2 ms·
That study wasn't about finding all the cases that originated from the rally. That was just proving that in fact, people who never attended the rally got sick w
by dragontamer 5y ago
That study wasn't about finding all the cases that originated from the rally. That was just proving that in fact, people who never attended the rally got sick with the same genomic-markers as the COVID19 present at the rally.
Which means that the "spread" of COVID19 from Sturgis -> Minnesota cannot be denied.
-------
http://ftp.iza.org/dp13670.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp13670.pdf
Page 60 (Appendix 5) shows a nice graph showing the "trendline" of COVID19 cases ("synthetic Meade county"), vs Actual Meade county.
We can see that COVID19 cases spiked pretty hard after the Sturgis rally. Now maybe there was some "other" superspreading event happening in that area at the same time... but Occam's Razor points to the giant 400,000+ person motorcycle rally without any mask precautions going on.
---------
> That's a drop in the bucket compared to the community spread in the US in 2020.
But you're right on this front. I think the poster earlier is overstating Sturgis's importance. Sturgis is just one event, there were plenty of others with far bigger spread (February 2020 Marti Gras New Orleans, especially because no one took any precautions during that event. It was "before COVID19" was well recognized by the public)
But without a doubt, Sturgis was a superspreading event. But there were _many_ superspreading events happening all over the place, so I personally don't want to put too much importance on Sturgis alone. The fact remains that many other events continued to take place, as that region didn't want to take precautions against COVID19 in general.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've read through the study pretty carefully, and it does appear to have tried to be comprehensive. Specifically: All confirmed cases among Minnesota residents were reported to MDH. MDH or local public health department staff members interviewed patients with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection to identify exposures and persons who might have been in contact with patients during their infectious period (2 days before through 10 days after symptom onset).* To assess exposures, interviews included questions about travel and being in specific settings, such as bars or restaurants, schools, health care facilities, or events or social gatherings in the 14 days before symptom onset. During August–September 2020, MDH and local health department staff members interviewed >80% of patients with a confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection. If the survey missed cases, it wasn't for lack of trying. That's not to say it didn't miss some. (Keep in mind I'm the person who'd suggested the relationship above.)