3 ms·
> [...]hostile political discussions are the result of status-driven individuals who are drawn to politics and are equally hostile both online and offline. Fina
by pessimizer 5y ago
> [...]hostile political discussions are the result of status-driven individuals who are drawn to politics and are equally hostile both online and offline. Finally, we offer initial evidence that online discussions feel more hostile, in part, because the behavior of such individuals is more visible than offline.
Not only more visible, but more out of context. The identical political conversation between someone and their parent, for example, in the context of a loving family relationship, will be remembered differently than that discussion with a faceless online swarm. You're forced to think of your parent as a person, whereas anonymous opposition is easy to dehumanize. And if you're a middle-class PMC, you can just fall into thinking of the internet as a mob of subhuman lumpen morons out for bloodsport and seeing every interaction in which people vehemently disagree with you as further evidence of that.
----
Edit: The fixation on online culture as the source of strife from people annoys me. I know plenty of mean, aggressive people in real life. I know very few on the internet - because I know fewer people online than I do in real life. Seeing people you don't know be mean online and thinking that online life is meaner is like watching the local news and concluding that everyone but you, your family, friends, neighbors, and coworkers are murderers.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoThe question is if the ability of the hateful to find communities of like-unminded people allows them to persist, organize, and affect the lives of the objects of their hatred in ways that were less likely than before. I’m not sure what the answer is, tbh. I certainly doubt something like the Trump presidency would have been -possible, or as likely, before the internet. Organizations from ISIS to “proud boys” certainly profit from the ability to proselytize on YouTube. But, at the same time, the general trend of the arc of history bending towards justice appears to be still alive, to some degree.
- jcims 5y ago>... hateful ... like-unminded ... Do you see these folks you're talking about as fully human? I see this kind of classification a lot, as though 'they' are just a swarm of zombie NPCs following some simplistic algorithm.
- s5300 5y ago> fully human This is a bad argument. Perhaps try "humans capable of living in and contributing to a civilized and prosperous modern society" and, unfortunately, I think you'll often find the answer is that they are not, nor do they wish to exist in one. They want power and total control over, hilariously, the lives of others who simply want to live in and contribute to a civilized and prosperous modern society. They're hateful, violent, and time and time again show that they're incapable of coexisting with others who don't share their same close-minded fantastical views.
- jcims 5y agoIn the context of the article I'll replay how I processed your reply. > fully human This is a bad argument. My immediate reaction was 'it was a question, not an argument' and got a little stab of cortisol from my endocrine system. The 'bad' adjective could be interpreted as ignorant/incomplete or malicious, but usually when I see folks invoke the whole 'bad X' question, its really just a play to reframe the discussion or ignore some nuance of it. So it didn't start off well, and I immediately felt that the comment was either reactionary or using my comment as a trampoline to project some tangential point. Perhaps try "humans capable of living in and contributing to a civilized and prosperous modern society" So this led me to believe we're going down the 'reframing' road, as the comment is adding a bunch of conditions to the term 'human'. This, to me, is simply a way to filter out humans that don't meet those conditions. Particularly when the comment includes 'capable', which clearly creates two classes of human from a political standpoint, one of which should be engaged with because they are capable of being influenced, the other is simply livestock. and, unfortunately, I think you'll often find the answer is that they are not, nor do they wish to exist in one. They want power and total control over, hilariously, the lives of others who simply want to live in and contribute to a civilized and prosperous modern society. The comment kind of lost me here, to be honest. Clearly this could apply to any individual interested in amplifying their own political perspective. They're hateful, violent, and time and time again show that they're incapable of coexisting with others who don't share their same close-minded fantastical views. I think I landed at this comment attempting to shift focus to extremists rather than the rank and file of any particular political persuasion. It's possible that connects back to the article because the extremists of just about any ilk are a) interested in amplifying their political perspective and b) are quite possibly more inclined to engage in sharp discourse on the internet.
- bopbeepboop 5y agoThe problem with censoring is the bias you showed in your comment, with who you selected as examples. Eg, mentioning the Proud Boys, but not Antifa — the violent street gang who committed billions in arson, murdered dozens, and is still pepper-spraying children in Portland parks. You picked the smaller street gang, likely because you’re politically aligned with the larger, more violent one. I don’t disagree that many groups are “bad” — but that doesn’t mean I believe we can regulate that without the censorship being corrupted into something worse.
- revolvingocelot 5y ago>The question is if the ability of the hateful to find communities of like-unminded people allows them to persist, organize, and affect the lives of the objects of their hatred in ways that were less likely than before I suspect this is a serious factor. In the before-times, the ability of these people to meaningfully organize was hampered by their comparative rarity and geographical distribution. The consequences of those two factors created a damping effect: the majority of their social interactions were with non-extremists, giving them neither a chance to express extremism nor mutually reinforce their extreme beliefs.
- rufus_foreman 5y ago>> I know fewer people online than I do in real life That sounds very, very strange to me. I know I'm the one that's weird here, but wow.