2 ms·
It is also a sad part of human psychology that it took this to get Afghanistan back in the headlines. The level of horror has probably been pretty constant from
by roenxi 5y ago
It is also a sad part of human psychology that it took this to get Afghanistan back in the headlines. The level of horror has probably been pretty constant from when the troops rolled in to now.
It isn't like this level of failure is a sudden and radical surprise when it comes to Afghanistan. It is clear at this point that the US hasn't been doing anything useful there for the last 20 years.
- jacobolus 5y agoThe war in Afghanistan was lost by the Bush II administration sometime between 2001–2003. They took what should have been an international law enforcement operation and turned it into an indefinite military occupation with no plan, no criteria for success, and no off-ramp. They dumped hundreds of billions of dollars in with limited accountability or due diligence. They had no clear separation between “good guys” and “bad guys” and limited understanding of local relationships or culture, and ended up killing large numbers of civilians and leaving a large part of the population and local social structures angry at them. The predictable product was a dependent and kleptocratic puppet government and military without local legitimacy or support, an endless parade of suffering, continuing local opposition, and ever growing apathy among the American public. US civilian and military leaders consistently lied to the public, and were too cowardly to admit their “mission” was an abject failure. And now all of the people who set up and supported this 20-year debacle: military contractors, hawkish congresspeople and DOD leaders, pro-establishment media, etc. have the temerity to claim that there was some kind of magical perfect withdrawal that the US military could have executed with no bloodshed or instability, and Biden’s administration were just too careless or pig headed to let them plan and execute.