9 ms·
I just can't honestly believe how anyone who's lived through the past 18 months thinks anything but the worst case scenario is possible. Right now in parts of t
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I just can't honestly believe how anyone who's lived through the past 18 months thinks anything but the worst case scenario is possible. Right now in parts of the US we have hospitals and ICUs that are at higher occupancy than they have been at any time during the pandemic, despite the fact that simple, safe, cheap and relatively unobtrusive measures that can prevent this have been widely available for months.
Compare that with what is needed to fight climate change, which is complex, expensive and at direct odds with the most straightforward pathway for billions of people to raise their standard of living (at least in the current moment). It is simply not possible with human nature to fight this calamity, at least how it has been presented.
I could see an outcome where advances in renewable energy and storage tech occur fast enough to make fossil fuels uncompetitive, but it's very difficult to see that happening fast enough to stave off disaster.
I feel like we've jumped off a tall cliff with no parachute, but because the valley floor is still a ways below we are trying to convince ourselves that we can knit a new parachute fast enough before we hit the ground.
Humans don't like to acknowledge that some situations are just not avoidable. I think the best we can do (at least at an individual level of you have the means) is to prepare for a much more unstable future world.
- mrfusion 5y agoTurn off the tv. Get outside you’ll feel better.
- tsimionescu 5y agoIn certain places in the world today, going outside may kill them from heatstroke. The number of such places is rapidly increasing.
- ThomPete 5y agomore die from cold
- chiefalchemist 5y agoIf we're myth busting, more die from too much food than not enough. Weight in excess is proven to weaken the immune system...
- tsimionescu 5y agoWhile the observation about the cold is fair, obesity is not "food in excess" the same way hunger is "missing food". We don't know the exact prime cause(s) of obesity, but the correlation between food availability and obesity is low.
- pc86 5y agoIn all but the <5% of occurrences where there is a hormonal imbalance or other medical issue, obesity is caused by eating too much food for your level of activity, full stop. Eating less and/or moving more will cause the vast, vast majority of obese people to lose weight. To say we don't know the cause of obesity is laughably wrong. If you mean "food in excess" at the personal, not societal, level, it's a completely accurate statement.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Eating less and/or moving more will cause the vast, vast majority of obese people to lose weight. Sure, for a few months, and then they'll get back to their lifestyle and put the weight back. The real question of course is why so many people have started overeating since the 1980s, and that is definitely not explained by changes in food availability. So sure, the proximate cause of obesity is chiar - eating more than you excersise - but the reason for this massive change in the behavior of the entire population is definitely not understood.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoI mentioned above but I'll repeat it here as well. Humans conform to the norms around them. As weight went up and it became normalized there's no feeling of being alienated. Smoking is a good example. It went up. But then it became unpopular and declined. Unfortunately, it's not acceptable to mention someone's weight. And the less that was allowed the more normalized it came be. It's ok for Oprah and such to promote the idea of "love yourself." Unfortunately they failed to mention that some versions of yourself might be unhealthy. And here we are, in the middle of a health pandemic and we are unable to discuss some of the root causes of worse outcomes.
- chiefalchemist 5y ago> Right now in parts of the US we have hospitals and ICUs that are at higher occupancy than they have been at any time during the pandemic, despite the fact that saimple, safe, cheap and relatively unobtrusive measures that can prevent this have been widely available for months. I presume you're referring to the fact that we had plenty of time to push back against climate change, but year over year have refused to make progress. Perhaps you're also upset about the lack of true leadership towards that goal? Much the same leadership / system has been incompotent and negligent over the last 18 months.Agreed, you're correct, if we had able and willing leaders more people might assimilate, else yes there's plenty of reason for doubt and lack of compliance. It's easy and normalized to blame the powerless. But we proles would be wise to resist that convenience and being to hold the powerful accountable. The current status quo isn't working.
- throw63738 5y agoPeople adapt. We survived ice age, we will survive warmer climate.
- IanCal 5y agoIf your bar is "a few thousand people survive" then most scenarios will seem OK, but that's not really what we're generally talking about.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI agree, I think "we", as a society will adapt. But I also can't help being put off by the nonchalant manner of that comment, given that "adapting" will result in extreme levels of upheaval, and the resulting resource wars and societal instability. Yes, we'll adapt, and huge swaths of humanity will die and suffer as a result.
- jka 5y ago> I could see an outcome where advances in renewable energy and storage tech occur fast enough to make fossil fuels uncompetitive This has, I think, near enough happened already. What we're battling currently is inertia, vested interests, and misinformation. With sufficient political vision and will, I think that the energy mix (both generation-side and consumption-side, across residential, commercial and industrial use) could change fairly swiftly. There are so many upsides to renewables that we'll look back and question why fossil fuels remained in use for so long. I've no association with the IEA but have been reading around their website a bit today and found an (optimistic, perhaps) report[1] of theirs on "Net Zero by 2050" inspiring. The link below is to a page in the (CDN-hosted) report containing "Key Pillars of Decarbonisation" - actionable and well-explained suggestions on their net zero roadmap: https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/beceb956-0dcf-4d73-89fe-1310e3046d68/NetZeroby2050-ARoadmapfortheGlobalEnergySector_CORR.pdf#page=65 https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/beceb956-0dcf-4d73-... [1] - https://www.iea.org/reports/net-zero-by-2050 https://www.iea.org/reports/net-zero-by-2050