5 ms·
This is a respectable strategy, but in a more prosperous society we would expect people to be able to have stuff and establish themselves as adults early. We l
by roenxi 5y ago
This is a respectable strategy, but in a more prosperous society we would expect people to be able to have stuff and establish themselves as adults early.
We live in an age of literal miracles. Thinking rocks, floating metal, what amounts to telepathy, machines roaming the countryside that dwarf giants, bodies being reshaped and redrawn, pandemics being fought back after a year or two. There really need to be some hard questions asked about why exactly a kid can't expect to move in to their own a home at 20.
I'm not saying there are easy answers. Maybe the world is just so complicated that a normal 20 year old can't make a meaningful contribution any more. But it is worth at least talking form time to time about why it is so hard to for young people to be independent. What exactly is the deal they are being offered here?
- mgh2 5y ago> Thinking rocks, floating metal, what amounts to telepathy, machines roaming the countryside that dwarf giants, bodies being reshaped and redrawn. ?? Please elaborate. Ask foreigners: They don't have parent's insurance or homes, yet are expected to survive without being able to take jobs that are reserved for Americans only. Americans have it easy.
- roenxi 5y agoI was thinking computers, cargo ships, SMS, cranes, mRNA vaccines and the COVID respectively. They're all pretty mundane because humans can get used to anything given a few months. But the things we have these days are all crazy.
- yardie 5y agoA permanent resident immigrant to the US is expected to have savings or a family network that can support them. The days of showing up to the border with the close on your back and $50 in your pocket are long over. And exactly what jobs are reserved for Americans? Only ones I know of are DoD or security clearance.
- mgh2 5y agoThe secret of companies nowadays is that discrimination occurs behind the curtains. When you are applying for jobs they will ask you "do you require sponsorship now or in the future?". Although it is illegal to discriminate based on country of origin, companies do it all the time - at the least, they will outright reject a candidate based on this criteria and at the worst, they string them along on years of abuse/slavery through an H1B and lower salary compared to Americans. Nobody wants to do extra paper-work and run through the hassle (laws) of hiring a foreigner if the risk is higher than hiring an American - if they do, they better get a better deal. Ask HR, STEM international students, someone on H1B. There are lucky ones, especially CS majors, but the majority is abused by the system due to the power imbalance. This is unknown to the average American, you don't know how much the balance has been tilted in your favor from the start. > The days of showing up to the border with the close on your back and $50 in your pocket are long over. You seem blind to the realities. Americans complain too much because they can, millions of people are just happy to have a way to survive. I did not even touch upon illegal immigrants who live in the shadows/fear, working quietly for a better future...
- yardie 5y agoCountry of origin and immigration status are not the same thing. A company cannot discriminate based on origin. Immigration status is something else. Companies are legally required to ask if you are eligible to work in the country. If your skills are in demand enough they can pursue a visa for you. If not, you’re just another cog in the machine. They are free to find someone who can meet the requirement.
- mgh2 5y agoI bet HR prepared the legal language to avoid discrimination charges. Even if the immigration status is legal, Americans have an unfair advantage just because they were born in the right place. Americans live in a privileged bubble, especially the tech sector. Remember tech wanted to increase the quota for H1Bs? It was a pro-immigration marketing stunt - because it is cheaper for them to abuse more workers. Progressives/liberals fight for minorities' rights, but who cares about immigrants, even if they are the backbone of your economy? Tech doesn't care, they profit from it. Tech (indeed, American enterprise) has always been a marketing show for the rich. Side note: Elon's hack in to the US as a Canadian > Aware it would be easier to enter the United States from Canada,[23] Musk applied for a Canadian passport through his Canadian-born mother. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk
- MattGaiser 5y ago> There really need to be some hard questions asked about why exactly a kid can't expect to move in to their own a home at 20. You can, just not a nice one in a major city. Given the choice between my parent's house and a small condo, house is a lot nicer. Given the options, it will never be the case that a 20 year old can have the same standard of living as what they grew up with right away. You choices are to lower your standard of living as you just aren't as valuable economically or stay put.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoAlso, older generations lived through some of the most prosperous times in American history. Those conditions no longer exist, where you could have a comfortable middle class existence on a single income.
- jaybrendansmith 5y agoBut why don't they exist anymore? Everything I read indicates that our productivity increase is the same since 1950. Surely, there must be some explanation...
- mgh2 5y agoA complicated issue, but here is a hypothesis: a shift in culture. People are not valued anymore, the current generation only seeks "quick money". Ex: 4HWW, Robinhood, FIRE, crypto, social media, (even startups) etc. promote this mentality and are either responses or symptoms of this shift. https://m-g-h.medium.com/why-we-are-dispensable-7a577eba4f3e https://m-g-h.medium.com/why-we-are-dispensable-7a577eba4f3e
- toomuchtodo 5y agoGlobalization, a decline in unions and collective bargaining power, inflation of healthcare, real estate, and education costs, etc. Middle class America had it good after world war 2 until capital and the rest of the world caught up.
- adriangrigore 5y agoLiving without any expectations is the healthy way to live. How to not have expectations, take things as they are, and understand that it's false that they "should" be in any other way.