5 ms·
DNA Tests May Increase Census Count Of Multiracial Population
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt's strange to see people lying/exaggerating about their racial diversity on census forms when under a century ago people lied about their racial purity on these forms to avoid being targeted by one-drop laws. It seems like a risky decision to make, as if those laws ever return your entire family tree could be punished for that box you checked.
- klipt 5y agoThe difference is that now, the discrimination against non white people is mostly unwritten (biases that have measurable effects, but are never outright stated as policies). Conversely all the discrimination against white people is formal (companies say they want to hire more non white people for diversity, government programs for minority owned businesses, etc). So from a game theory perspective, the best possible position is one where you are informally perceived as white (so you don't face any of the unwritten biases) but are formally listed as a marginalized group (so you benefit from formal policies intended to help those groups). Not surprising people who can, would use a DNA test as an excuse to put themselves in that group.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>So from a game theory perspective... The part you're forgetting is that is incredibly simple to prove you have racial diversity, you can just provide your DNA test results. But if you're formally listed as diverse, it is impossible to then prove you aren't.
- klipt 5y agoSo you think not taking a test will protect you if a Nazi government arises that wants to kill everyone who listed themselves as diverse? What would stop said Nazi government from forcing you to take the test anyway?
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>What would stop said Nazi government from forcing you to take the test anyway? The fact that testing everybody is difficult both politically and logistically.
- klipt 5y agoThat stops liberal democracies. It wouldn't stop Nazis.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoI'm discussing the return of one-drop laws, something that happened in a liberal democracy.
- decremental 5y agoThe Nazis don't exist anymore. It's so called liberal democracies you've got to be worried about.
- decremental 5y agoGovernments around the world are currently working on setting the precedent. Surely if you're a good person you'll take the test so we can strive towards true equity. Those anti-equityers are an existential threat to our society, and more importantly, to marginalized peoples. Sounds absurd but everything that sounds absurd today is only 5 years down the line. Think of what the unthinkable was 5 years ago or 10 years ago. Don't be surprised when you start to hear about equity ID.
- jl6 5y agoI think it’s more likely that increased population mixing will make everyone mixed race and we will have to find something else to talk about.
- uncoder0 5y agoI can't see that happening. Race is a valuable tool in capital's toolbox of divisiveness.
- speedgoose 5y ago> While partially based on physical similarities within groups, race does not have an inherent physical or biological meaning. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization)
- chillwaves 5y agoThat doesn't really matter for the purposes of the comment you are replying to.
- ReptileMan 5y agoSince Wikipedia has been run by ultra liberals lately take everything you read there with a grain of salt when it is related to the culture war.
- klipt 5y agoIf race has no biological meaning, why isn't Rachel Dolezal (who was raised with multiple adopted black brothers) allowed to identify as black? Isn't it seen as lying purely because of her ... genetics?
- tdfx 5y agoThe only thing holding this back is the economic dominance of white people. There's nothing inherently favorable about being white except that, in most cases of human history, white groups have been the dominant economic actors throughout the world. I could easily see this being shifted to another race, i.e. East Asian, should the economic balance of the world substantially change.
- lukesky3 5y agoIf and when you have 15 yo children applying to college, you'll understand this well. If you are Asian, you really understand it -- Ignoring justifiable attempts to increase diversity on campus, Asians find that being Asian American immediately docs points off as compared to White students. Of course I want to find the bit of white in me via DNA tests, so my child can get into a great school with, say, 2200 SATs (standard) vs the 2300 they would require as Asians.
- JPKab 5y agoMy wife's parents came to the United States from the Philippines. It's a very odd twist that our mixed-race children will benefit on their college admissions forms by checking the box for white. Completely unfair. I would vastly prefer to walk into any college campus in the United States and be vastly outnumbered by Asians who earned the privilege to be there than to see them be more representative of the population as a whole by changing the standards for different groups.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe expected result from what you're describing is people claiming that they aren't Asian, but the article discusses more people claiming that they are multiracial.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoClaiming or being Jewish would be the most advantageous to get into a top school. Way overrepresented ethnic group even accounting for higher IQ distribution.
- throwawaytruth1 5y agoWhat's even more disturbing is the fact that a lot of the justification of discrimination against asians, requiring higher test scores etc. is from none other than Ashkenazi Jews. Imagine the outcry if they were limited to be closer to their population percentage. If people actually cared about racism and being logically consistent, their first concern should be this massive overrepresentation of Jews. They don't.
- zazen 5y agoSouth Park saw it coming: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5F_AhciUy4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5F_AhciUy4
- lebuffon 5y agoSo did Russell Peters (comedian) "In the future there's gonna be a little brown in everybody"
- cherrycherry98 5y agoMy spouse and I did these tests and the results have changed a fair amount over the years. Where initially there were some surprising, albeit trace, amounts of DNA detected from certain ethnic groups, the results have now normalized down to what I would expect given my family history. If I had not checked in since my initial results I very well may have considered my ancestry to be something it's not. However, I increasingly question why I should care about my ancestry and what it says about me. I'm generations removed from those who arrived from foreign countries. I know less about what it means to be some of the ethnicities in my blood than those those that I'm not. I feel greater fellowship with others based on common interests than I do race. Next census I'll probably write in "American" or "Human", since these stats just seem to be used to advantage or disadvantage people based on group identity, regardless of their actual individual situation.
