4 ms·
Is Zoom Illegal in the EU? Unpacking the Hamburg DPA’s Decision
- rnd420_69 5y ago*is the current implementation of zoom illegal in the EU because it doesn't follow data privacy laws? yes
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoCorrect, then… why is still in use everywhere in the EU?
- nextlevelwizard 5y agoWhy do people... regularly speed in their cars? incorrectly dispose their waste? use illegal narcotics? not correctly pay taxes on things they sell? Because most people don't care and risk of getting caught and then being fined for it is low enough.
- bserge 5y agoOr the law is shit.
- blackbear_ 5y agoOr the law is good but the enforcement is shit.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoThis I think!
- stingraycharles 5y agoThere have not been many instances where the DPA is enforced. And enforcement happens on a national level, not EU. Someone has to file a complaint at some national watchdog, who then investigates (which can take a long time), and then can fine the business. This happened only a handful of times in the EU over the past few years, not sure about Zoom specifically.
- sprafa 5y agoMaybe that’s a good thing?
- raverbashing 5y ago> This decision is specific to one controller—the Hamburg Senate Chancellery—and to one Zoom implementation—”on-demand” mode. So, as per Betteridge's law of Headlines: No More specifically: it applies when recording meetings
- jacquesm 5y agoThe article is not served well by the headline.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoNo, it applies when requiring registration to access features such as on-demand recordings. Most Zoom users are probably registered & logged in one way or the other. Did none of you read the article? Do none of you understand GDPR?
- jacquesm 5y ago> Did none of you read the article? Did you not read the guidelines? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- eurasiantiger 5y agoIt was a legitimate question at the commenters.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe title here is quite suggestive, this is limited to one feature of zoom (recording) and transferring data outside of the EU without sufficient guarantees that users data privacy is guarded. Of course this goes much further than just zoom, but in the narrow context of the case (the use of Zoom by German authorities) it makes sense to be at least doing the right thing, whereas many companies would probably never even think about what the consequences are of streaming meetings through services such as Zoom, Google meet, Microsoft 'Teams' and so on. Regardless of the legality it's a shitty implementation of a pretty simple concept, I'm not surprised their legal implementation is similarly broken, Zoom could easily set things up so EU customer data never leaves the EU. That would be the simplest solution to the problem. Oh, and their conclusion 'The Hamburg DPA’s decision implies that it is unlawful for US-based data controllers to use Zoom.' is utter bullshit. What this article really is is a thinly disguised advert for a for-pay event.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoIt is not limited to the on-demand recording feature: it is caused by requiring registration to access those on-demand recordings. If your organisation uses paid Zoom, you are probably already registered to Zoom, and this decision does very likely apply to you.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou disagree and then proceed to agree. I'm not sure I follow you.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoTry reading a bit more carefully.
- ddevault 5y ago>First, the EU data protection authorities (DPAs) came for your newsletter (Mailchimp). Then, they came for your cloud storage provider (Cloudflare). And on Monday, the Hamburg DPA said using Zoom could be incompatible with the GDPR’s data transfer rules. Alternate subtitle: First, the your spam service (Mailchimp) stole your personal information. Then, your MitM-as-a-service (Cloudflare) stole your personal information. And now, the meeting service with flagrant disregard for privacy and security and several useful alternatives available (Zoom) stole your personal information. The EU told them all to knock it off.
- bserge 5y agoThe same EU that will be scanning all my texts soon (to protect the kids, of course). What a fucking joke.
- 12ian34 5y agoIs this SMS specifically? Do you still use it?
- input_sh 5y agoIt's basically a pointless publicity stunt. The law in question provides a hole for private companies to allow them to scan for child molestation materials, allowing Apple and similar to do what they were intending on doing anyway. There was a pressure to pass something quickly for whatever reason (I'm sure has nothing to do with Silicon Valley lobbyists), it's "legally flawed" and it will crumble in front of the court. It's a performance for the sake of the performance. European MPs pretend that they're doing something about the problem without ever even beginning to address it, fully aware that courts will undo their "effort", at which point they'd be like "oh well, we did our part".
- noptd 5y ago>it will crumble in front of the court I hope so considering the precedent it sets but what makes you think that'll be the case?
- TheGigaChad 5y agoWho cares about the EU soys?
- richwater 5y agoEU has a hard-on for punishing/taxing US tech companies. This is not surprising.
- npteljes 5y agoGo EU! It's time EU had its own infra.
- nih0 5y agoUS tech has a hard-on for ignoring EU law. This is not surprising.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoUS tech firms deem themselves to be above the law. Most countries can't even do anything about it. Once in a blue moon EU squeeses them where it hurts, and you get these screams of "oh noe, US firms that operate how the please and pay no tax are being harrassed"! So entitled, its unbelievable.
- dathinab 5y agoOne important question is: What value do SCCs have if the country you operate in requires you do breach that contract on demand. I.e. if it is from the get-to-go known that you will likely not be able to uphold the contract.