arbitrarily large number of points, leading either to two perfectly solid but slightly different-sized spheres; or two identically-sized spheres with small holes. Of course, without some need to specify the number of points, you would be well positioned to use the infinite variant. But if someone asked you if this means that the sphere really has an infinite number of points, the answer would have to be that you can't be sure.