- foxhop 5y agoIt matters at least for your choices of diet which regulates your health. I never used any of these tests, it freaks me out a bit to be in some database. That said, My family of origin did too and had a similar experience. It's all a scam there are YouTube videos of identical twins taking tests from the major players. The data science was flawed because there is no science or regulations. All these startups are winging it, it seems.
- daveFNbuck 5y agoIf we don't have the data science to even know what peoples' distant ancestry is, how do you know it matters for choice of diet?
- bqmjjx0kac 5y agoMaybe your ancestry per se is not so important, but your genotypes can reveal predisposition towards vitamin deficiencies. For example, see https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5801754/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5801754/ > Overall, the data analyzed suggests that ethnic-specific associations are involved in the genetic determination of vitamin B12 concentrations. Disclaimer: I am a biology dilettante
- cltby 5y agoGiven how much time and energy our prestige institutions spend denigrating whites, of course fewer people would adopt the label for themselves.
- h2odragon 5y agoIs anybody proposing we link the legal "racial/ethnicity" measures to DNA yet? Just imagine how much fun the intelligentsia would've had with DNA tests say 150 years or more ago. They thought they had it with phrenology. But of course, we're following the science, and can thus be confident of our lack of error.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt would be fairly weird to have people self-identify in one field and force a genetics-based determination in another.
- pessimizer 5y agoBut once everyone's DNA is on file, imagine the easy time a new government will have after the next great political/cultural change (or the one after that) getting their country in order. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust
- ralusek 5y agoI'm a "white passing" Hispanic. There is no material benefit, ever, from me declaring myself to be white. Applying to job? Applying to school? Always Hispanic. I've even had countless conversations turn around when I'm suddenly allowed to have a particular opinion, or discuss a certain topic, when it is made clear that I am Hispanic. If I were a white person discovering any degree of non-whiteness in my genealogy, I would sure understand the appeal of clinging to it.
- JPKab 5y agoIt's almost as if conferring special privileges and innate knowledge on people because of their group identity is absurd and creates silly incentives.
- scarecrowbob 5y agoYeah, as a person with a diverse racial background from Texas since before it was Texas (relevant cause of the opinion I'm getting to spout), you might be right that there "is no material benefit, ever, from me declaring myself to be white." I personally think race is a wholly made up concept, so it's a bit vexed to add it into how institutions deal with folks. What you're writing made me think about something that's omitted from what you're writing: almost all of the benefits I've had from how folks interpret my race have come from -not- having to say explicitly how my race should be interpreted. So, while I get what you're trying to say, where I live most racism exists in the unspoken assumptions about how people act. As such much of that racial bias is very difficult to point out to people because it's like trying to point out water to fish.
- pessimizer 5y agoYou're white-passing. There's no need to "declare" yourself white, everyone who sees you does it for you. Also there's no contradiction between being Hispanic and white, so I'm assuming that you're saying that you have some ancestors who were here more than 600 years ago.
- bangkoksbest 5y agoDon't Americans split off Hispanic status as a separate question? That's what I've encountered when filling in US forms... There's plenty of white people in Latin America, and race is, if anything, much more rigidly stratifying there than it is even in USA. It's not a coincidence that if you visit Miami, you'd imagine Cubans were a fairly white-dominated population, but if you visited Cuba itself you'd find that's not at all the case.
- NelsonMinar 5y agoReminder that "race" is not at all a well defined concept genetically. Mixing genetic material across regions is the norm for humanity, not the exception. https://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2017/science-genetics-reshaping-race-debate-21st-century/ https://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2017/science-genetics-res... "Race" as a social concept is still meaningful and I'm glad the US census measures people's self-identified racial categories. But it's a complicated topic.
- kome 5y agothis is so american and pointless... human races are not a biological thing, stop trying to make it happen. the U.S. is SO obsessed with race.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't turn a race war into a nationalistic one. That's not the direction we need to be going here! https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kome 5y agowhere i made nationalistic claims? i said that the racialist obsession in the US is a strong cultural trait, but it's completely unscientific
- dang 5y agoIt's not a matter of "claims", it's about internet rhetoric, name-calling, etc. If you're posting trashy pejoratives about countries, that's nationalistic flamebait. Please don't do this kind of thing on HN: > "this is so american and pointless" "the U.S. is SO obsessed with race" - actually, please don't do it regardless of the topic is. We want substantive comments and thoughtful conversation. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- carbocation 5y agoGenetic ancestry is not race.
- kizer 5y agoFor the 2030 census race shouldn’t even be a question. You won’t get any actionable data.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]