5 ms·
So... a few anecdotes packed together is the new journalism?
by ekianjo 5y ago
So... a few anecdotes packed together is the new journalism?
- gogopuppygogo 5y agoYep. All ad money went to zuck, brin, and page.
- Applejinx 5y agoUpvoting this grayed-out comment. Like it or not, overly generalized/personalized or not, this is still an important truth about how journalism is sustained under capitalism. Extremely large quantities of money have been removed from the business models of traditional, worker-employing journalism and redirected to Google, Facebook etc. to the point where I don't understand how any of the traditional old school businesses remain functioning at all. Hell, Craigslist struggles, and Craigslist was an early wave of the internet hurting what newspapers do. "Yep. All ad money went to zuck, brin, and page" is glib, but does not deserve this degree of downvoting. In important ways, it's the truth.
- luckylion 5y agoNot sure about Craigslist. How is anyone expected not to struggle when they seem to have done little in terms of improvements in 25 years? I checked whether it's still alive and it had a few listings in Berlin, one of which may or may not be offering to sell a baby, so at least it's kind of a weird lawless place, but I'm not sure that's enough to run a business on (might be good enough for a few reddit threads exploring creepy stuff though). I'm sure that ad spending has shifted online, but traditional media companies have been losing audience before Google launched News and Facebook started to dominate. There's plenty to blame, and the web as a whole probably played a part, but I'm not sure it's the primary driver. Before there were online alternatives, there was TV or just not getting "the news" at all. Relying on not having competition feels like a bad idea with regards to being a sustainable business.
- Tycho 5y agoIt’s The Guardian, journalism isn’t what they’re known for.
- gizdan 5y agoWhile I agree that getting the opinions of a few individuals is not particularly good journalism, this opinion seems to be the consensus among almost everyone I've spoken to about this. Colleagues, ex-colleagues, friends, family, everyone. The few who I have talked to that still want an office, have been in leadership positions, and usually this is from those who are higher up in the ranks. Fact of the matter is, an office is an outdated method of working with today's technology. It just took a pandemic for the general public to realise this. You pay for a commute that's not necessary, you pay with your time (that you're not paid for) to get there (time that you could be spending on family, or something else), and depending on where you work, you're probably smelling 100s of people's sweat every day, and taking in, and contributing to, a whole lot pollution.
- dazc 5y agoI dare say it is the consencus but I don't think it's a surprise to learn that people hate commuting. The problem is that managers want to see people working and an office environment is perfect for this purpose. I would be surprised if anything really changes in this regard long-term, other than in a few outlying cases.
- iamstupidsimple 5y agoDo managers really care if you're in seats working? Most managers I know are fans of remote because they're usually older and have family. The push to return is coming from company executives at the very top.
- dazc 5y agoAnecdotally, there are a lot of bad managers around who do care. I'm glad your actual experience contradicts this.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoThis hasn't been my experience so far, I've been looking at moving jobs recently and I've got plenty of options even after discarding anything with required office hours or "temporarily remote" jobs which will return to mandatory commuting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _rpd 5y agoYou're lucky it isn't just images of their tweets tied together with an 'emerging trend' narrative.
- lazyjones 5y agoOnly if they are carefully chosen to support a particular narrative.
- sprafa 5y agoThis was always the case!
- wayanon 5y agoA few days ago there was an online thing on the Guardian site for people to add stories like this of their own experience.
- eplanit 5y agoYup. Anecdotes or lies; take your pick.
- skrebbel 5y agoI wish there was an HN guideline against nihilism.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- simonswords82 5y agoThe BBC news website was previously very high quality mostly impartial journalism. I am not sure why but the quality and impartiality has dropped noticeably over the last 10 years.
- lmm 5y agoAlways has been. The internet exacerbated things by publishing more anecdotes to cherry-pick from, but journalists were never scrupulous about taking a representative sample, and the Guardian in particular has always been practically innumerate.
- hatware 5y agoDo you think the views expressed in the article are something that has been fairly covered through all this time...? This is a breath of fresh air, finally some cost-benefit analysis is being done on what was a very hasty set of decisions.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoMaybe it's Google's algorithm, as I have clicked on several of the articles from an Android, but it feels to me as I have seen more and more of these "pro commuter" and "how the office is a better place to work than home" articles come out now that we're coming to a point where lock downs are supposed to be ending. In the beginning, all of the opinion pieces seemed to be, "Work from home, is it the wave of the future?" style pieces. It's either journalism trying to ride a wave or being paid to push a narrative. Business as usual in the journalism world.