3 ms·
While I think Nicklaus' mindset is commendable, I also think there is a real danger trying to think his lessons are widely applicable. Jack was by far the best
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
While I think Nicklaus' mindset is commendable, I also think there is a real danger trying to think his lessons are widely applicable.
Jack was by far the best golfer of his era, and he made many millions of dollars playing a game he loved, so he could easily afford things like having his family travel with him everywhere. For nearly all others caught up in the rat race with an unhealthy work-life balance, they can't say the same.
I'll just speak personally for myself, but I know some of my tendencies to over-commit to work are because I, just like Jack, want to be really great at what I do. But at the same time, I don't have anywhere near the same level of comparable talent in my field, so I have to work much longer at it, and I'm still rarely satisfied with the results.
It kind of reminds me of stuff I've read about Usain Bolt, that he's really chill and laid back. When you know you have the innate gifts to never lose, it's easier to feel that way.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoIt must be nice to be able to focus on the one thing you are really good at, and make enough money with it so you can spend money to get help at all the other aspects of life. That’s why it often bothers me when celebrity mothers talk about life balance in talk shows and get admired for it. This is much easier to achieve if you can afford nannies, cooks and cleaners. In general, be wary of life advice from wealth people. Their advice often doesn’t apply to the average guy.
- kwanbix 5y ago100% truth. While living in south america, we could afford a nanny and a cleaning/cooking person. Life was so much easier from that point of view.
- EngCanMan 5y agoYour views are ones that are unfortunately too common in society, the common theme being ‘the successful guy has it easy, if he had my problems…’. The successful probably worked harder than you, made smarter/luckier choices than you, and had to overcome many of the same problems as you. Society needs to stop excusing their own problems as if the successful don’t have them too.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoWhat you've written is a total, 100% mischaracterization of my opinion. I don't think Nicklaus "had it easy", nor do I think there probably weren't lots of things he had to overcome. But at the very top echelons of sport, virtually all the difference in success comes down to innate talent. Why? Because at that level, basically all the competitors are putting in nearly the maximum about of time and practice necessary to succeed. We don't ever really try to deny this either - look at how sportscasters talk about people like Bolt, Nicklaus, Messi, Ronaldo, Biles, James, Phelps, etc. etc. Nobody denies they work really hard, but also nobody denies their innate gifts are otherworldly. I mean, I've seen loads of articles that talk about how Phelps is almost genetically constructed to have the perfect body for swimming. And I don't begrudge any of these superstars for their success - on the contrary, they bring me lots of joy by sharing their insane talents with the world. What I do begrudge is the messaging that we can all "be like Mike" if we just put our mind to it and work hard, and then we can have a nice work-life balance to boot. I'd much rather read articles about "average" people and how they learned to balance their desire for success with healthy relationships.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- k__ 5y agoThe truth is actually the other way around. Right, the successful people have problems too, had to work hard to get where they are. Often the only difference between successful and unsuccessful people is their success. Having the same problems as successful people, without the success, doesn't really make for an easy life
- mfer 5y agoJack didn’t overcommit. For example, he played a limited set of events each year. There are some lessons in that. You don’t need to overcommit to be great. He prioritized family over money and success (he could have won more tournaments which bring more money and records). We can all do that
- frankbreetz 5y agoSome people don't need to overcommmit to be great. I, for instance, could go through a similar golf itinerary as Jack and would only be an average golfer, as I am not a gifted golfer. I could perhaps dedicate every waking second to golf and perhaps become pro, but still probably not. Jack had a once in a generation talent to go along with his commitment to work life balance.
- mfer 5y agoA lot of people feel the need to overcommit in the chase to try to become an all time great at a thing. While overcomitting they miss out on many other things in life and have poor relationships along the way. Often not realizing the lack in quality of the relationships until they regret it.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoWhat you are saying exactly proves my point: "A lot of people feel the need to overcommit in the chase to try to become an all time great at a thing." Jack Nicklaus was the all time great at a thing, and could still have a nice work life balance. My point is not that Jack Nicklaus did anything wrong, it's just that the lessons learned from his life aren't really applicable to many other folks because he didn't have to choose between being the best and his relationships - very few other people have that option. I feel pretty strongly about this point because I see it all the time in "feel good" articles and stories in the US. One of my favorite examples were all the "best lessons of business from Google" books that seemed to be all the rage in the 00s. Except that Google had discovered and eventually monopolized a giant, nearly endless profit producing machine that hardly any other companies have access to. So much of the tools of that success (e.g. hiring top talent, giving that talent lots of freedom, 20% time, loads of cushy benefits, yada yada) were only possible with their giant pit of cash. And I'm not saying other companies weren't immensely profitable yet still fucked things up, I'm just saying the primary keys to Google's success is the immense profitability of their business, not all the other things than can result from that.
- jlarocco 5y agoWhile I agree it's a little easier for a famous millionaire to say it, I think you're missing the point, which is that "success" is subjective and everybody decides for themselves what's important. It's only a rat-race if you choose it. Nicklaus wasn't saying, "I have economic success, so now I focus on my other priorities," but instead, "My family is my priority, and I make economic success fit around them." Personally, I don't see any danger in more ordinary people taking that advice. Realistically, most of us won't be rich and famous no matter how hard we try, so why sacrifice so much trying to do so? Focus on something more realistic, like enjoying family or recreation.
- listenallyall 5y ago> he could easily afford things like having his family travel with him everywhere Most people's job don't require them to travel every week. They see their family every day, but are still unable to manage a healthy work-life balance. Jack made a significant effort to work at it, it's rather obvious when you see his interviews and public appearances.
- watwut 5y ago> he could easily afford things like having his family travel with him everywhere That is not easy, because your partner is very likely to get sick of following you all the time randomly and not having own stable life. Whether career or social network while being at home. Same with kids, they actually like and need stable friendships.